The author's subject, and a good one, is the Banaras Hindu University from its foundation in 1915-the bill setting it up was passed 1 October - till Indian independence, seen as its golden years. At a time of debate in Britain today over the virtue of faith schools this study of a faith university has a real topicality.
All the expectations of those who campaigned for such a university were in many respects to be belied. The British broke a tradition of a purely secular education, post-Mutiny, in the hope that a religious based institution would curb the seditious outlook of Indian students. They brought the Indian princes on side to strengthen their cause. The university still went on to become a stronghold of Indian nationalism. Annie Besant's Central Hindu College, set up in 1899, was the core of the University to be but she had hoped it would be a university of all the Indian religions only to be disappointed with its being a narrowly Hindu foundation. Pandit Malaviya is the key figure. His vision was of the university making a significant contribution to a Hindu renaissance if in a context of a western-style education. In fact the so-called modern subjects, and above all engineering, proved far more prestigious than the indological.
This was no easy piece of research for the author. She battled to gain access to the university records. She had to weather student protest on campus in the 90s. Even more demandingly, as she puts it, “to make progress in my research I had to progress spiritually” (p. xii). She successfully tracked down former students and their interviews, such as for example with the communist Rustam Saitin, suggest how liberal a ‘civic sphere’ the university indeed became. She faces the perennial problems of all historians contextualising a specific theme within the history of Empire and nationalism with some adroitness but her accounts of the parallel history of the setting up of the Aligarh Muslim University in 1920 and then Gandhi's own version of a Hindu education, both in his Kashi Vidyapith, the Congress party's alternative university to the BHU during the non-cooperation movement 1920–22 and in his ashrams, does lead to some loss of focus. Incidentally Gandhi comes out very poorly from the comparison, seemingly both Luddite and philistine: “Gandhi's ideas of education do not correspond with the common definition of education” (p. 113). I wonder why she left out any account of that famous speech by Gandhi at the inauguration of the University? It might have been more informative in terms of contextualisation had she followed up on her insight that the University was part of the Hindu religious reform movements, not really addressed in the text, and possibly made a backward glance at the Sanskrit colleges in nineteenth-century Calcutta and Banares.
So in what sense was this a faith institution? So much hinged on Pandit Malaviya, born 25 December 1861, son of a Brahman reciter of puranic texts, “a small, soft-spoken man of delicate features”, “instinct with intellectuality”. Early on he had a reputation as pro-Brahmin and anti-Muslim, taking up such communal causes as Hindi and cow protection, and that is the question really being explored in the book: did he pursue a communal agenda? His first educational venture had been the setting up of a Hindu boarding house at Muir College, Allahabad. To proceed with plans for the BHU he had to abandon plans for Hindi as the medium of instruction and settle for English. (One of Gandhi's complaints against the ‘satanic’ BHU.) The architecture of the University was strikingly Hindu with many temple features to the buildings (though they only acquired their Birla temple after independence) and all in a reddish and yellowish brown, symbolic of renunciation. Many trees were planted to suggest a forest hermitage. Malaviya became Vice-Chancellor on 30 November 1919 (and was only replaced by Radhakrishnan in 1939) and set about putting his stamp on its curriculum. The College of Theology, exclusively for Brahmins, was to be its leading department. All students had to study Hinduism - Mrs Besant's textbooks the means - and Malaviya gave Sunday lectures on the Gita. Professors were looked on as gurus. But Renold tellingly describes how none of this really defined the University. A strict attendance was not enforced and examinations in Hinduism were very easy. If part of the sacred geography of Benares the University was characterised, as she puts it, by ‘a loose and flexible Hinduness’, the Hindu renaissance subjects did not really take off, and ‘a specifically Hindu ideology did not dominate the intellectual life of the campus’ (p. 179). Indeed there was far more of a cosmopolitan outlook. So what was the true thrust of the institution?
This was India's first university entirely run by Indians. It was never a large body, by 1937 1,782 students were on campus, a further 420 in lodgings in the city, rising to 4,000 by 1946. The majority were poor brahmans from UP and Bihar together with a small number of women. But it was an inclusive student body, with no segregation along lines of wealth, caste or community. The most popular courses were in the Faculty of Arts. above all, English. This was a highly idealist community, with a dedication to service uppermost, “almost a religion unto itself ” (p. 204). (The ideal of service is at the heart of the religious reform movements.) And here Malaviya's wearing another hat as a leading Congress figure, if a Moderate, was critical; the campus was passionately nationalist. Malaviya, however, never broke off contact with the government and for Gandhi its government grant was its most damning feature. (Malaviya replied, “one should accept nectar even if it comes out of poison”.) Student protest was at its fiercest during the Quit India satyagraha of 1942 and but for Radhakrishnan's skilful intervention the military occupation of the campus could have led to its permament closure. Nationalism is seen as the defining feature of BHU.
So in this account the University is exonerated from any taint of Hindu communalism. The RSS may have played a small part in physical education but otherwise was of little influence. I liked her final judgement on the University: ‘there was nothing malevolent in its character’ (p. 218). But at the very end she suggests that such Hindu identity as it had acquired “provided a basis for the politicising of religion and the rise of Hindu nationalism” (p. 220). One very much hopes the author will take her story of this rich and intriguing institution forward.
