It has been almost twenty years since Nelson Mandela became South Africa's first democratically elected president and began the country's process of redefinition. Since then, South Africa has proclaimed itself a ‘rainbow nation’ in an attempt to mark its progress. Yvette Hutchison's South African Performance and Archives of Memory reflects on this anniversary and examines the role of memory in performances of national identity and history. Hutchison takes the notion of the ‘rainbow nation’ to task and asks what alternative memories can be imagined and articulated when less official performance repertoires are highlighted. She maintains that live performance, in its representation of multiple experiences simultaneously and open-ended questioning, might be an equitable way to remember the past and construct a dialogic, inclusive present and future. Hutchison takes the country's Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) as her starting point, examining the tension between official and unofficial memories in the commission's selection process for stories to be heard and broadcast internationally. Following this, she analyses performances responding to the iconic event that engage divergent, marginalized histories.
Many scholars have investigated memory in post-apartheid South Africa, especially in the TRC, as a dynamic, contested site of identity formation and belonging on individual and international levels. Similarly, many have theorized relationships between archive and repertoire and sanctioned or forgotten memories and histories. To this conversation Hutchison contributes a sweeping comparative catalogue on South Africa's use of texts and performances to build national identity at critical historical junctures. The book ranges from a discussion of the 1910 South African Pageant of Union, which narrated the country as a unified, independent nation, to the construction of the Voortrekker Monument in honor of the journey of Afrikaners from Cape Town to Pretoria, and the monument's subsequent reinterpretation post-apartheid. Hutchison inventively traces Thabo Mbeki's African Renaissance, including a discussion of a touring set of historical documents called the South African–Mali Timbuktu Manuscript Project. The book concludes with a series of contemporary theatrical performances that centre on memory, nostalgia, ghosts and dreaming.
South African Performance and Archives of Memory productively indexes the similarities and differences among national memory projects and the use of performance to define South Africa in relation to other African nations – two important areas of research. Given its expansive case studies, Hutchison's argument occasionally fails to flesh out her insights regarding memory's impact on nationality, gender, ethnicity and individual agency in post-apartheid South Africa. A more detailed definition of embodiment and performance in connection with archives and repertoires would help to detail the ways in which performance can disrupt official histories while also producing its own selective, hierarchical narratives. An analysis of the paradigms of power at work in every level of history-making would further link Hutchison's case studies to her conclusion that, imperfect as they are, archive and repertoire must remain in constant dialogue for the equitable production of historical narratives.
