This book is the result of a group project conducted under the auspices of the Jerusalem Institute for Israel Studies and was produced by that organization and the publisher Palgrave. The group of distinguished researchers, all Israeli academics, began meeting in 2003 on a regular basis to discuss and exchange ideas.
The central thesis of the book is given in the subtitle, “From Conflict Resolution to Conflict Management.” The scholars recognized the change as they studied the conflict between the years 2000 and 2005. The book convincingly describes the transition from the pursuit of conflict resolution to conflict management during this period of time. The failure of the Oslo process and other peace-seeking initiatives led to the violent clashes that erupted between Israel and the Palestinians beginning with the al-Aqsa intifada in September 2000. The clashes developed into a protracted low-intensity confrontation. “The confrontation exacted a heavy human toll on both sides, inflicted severe economic damage, and raised the level of mutual enmity and mistrust to levels that are hampering dialogue” (p. 1). There seems to be no political or military solution to the present situation. Hence, we see the shift in policy from attempting to resolve the conflict to Israel's attempt to manage the ongoing situation. The book discusses the causes of the confrontation, each side's perceptions and goals, traits of the confrontation as a low-intensity conflict, the impact on both societies, the reasons for the failure of efforts to terminate or moderate the conflict, and the phenomenon of unilateral disengagement as a unique strategy of conflict management.
The editor, Yaacov Bar-Siman-Tov, is a professor of international relations and holds the Chair for the Study of Peace and Regional Cooperation at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. He also serves as head of the Swiss Center for Conflict Research, Management, and Resolution at Hebrew University. He has written or edited ten books and numerous articles on topics related to conflict management and resolution, particularly concerning the Israeli–Arab conflict. Other contributors are professors and researchers at Tel Aviv University and other universities in Israel with specialties in political psychology, Middle Eastern affairs, democracy studies, conflict studies, social psychology and cognitive psychology. There were twelve discussants, seven of whom authored or coauthored chapters on various aspects of the conflict—topics that emerged from the group discussions. The anthology integrates the essays of the analysts who represent diverse approaches and disciplines.
The first chapter sets the stage with a discussion on the dialectic between conflict management and conflict resolution followed by an essay on the influences of heuristic thought and group dynamics. According to Bar-Siman-Tov, there are three types of conflict management: unilateral, joint, and external. Israel is currently using unilateral management strategies regarding the conflict. Other chapters in the book cover the topics of the interaction between the military and the political leaders in Israel, changes in Israel's official security policy, attitudes among the Jewish public, the role of the media during violent confrontation, Palestinian society especially after Arafat's death, and the Israel disengagement plan as a conflict-management strategy.
There are some interesting points made in the book: the media in Israel has an influence on public opinion and usually conveys official messages, but there is not full agreement between the Israeli public and the national leadership and there are some opposition voices in the media; the Israeli media operates in an ethos of conflict; Israel tries to delegitimize the Palestinians and considers itself as victimized; the Israeli psychological repertoire is based on the ethos of conflict, collective memory, and a collective emotional orientation of fear; the Palestinian armed struggle remains an important value in the eyes of that society that has united armed elements in the nationalist and Islamist camps alike; there is tension between Israeli political leaders and military leaders as to who makes decisions, especially when the leadership changes; many older Palestinians are more moderate while the young activists want armed confrontation; Palestinians are fragmented but have a common agenda of liberation from the occupation and political independence; with the political process having collapsed, the resulting violence must be managed; the dialectic between the two processes of conflict management and resolution is complicated; and unilateral conflict management results in an escalation of violence that in turn perpetuates despair with no hope of joint management or resolution. Each group (Israelis and Palestinians) has its own history, resources, psychology, and societal structure that defines their group beliefs and actions, so any resolution will require changes in attitudes, media reporting, goals, and power structures.
Common themes run through the essays, resulting in some repetition. One major topic is that because the increased violence has resulted in an intractable situation, Israel has unilaterally closed some settlements and disengaged in order to manage the confrontation. The last chapter explains this in detail and would be helpful to readers if it were presented earlier in the book. The book is technical and in some parts quite philosophical, which, without a good background in the topics, could cause difficulty in full comprehension. The essays probe the conflict using theoretical, historical, and psychological methods. It provides a profound explanation of the years between 2000 and 2005 that resulted in the current situation. A perceived problem from the Israeli side is that there is no one in the opposition with whom to deal. Arafat was considered an unfit partner for negotiation, and after his death, Palestinian infighting and the destruction of the Palestinian Authority created a troublesome condition. One of the entities in the conflict is a state while the other is a nonstate with a large number of nonunitary subactors, making negotiations difficult and perplexing. There is mistrust on both sides and each wants peace on its own terms, making a political solution difficult if not impossible. Therefore, one side has resorted to violence, and the other has used a military response. Palestinians feel that negotiations are not worthwhile, so they have resorted to violence to try to reach their goals, while Israel has responded with military force. However, to reduce casualties, Israel has recently employed disengagement tactics and the conflict has reached a stalemate.
Publishing books about the Arab or Palestinian–Israeli conflict is a popular activity in recent years. Books include a variety of approaches and relevant topics such as causes, challenges, history, reconciliation, the peace process, narratives from both sides, and so forth. This book on the conflict is a unique approach, as it discusses the fact that because resolution does not seem possible, Israel has moved to managing the conflict rather than trying to resolve it. Some of the material in it overlaps with other studies, but for the most part it contains new material. It is written for those with some background in the history and politics of the Middle East. Professors who teach Middle East studies would find it very useful as would anyone interested in conflict resolution.
As there are a variety of authors, the writing styles vary from one chapter to the next, making some more readable than others because of the technical aspects. However, all provide valuable insights that relate to the study and major thesis. Each chapter is well documented with extensive notes and references. However, there is no general bibliography, and the index is quite sparse. Although much of the book is about the Israeli reaction, the presentation is quite objective, giving information about both sides. The book is recommended for those interested in the Israeli–Palestinian conflict, the current state of Israeli–Palestinian relations, and the prospect of a continued peace process. It provides vital insight as to why the situation is at a stalemate, and understanding this is a key to progress.
