Growing up as an Iranian-American in California, Pardis Mahdavi's imagined Iran “included only women clad in black chadors wailing and whipping themselves, and black-bearded men with heavy hearts and souls” (p. 2). Passionate Uprisings: Iran's Sexual Revolution begins with Mahdavi's account of her arrival to Tehran's airport for the first time in 2000. She describes her horror at losing her headscarf to the wind and having to chase it down the runway while being yelled at by an angry man who, with eyes averted from her uncovered head, asks, “What are you doing, sister?” Mahdavi finds in Iran a society and state hostile to women and repressive of the faintest hint of sexuality. But over the course of her three summer research visits, she also discovers a side of Iran wherein young people style up and engage in illicit sexual acts as a form of political critique of the Islamic Republic's official culture. She labels this phenomenon Iran's “sexual revolution.” With the help of her “informants”—“key players” in this revolution (p. 40)—Mahdavi guides the reader through an exposé of sex Iranian-style, with youth engaged in flirting, heavy-petting parties, and group sex orgies, always on the run from the omnipresent morality police. Throughout the book, she relates stories people have told her: sex in back seats, hymen reconstructions and brutal abortions, a female passenger paying for her cheap taxi ride by letting the driver finger her vagina, and wives’ habitual betrayals of their husbands. Her descriptions are accompanied by photographs of average Iranians engaged in everyday life, which are subtitled with headings such as “The look of the sexual revolution: A woman applying makeup and smoking a cigarette in a public park” (p. 121).
Mahdavi's account of life in Iran is problematic in that it inaccurately describes and exaggerates both the repression and limitations that exist as well as the social and sexual acts that Iranian youth engage in as part of their “self-proclaimed social movement” (p. 107). Tremendous repression certainly exists both in the public and private spheres, but Mahdavi takes already harsh conditions and turns them into cartoon-like clichés. For example, she describes one incident in which she and her male friend are stopped by the morality police, and to escape trouble she claims to be his wife. Mahdavi concludes, “If we hadn't said that, we would have immediately been arrested and forced to get married” (p. 212). In reality, the couple would have had to show proof of marriage. Failing to do so, and depending on the circumstances of their arrest, they would have had to sign a promise of repentance, pay a fine, or receive lashings. Mahdavi also draws on her informants’ experiences to repeatedly assert that birth control pills and condoms are too expensive or too difficult to purchase in Tehran. As a matter of fact, due to the country's progressive population-control policies (which she even describes in a different part of her book!), the pill is sold over the counter, and a monthly dose costs less than one dollar. And surely one can anonymously purchase condoms and pills in a city of twelve to fourteen million people. Likewise, in her brief section on being a woman in Iran, Mahdavi describes men pinching her legs “black and blue” in the bazaar, bank tellers declining to serve her because she is a woman, and one bookseller refusing to sell her books and ordering her to “go home and cook something for your family” (p. 71). The bazaar can of course be an unpleasant place for a woman, but its conservative merchants have an interest in maintaining a safe atmosphere for the majority-female customers. In my eight years of visiting the bazaar, I have not been pinched once. Similarly, there are millions of female bank-account holders and thousands of female bank tellers in Iran, and with women accounting for about 63 percent of Iran's university students, booksellers are by now accustomed to women buying books.
By the same token, Mahdavi's descriptions of fervent sexual activity at most of the parties she attends are unrealistic. It is not that Tehran does not believe in love; it has dating, partying, cheating, adultery, and sex like everywhere else. But also like everywhere else, most Iranians have certain standards of propriety and do not engage in heavy petting in public. In addition, considering the brevity of her research in Iran, it is peculiar that Mahdavi was able to practically stumble upon scenes of group sex orgies, such as the one involving forty naked men and women in an empty swimming pool. Perhaps Mahdavi's research topic predisposed her to encounter such extraordinary situations, but claiming that certain factors had “combined to popularize group sex as a phenomenon” (p. 180) in Iran is simply not true. The dozen or so journalist colleagues I have questioned and I have never been to or—with one exception—even heard rumors of group sex orgies in Iran.
