Censorship in the British theatre is hardly a neglected topic, yet Theatre Censorship: From Walpole to Wilson approaches the subject from a novel perspective by focusing primarily on the statutory history of censorship. As a result, the book becomes largely a history of the repeated efforts to circumvent and overturn the system of censorship that was established by the 1737 Licensing Act. Authors David Thomas, David Carlton, and Anne Etienne spend very little time examining the effects of these laws upon the British theatre (terrain that has been well covered by other scholars), choosing instead to uncover and explicate the reasons why it took so long for British law to extend the same freedom of expression to the stage that had long been enjoyed by other arts.
The book's first chapter provides a brief overview of the Lord Chamberlain's censorship powers, exercised primarily by the Master of the Revels, prior to the Walpole administration in the early eighteenth century. As the authors discuss, the goal of having the Master of the Revels evaluate each text before it was performed was less about maintaining ideological control over the productions and more about upholding high production standards. They argue that the relationship between the Master of the Revels and the theatre managers, especially before the Interregnum, was highly amicable and not a little bit symbiotic. The Master of the Revels was paid only for plays that were successfully licensed, and the theatre managers in turn enjoyed the protection of the Crown in their ongoing conflicts with the Puritan-controlled Common Council of London. This relationship would, of course, evolve over the century and a half between the reign of Elizabeth I and the Walpole administration, with the influence of the Lord Chamberlain's office waning by the early eighteenth century.
The second chapter covers an enormous amount of terrain (1737–1892) but focuses primarily on activity relating to the enactment of the 1737 Licensing Act and the 1843 Theatres Act. With this chapter, the authors begin to develop their systematic method for discussing the events of each period: carefully laying out the political and theatrical background of each historical moment in preparation for an in-depth discussion of the development and impact of each statute (or the unsuccessful challenge thereof). This practice is used to great effect, and it allows the authors to communicate fully the highly intricate circumstances in which each censorship effort occurs.
The third chapter details the extensive campaign led by George Bernard Shaw and Harley Granville Barker to repeal censorship in the first decade of the twentieth century. As the authors point out, this was a large-scale effort that was led primarily by the playwrights, whose Ibsen-influenced work was being systematically repressed by the Lord Chamberlain's Office. The timing, however, was dismal; the endeavor was completely overshadowed by Prime Minister David Lloyd George's efforts to liberalize the British government. It is in the process of depicting the events of this period that the authors' archival research proves most effective. By revealing the interoffice and interpersonal communications of figures such as the prime minister, the Home Secretary, and the Lord Chamberlain, the authors reveal that, although officials such as the prime minister and the Home Secretary felt that the system of theatrical censorship was antiquated and in great need of reform, they chose to embark on a policy of “deliberate inertia” (140) so as to avoid a politically contentious issue while attempting to navigate other controversial legislation through Parliament. The authors skillfully demonstrate how the government used petty divisions within the theatre industry and confusion regarding the role of Royal Prerogative as stalling tactics, deftly punting the issue down through the generations until reform was successfully passed in 1968 during the Wilson administration. Chapters 4–7 continue to track the progress of statutory theatre regulation and the attempts to reform it through the decades leading up to the Theatres Act of 1968; this lucid and insightful section brims with fascinating revelations from their archival work.
The book's eighth and final chapter discusses efforts undertaken by a variety of figures to exert prohibitive controls on the theatre in the era since the passage of the 1968 Theatres Act. As part of their research for this chapter, the authors circulated a questionnaire to 454 theatre organizations throughout Britain in an attempt to gauge the extent of ongoing censorship (both official and unofficial) through the modern era. The authors' report of their findings from this questionnaire are necessarily diffuse, yet still quite interesting, and the chapter's ending offers an intriguing discussion of the new forms of social control that have arisen in the past decade.
Cowritten books are uncommon in theatre studies, and Theatre Censorship is an excellent example of just how productive an interdisciplinary collaboration can be. As stated in the book's introduction, the project team was directed by David Thomas, who also served as the primary author for the first two chapters; David Carlton “took primary responsibility for researching and writing the sections on the political background of each major period” (3), and Anne Etienne carried out the extensive “archival and empirical research” (4) that provided this study with so many of its most stunning revelations. Overall, Theatre Censorship: From Walpole to Wilson is a highly commendable piece of scholarship that should appeal not only to scholars of British theatre but also to anyone concerned with the evolving relationship between public policy and the arts.
