The title of Mahmood Monshipouri's book provides a clue to one of the central dilemmas the author faced when framing this valuable contribution: is this a work about political Islam (i.e., Islamist activism), or is it about the broader set of political issues faced by Muslims today? Ultimately, the book tries to address both of these subjects and as a result, provides more of a comprehensive survey of differing visions of Muslim politics than a focused argument. Monshipouri does pursue a consistent theme throughout the book, however: the role of Islam in framing political identities and political interests in an increasingly globalized world. Within the overarching narrative of identity politics, the volume devotes particular attention to human rights in Islam and especially to women's rights.
Muslim political identity is seen as constructed in part by external shocks (such as the events of 11 September 2001), but the book is not entirely clear on how specific identities emerge or why they may shift over time. Monshipouri suggests that an upsurge in identity politics beginning in the 1990s is due partly to democratization pressures and to an emerging culture of resistance in much of the Arab world. In this context, Islamic, national, and state identities compete for attention simultaneously, although it is not clear from the author's account when Islamic identity will dominate. He views the process of identity assertion as one of reclaiming personal and cultural power, a point that has strong contemporary resonance given the newfound belief in popular authority in the wake of the 2011 Arab uprisings. The author sees globalization and the Internet as key sites for the competition over identity, recognizing that the process of identity formation is often a conflictual one. He notes that “Islamic militancy arises largely in response to casting about for identity” (p. 255).
The author makes several important choices in structuring the work that are key to its message. First, he creates a typology of Muslims, distinguishing between “conservatives,” “neo-fundamentalists,” “reformists,” and “secularists.” This typology is helpful in distinguishing between very different Muslim ontologies, making it crystal clear that stark differences in political outlook exist across the Islamic world. Muslims are engaged in a “cultural conflict over who controls the process of social change” (p. 11), and their beliefs and strategies about ideal social outcomes are very diverse. The distinction between these worldviews, however, is often muddied by imprecise language and a failure to stick to the original typology in each of the cases: terms such as “neo-conservatives,” “new Islamists,” “modernists,” “neo-modernists,” and “neo-orthodoxies” are all used as descriptive categories that overlap with his typology over the course of the book.
Second, the author makes intriguing choices about case selection, which in some ways distinguish this book from comparable works. Each of the main cases, which include Egypt, Iraq, the United Arab Emirates (UAE), Iran, Turkey, Indonesia, and Western Europe, gets its own chapter, and these chapters form the bulk of the volume. The case selection errs on the side of comprehensiveness, which increases the book's empirical reach and makes it a useful pedagogical resource for those seeking to present a broad introduction to the diversity of the Muslim political experience. The challenge with such an array of diverse cases is that many of them simply do not fit well into Monshipouri's conceptual framework of competing Muslim worldviews, and thus the thread of the volume largely gets lost in the more descriptive accounts of Muslim political experience in each locale. The Iraq chapter, for example, focuses largely on the American occupation and prospects of democratic transition, losing much of the thematic focus on identity; the chapter on the UAE focuses on politics and society more generally, as the UAE has very little political Islam to assess or even describe; and the Iran chapter focuses primarily on developments in women's rights. Because many of the case studies assume little general knowledge, they serve as a useful introduction to the range of differences within the Muslim world. However, the issues these chapters address are not always comparable to one another.
Monshipouri does make a number of specific arguments in regard to the intersection of Islam, human rights, and gender identity, as well as about why Islam becomes politicized. He argues that group (religious) rights should matter in discussions of international human rights norms while allowing that universal values could also be applied to challenge some of “the Muslim world's archaic and unfit traditions and laws” (p. 46). As evidence, he points to the dramatic failure of France's social integration model, arguing that “assimilation is unlikely to work in European multicultural societies” (p. 242). He also asserts that there are pragmatic grounds for greater cooperation between secular and Islamic feminists in promoting women's rights, although it is not clear why gender rights successes have been more common in some contexts than in others.
For Monshipouri, the variable success of Islam as a political identity from one case to another is the result of a complex interplay of international, state, and economic factors. He argues that Islamism is fundamentally a reaction to the colonial experience, state authoritarianism with its attendant corruption and repression, and the failure of secular models of governance. In addition, its proponents are often affected by mass economic dislocation and benefit from the provision of grassroots services provided by Islamic groups. His argument that “in many Muslim countries revolution is highly unlikely” (p. 26) will probably be updated or clarified in a subsequent edition of the book.
These arguments are juxtaposed with a number of sensible, if unsystematic, policy asides that demonstrate the relevance of his arguments to policy decisions. He uses a normative lens when describing “outmoded thinking on women” (p. 54) but believes that a strict application of external women's rights standards can do more harm than good. He argues against military incursions into Iran (p. 52), that the United States has grossly mismanaged Iraq, and that “Indonesia has proved to be ill-prepared for democracy” (p. 206). One of the central policy arguments of his book is that it is wise to integrate mainstream Islamists into their political systems through democratic reforms, which should then lead to less militant forms of Islamism.
Overall, this book does several things quite well. It engages the nonspecialist with a wide variety of examples of the Islamic political experience. It is particularly illustrative of the diversity of Muslim political viewpoints and the contexts in which Islamic identity becomes politicized. Its focus on identity, human rights, and gender issues provides a useful lens through which to examine the author's remarkably diverse cases. However, the case studies ultimately sacrifice some of the benefits of the book's conceptual framework in order to provide descriptive background to the most uniquely compelling contemporary issues in each country or region. As the book progresses, its early arguments fade increasingly into the background and are not systematically integrated into the discussion. For those interested in a conceptual framework for understanding the different political identities and interests of Islamic actors, Muslims in Global Politics proves both very useful and thoughtful. For those interested in the dynamics of Islamist political movements and political parties, it has much less to say.
