Between them, Irene Hardill and Susan Baines have a healthy track record of empirical research into different aspects of unpaid voluntary action. This book, which brings together the findings from their work to address some of the key questions raised by the Big Society, is therefore timely. Focusing on organised and formal volunteering for social welfare, it explores unpaid voluntary action from an individual, organisational and community perspective, embedding it within its community and (mainly) voluntary sector context. Its exploration is informed by theoretical perspectives from the sociology of work, the feminist sociology of care and concepts of enterprise. This allows the authors to contrast what they see as an increasingly instrumental approach to voluntary action in policy with a more rounded understanding of the role it plays in the lives of individuals, communities and society.
While they provide us with useful statistical information, Hardill and Baines are not concerned here with enumerating and classifying volunteering and assessing volunteer motives. They adopt a more holistic approach that considers ‘the ways in which actions, choices and constraints for individuals are embedded in household, kinship and friendship networks, as well as organisations and communities’ (p. 150). For this they use the total social organisation of labour (TSOL) framework, which places unpaid voluntary action in a broader spectrum and understanding of ‘work’. They suggest that as voluntary and community organisations are increasingly seen by government policy as labour market intermediaries, agents for public services and social partners (e.g. in regeneration), this has led to an instrumental and increasingly managerial approach which excludes other logics and neglects other values involved in unpaid voluntary action. In particular, they are critical of a focus on unpaid voluntary action as a preparation for the labour market and engagement in the formal economy, seeing this as an individualist approach which undervalues the care ethic and collective approaches to caring citizenship.
The book draws on research studies carried out between 2002 and 2010. After introducing the structure and theoretical grounding for their research, the authors explore unpaid voluntary action first from the perspective of the journeys of individual volunteers and questions of motivation. They then place it in an organisational context, first examining the extent to which voluntary action has been professionalised through paid volunteer management posts and then how it has been shaped by the increase of contracting arrangements between VCOs and the state and an increasing emphasis on enterprise. A further chapter then places unpaid voluntary action within a community context, exploring the collective ethic of care in which it is embedded, first focusing on locality and then on communities of interest. A final chapter considers how unpaid voluntary action will fare in the context of the Big Society and fiscal austerity.
Books like this, that bring together linked research projects over a number of years within a coherent theoretical context, are a valuable resource. Hardill and Baines provide the reader with a range of different ways to think about volunteering. Reading from cover to cover, however, I was not always convinced that the book held together as well as intended. The focus, for example, seemed to shift between volunteering, the voluntary and community sector and voluntary action. I also wondered whether in its thoroughness, the book tried to cover too much. Passing references to the devolved administrations, a section on co-operatives, plus one towards the end on participatory research, for example, whet the appetite but there is not room to follow them up in more detail.
On the other hand, I would have liked to have seen more recognition of the long-term nature of some of the debates the book raises. While the authors may be justified in highlighting the prominence that voluntary action has been given in the Big Society and before it under New Labour, the promotion of volunteering was an attractive proposition for politicians way before New Labour came to power. There is passing reference to research and debate on volunteering in the 1990s, for example (and more on community policy), but debates at that time and before prefigure some of the issues raised here – about the relationship between volunteering and work, for example, the impact of the ‘contract culture’ or the relation between citizen and state. In view of this, I would have also liked some crystal ball gazing at the end about how these debates might develop in the future.
This may be a reflection of the length of time I have been around in this field. For those who have come more to it more recently and in areas with which I was less familiar, Hardill and Baines provide important context and always embed their empirical work in very helpful summaries of the literature – I found those on the Big Society debate, and on social enterprise particularly helpful.
There are some editing errors and the very brief section on useful websites has some surprising omissions, but these are quibbles. Generally speaking, this book, from authors who know their field very well, is a valuable resource, giving this reader, at least, a fresh sense of the complexity of unpaid voluntary action, a good sense of the reality on the ground and a range of useful ways to understand it.
