As the centennial of the First World War rapidly approaches, there has been a not-unexpected flurry of books relating to the outbreak and conduct of the Great War. Often overshadowed by its much more destructive sequel, the First World War is reemerging from the historiographical shadows. Historians know that it has an importance beyond just setting the stage for the destruction of 1939–1945, but its significance often seems to recede as new studies of later events, such as the Cold War, dominate publishers’ catalogs and the CVs of new scholars. The centennial anniversary of the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand and the destruction that soon followed is, however, refocusing historians on the upheaval that destroyed so many lives and so much property, ended several empires, and helped propel other nations into greater roles on the world stage.
One notable recent entry in this discussion is Wiley-Blackwell's new addition to its “Companion” series, A Companion to World War I, edited by John Horne, professor of modern European history at Trinity College, Dublin. Horne has done a wonderful job in collecting and correlating more than three dozen essays on the First World War. A Companion is broken into five parts beginning with, naturally, the setting for the war. Historians can easily get bogged down in the various plans and diplomatic maneuverings of the summer of 1914. Instead, Gerd Krumeich discusses the outbreak of the war in the light of how, even before Franz Ferdinand made his trip to Bosnia, the different European powers imagined how a European war would look and how it would be fought. Krumeich reviews the growth of “international antagonism and the polarization of the European alliance system” (3) and the increasing tendency of the European states to see a future conflict as inevitable, and, for some, even desirable. John F.V. Keiger follows with an essay on how the causes of the war have been interpreted over the past century and includes the ever-popular “war guilt” question. These first two chapters thus nicely set the tone for the rest of the work, establishing the necessary background for students and acting as a thoughtful refresher for more experienced scholars.
The second section's chapters each cover a different front of the war. The first provides an explanation of the overall command, strategy, and tactics. The subsequent eight chapters cover the war in the west from 1914 to 1916, the Eastern and Balkan fronts, the fronts in Italy and Africa, and the Turk's war. The section finishes with the Western Front in 1917–18 and war in the air and on the seas. Combined, they provide a succinct, well-written, and thoughtful overview of the military history of the war, general enough to serve as a good summary for a class. The Western Front is the only one that gets two chapters instead of one, but arguably the war was decided on this front. There is no discussion of the war in Asia. Although it was such a minor front in the war that its absence is only noticeable because of the completeness of the rest of the material, a chapter on Japan would have been a welcome addition. The individual authors relate the material they are covering to the war as a whole, but a separate chapter concentrating on the belligerents’ wider strategies would have been a helpful addition. Fortunately, A Companion does include maps, which are generally well-done, although a few more would have been useful.
The third part, “Faces of War,” covers a wide spectrum of topics, from the role of women, non-combatants, public opinion, medicine, science, and technology, as well as the war as depicted on film and its effect on the visual arts. This section is simultaneously a bit of a hodge-podge as well as at times the most interesting part of the book. This segment is the one that might sometimes be overlooked in the classroom but may well have the chapters of most interest to individual students. For example, Sophie Delaporte's chapter on military medicine recalls the psychological traumas inflicted on so many of the veterans. Only eleven pages long, it proves a quick summary, which invites additional reading. That is not always an easy balance to achieve.
The fourth section's eleven chapters are dedicated to the major combatants and their respective empires. Hamit Bozarslan's chapter on the Ottoman Empire is particularly interesting. Already in political turmoil well before the war started, the Ottomans had lost territory in North Africa and the Balkans in a series of small wars before entering a much larger war that would, in the end, destroy Ottoman rule and leave Turkey in its place. Bits and pieces of this part of the war are familiar to most American historians: the Armenian genocide, the Gallipoli campaign, and the Arab revolt, the latter if only through watching Lawrence of Arabia. Bozarslan puts it all into the proper wider context.
The last segment, “Legacies,” covers the peace treaties and their aftermath, the continuing conflicts immediately after the war, and finally, how the war was remembered until it was eclipsed by the Second World War, as well as how the dead were mourned. Smaller wars and revolutions, some of them quite large in their own right, continued after the eleventh hour of the eleventh day of the eleventh month in 1918. They were as much a legacy of the war as were the various treaties that were hammered out, revised, and then abandoned. Lawrence Van Ypersele's concluding chapter on “Mourning and Memory, 1919–1945,” examines how different groups in Europe remembered the war and how that memory changed over time. It is an appropriate coda to the book.
A Companion to World War One is suitable for upper division or graduate classes. Every chapter is well-written and argued, and each includes a short list of sources for further reading. An extensive bibliography is also included. Overall, the lists of subjects covered are thorough, but not exhaustive, assuming such completeness were possible. Surprisingly, there is no chapter on the intelligence war. Berlin, London, and, to a lesser extent, Vienna, were heavily invested in espionage in neutral nations, and the Central Powers encouraged revolution and sabotage in places as separate as India and the United States. There is more to the intelligence war than the Zimmermann Telegram, and this should be better reflected in this fine compilation. The selection of authors is impressive. Horne gathered a wide grouping of experienced historians from the United States, Canada, Australia, and Europe. In some cases this volume provides an opportunity to read the work of scholars who do not normally publish in English. In short, A Companion to World War One is well-written and well-organized, suitable for students as well as for other scholars. It is highly recommended.