Mahdavi's many exaggerations tarnish valuable parts of her book—for example, her insightful portrayals of Iran's health service providers and triangular clinics, as well as her animated descriptions of her informants’ lives—and cast a shadow of incredibility over her work. This leads to a central question not just about her text but also about observational work in general: how can authors preserve their informants’ confidentiality and simultaneously secure trust in their accounts? More description and detail as well as references would certainly help alleviate this paradox. For example, in one of her first journal entries, Mahdavi describes a scene she encountered on 1 June 2007, in which a woman being accosted by the morality police got into a rage, climbed on the hood of a car, and started screaming and taking off her clothes, “first her hejab and manto and then her shirt, bra, and belt” (p. 6). Mahdavi states the scene was covered in the “morning papers” but fails to provide reference to even one article. In my own search, I could not find any mention of such an incident in Iran's main newspapers around the time of its alleged occurrence, and there is no mention of it on the Internet. This is surprising in the context of Iran not only because the scene is so extraordinary that it would have provided conversation fodder for months to follow but also because the practice of taking pictures with one's mobile phone is so entrenched that barely any scene goes unrecorded, especially if witnessed by dozens of bystanders, as she reports. In fact, a scene that was the talk of the town in the summer of 2007 happened just two weeks earlier and bears many similarities to Mahdavi's story of the breast-baring woman. Accounts of the scene on the Web describe a scuffle between the morality police and a woman who had removed her headscarf in protest against being treated harshly. Pictures showing a bloody-faced woman encircled by a large crowd, some of whom attacked the morality police in anger (which, according to Mahdavi, occurred in the event she witnessed as well), can still be viewed on the Internet.
Yet the biggest problem with Mahdavi's work is her thesis. She argues that, if not all Iranian youth then at least her “representative” sample of informants (she interviewed over 100 people but largely bases her findings on the accounts of seven individuals) intend their actions—including relationships, public comportment, and style and dress—to be political and within the framework of a “sexual revolution.” To be sure, gender and sexual relations have evolved in Iran over the past decades, as is craftily documented in another recent work, Janet Afary's Sexual Politics in Modern Iran (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2009). However, Mahdavi's repeated assertion that the “youth themselves characterize these behaviors as part of a project of social change” (p. 183) is often forced. She writes about “Iran's sexual revolution” as if it were a clearly delineated, self-conscious political movement with card-holding members. In one part of her book she even states that young people date because “they see the creation of a dating scene as a vital part of the social and sexual revolution” (p. 144), confusing the direction of causality. Other sections in her narrative also stand out. In one scene, two friends take her to a sex orgy in a bathhouse. The party is supposedly hosted by the daughter of a wealthy cleric who—shockingly—is on pilgrimage to Mecca. After about twenty-five minutes and without talking to anyone, the author decides to leave but nevertheless concludes that “young people are carving out a social and sexual space and creating a social movement with the goal of changing the sociopolitical climate” (p. 183). As in other parts of her book, Mahdavi draws a grossly overstated conclusion based on an unusual incident.
Considering the number of times her informants confess to being “a member of the sexual revolution,” it appears they may be responding to her cue and adopting her terminology. For example, after showing her footage of Valentine's Day in Iran, one of her informants exclaims: “We have taken a Western holiday, made it our own, and popularized it. This is living proof of the sexual revolution!” (p. 44). The emergence of this holiday as a phenomenon of Westernized, commercialized global youth culture is uncritically presented as proof of her thesis. Complex changes are indeed taking place, but in Mahdavi's text, the most banal phenomena are exoticized. In a footnote, she even observes that “straight hair is highly desirable in Tehran, where many of the women have naturally curly or wavy hair,” as if women in many other places—including her native California—do not care to have their hair blow-dried.
Unfortunately, inaccuracies and simplifications scar Mahdavi's work on a topic that even without exaggerations could be quite revealing. Dedicated to her thesis of Iran's “sexual revolution,” the author does not even hint at the possibility that some of the behavioral extremes she witnessed in Iran—such as the incessant cheating on partners—are possibly a reflection of moral corruption, as many Iranians themselves lament. This corruption in part arises from the problem of people being policed by mere mortals who claim to enact the will of God as well as the dire economic hardship faced by large numbers of Iranians. Somehow, the famous brothel scandal of Tehran's police chief, General Reza Zarei—a strict proponent of enforcing “morality” on the streets—is missing from her account. He was caught in 2008 with six prostitutes he had asked to line up in front of him and pray naked. Viewed within Mahdavi's framework, General Zarei would surely have to be interpreted as a “key player” in Iran's sexual revolution.
