Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-tnkh4 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-18T07:18:36.703Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

A Question of Respect: A Qualitative Text Analysis of the Canadian Parliamentary Committee Hearings on The Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  18 December 2017

Genevieve Fuji Johnson*
Affiliation:
Simon Fraser University
Mary Burns*
Affiliation:
Simon Fraser University
Kerry Porth*
Affiliation:
Independent researcher
*
Department of Political Science, Simon Fraser University, AQ6069 - 8888 University Drive, Burnaby BC, V5A 1S6, email: genevieve_johnson@sfu.ca
Department of Political Science, Simon Fraser University, AQ6069 - 8888 University Drive, Burnaby BC, V5A 1S6, email: meburns@sfu.ca
Independent Sex Worker Rights Educator, Researcher, and Writer, C/O Department of Political Science, Simon Fraser University, AQ6069 - 8888 University Drive, Burnaby BC, V5A 1S6, email: kerrylporth@gmail.com
Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Abstract

We evaluate the Canadian parliamentary hearings on The Protection of Communities and Exploited Persons Act to determine whether respectful and fair deliberation occurred. Our focus is on the content, tone, and nature of each question posed by committee members in hearings in both chambers. We find that, on the whole, the vast majority of questions met this baseline but that committee members were biased toward witnesses in agreement with their position and against witnesses in opposition to it. In addition to our substantive findings, we contribute methodological insights, including a coding scheme, for this kind of qualitative text analysis.

Résumé

Nous évaluons les audiences parlementaires canadiennes relatives à la Loi sur la protection des collectivités et des personnes victimes d’exploitation afin de déterminer si elles ont donné lieu à des délibérations respectueuses et justes. Nous portons notre attention sur le contenu, le ton et la nature de chacune des questions posées par les membres des comités lors des audiences tenues dans les deux Chambres. Nous constatons, dans l’ensemble, que la grande majorité des questions ont satisfait à ces conditions de base, mais que les membres des comités manifestaient une certaine partialité à l’égard des témoins qui étaient en accord avec leur position et à l’encontre des témoins qui y étaient opposés. À côté de nos constatations substantielles, nous apportons des indications d’ordre méthodologique, y compris un schéma de codage pour ce genre d’analyse de texte qualitative.

Information

Type
Research Article
Copyright
Copyright © Canadian Political Science Association (l'Association canadienne de science politique) and/et la Société québécoise de science politique 2017 
Figure 0

Table 1aStanding Committee on Justice and Human Rights—Summary by Pro and Con Witnesses

Figure 1

Table 1bStanding Committee on Justice and Human Rights—Summary by Pro and Con Briefs Submitted

Figure 2

Table 1cStanding Committee on Justice and Human Rights—Briefs and Witnesses

Figure 3

Table 2aStanding Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs—Summary by Pro and Con Witnesses

Figure 4

Table 2bStanding Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs—Summary by Pro and Con Briefs Submitted

Figure 5

Table 2cStanding Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs—Briefs and Witnesses

Figure 6

Table 3Inter-coder Reliability (between 2016 coders)

Figure 7

Table 4Inter-Transcript Reliability (between 2014 and 2016 rounds of coding)

Figure 8

Figure 1The distribution of questions addressed to pro and con witnesses for each party

Figure 9

Table 5Total Questions by Party and Witness

Figure 10

Figure 2The distribution, measured in terms of percentage (%), of disrespectful and respectful questions addressed to con and pro witnesses by each party

Figure 11

Table 6Content–Total Questions by Party and Witness

Figure 12

Figure 3The distribution, measured in terms of percentage (%), of negative, neutral and positive questions addressed to con and pro witnesses by each party

Figure 13

Table 7Tone: Total Questions by Party and Witness

Figure 14

Figure 4The distribution, measured in terms of percentage (%), of combative, fair, and sympathetic questions addressed to con and pro witnesses by each party

Figure 15

Table 8Nature: Total Questions by Party and Witness

Figure 16

Table 1Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights Con Witnesses

Figure 17

Table 2Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights Pro Witnesses

Figure 18

Table 3Standing Senate Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs Con Witnesses

Figure 19

Table 4Senate Standing Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs Pro Witnesses

Figure 20

Table 5Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights Con Briefs

Figure 21

Table 6Standing Committee on Justice and Human Rights Pro Briefs

Figure 22

Table 7Senate Standing Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs Con Briefs

Figure 23

Table 8Senate Standing Committee on Legal and Constitutional Affairs Pro Briefs