How did Barth's biblical exegesis determine his dogmatic theology and how did his own dogmatic theology influence his reading of scripture? This is the complex question raised in this doctoral dissertation by a young Roman Catholic systematic theologian who currently teaches at the Faculté de théologie of the Université catholique de Louvain (Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium). The book contains two main parts: the first, quite short (only 85 pages), focuses on ‘biblical hermeneutics’ and the second on ‘dogmatic hermeneutics’. The first part is divided into two chapters: ‘The Problem of Barth's Biblical Hermeneutic’ and ‘Biblical Hermeneutic in the Fourth Volume of the Church Dogmatics’. The second part of the book (c.400 pages), is divided into three large sections: ‘A Critique of Dogmatic Reason: Theology as a Hermeneutic of Facticity’ (chapter 3), ‘A Pragmatic Approach to the Christological Event: Theology as a Hermeneutic of Historicity’ (chapter 4) and, before a conclusion, an ‘Assessment (Bilan) of a Theo-Logic’ (chapter 5) in which Bourgine summarises his findings and provides a critical evaluation.
The book commends itself for its methodology and the clear delineation of its subject matter. Bourgine's decision to limit himself to the fourth part of the Church Dogmatics (hereafter CD), in other words to Barth's doctrine of the reconciliation (written between 1951 and 1961), is sound. Surprisingly, rather than studying some of the sections of CD IV, mostly in small print, in which Barth interprets scripture, Bourgine focuses on a selection of ten passages from the dogmatic text itself (pp. 168–259). He also chooses to study both aspects of the problem (biblical hermeneutic/dogmatic hermeneutic) independently from each other, in order to follow Barth's own way of clearly distinguishing the two, but also in order to avoid arbitrariness and to increase the verifiability of his results (p. xx, n. 16). Bourgine acknowledges the important work done by other scholars in recent years in the area of Barth's scriptural exegesis (he particularly mentions Helmut Kirschstein, Ulrich H. J. Körtner and Richard E. Burnett, whose findings he presents in chapter 1).
In part 1, Bourgine distinguishes among the key features of Barth's biblical hermeneutics in CD IV what he rightly calls a ‘naïveté critique’, for instance in his understanding of the Easter events (pp. 46–7, 201 and also pp. 128–9, where this ‘naïveté' is the object of a critical remark from a ‘modern’ standpoint). Barth's actualistic understanding of scripture as ‘witness’, of the Word of God as an ‘event’ in which the written word ‘refers’ to its object – God's self-revelation in Jesus Christ – only whenever and wherever God wishes to do so, is rightly emphasised (pp. 17–18, 85 passim). This actualism is only a mean to an end: it allows Barth to preserve the sovereign freedom of God's Word.
The main contribution of Bourgine lies in the second part of the book. He begins by reviewing some of the important studies of the last decades (I. Spieckermann, M. Beintker and B. McCormack). He notably, but not quite convincingly, questions McCormack's critique of von Balthasar's thesis of a turn from dialectic to analogy around 1931 (pp. 97–8). This criticism is made only in passing, but it is worth pondering. One perfectly understands how Bourgine, finding many crucial themes of the book on Anselm (1931) in CD IV, was led to argue for the importance of that book in Barth's career, and thus became suspicious of McCormack's thesis. But, if I am not mistaken, McCormack would not deny Bourgine's correct impression that one finds in CD an application of many important insights present in the book on Anselm. What McCormack would deny, however, is that the book on Anselm contains insights which were not present in Barth's earlier writings. Whether McCormack's thesis is correct or not should certainly remain an open question, rather than something ‘settled’, but a thorough critique of his thesis would require a very different study than Bourgine's.
It is in Barth's book on Anselm that Bourgine finds the term ‘facticity’ (‘facticité’; pp. 110–11 and 118), which he then uses to describe Barth's dogmatic hermeneutic. That hermeneutic is a ‘hermeneutic of facticity’ in the sense that it is centred on the concrete historical fact of God's revelation in Jesus Christ. His hermeneutic, like his entire theology, begins with the concrete, never with the general (but the concrete event or fact is itself of general or universal relevance (p. 478ff.). Bourgine then turns to a close study of the fourth part of CD, using ‘an analytic approach’ on ten ‘small argumentative units’ (pp. 166–7) in CD IV/1, IV/2 and IV/3. The length of these passages varies. Some are very short (less than 5 pages). This method can only be commended, since it allows for a detailed and thorough analysis and interpretation of the selected text. For each passage, Bourgine summarises its context, main topic, structure, various themes and method, and finally comments on the relation between exegesis and dogmatic theology. These pages, which are too rich to be summarised, are among the most interesting in the book. Bourgine provides a very detailed analysis of the selected texts and finds a specific ‘logic’ in each one of them (a logic of ‘objectivity’, of ‘facticity’, of ‘participation’, of ‘assertion’, etc.). In all ten passages, Bourgine sees at work an understanding of ‘dogmatics as hermeneutic of the Gospel’ as history and story (pp. 248–9). Bourgine concludes, somewhat vaguely, that scriptural exegesis and dogmatic reflection stand in an ‘organic relation’ (p. 309).
The second half of the second part of the book develops Barth's ‘hermeneutic of historicity’, by which Bourgine means God's own historicity (pp. 314–37), understood as the relational structure of God's trinitarian being and as God's freedom (pp. 336 and 376). Jüngel's study of Barth's doctrine of God (God's Being is in Becoming, first published in 1965) is the main reference here. Bourgine then turns to the historicity of God's revelation in his Word and to the historicity of salvation in human history.
The third and final chapter of part 2 (‘Bilan d'une théo-logique’) is radically different in its method from the previous chapter: after concentrating on ten passages from CD IV, Bourgine considerably widens his horizon and offers many interesting insights in dense comparisons of Barth's hermeneutic of facticity and historicity with the thoughts of Bultmann, Kant, Hegel, Wilhelm Schapp, Gadamer and Jean Ladrière before moving to a study of Barth's (positive) influence on Catholic fundamental and apologetic theology after Vatican II. A final section before the conclusion raises good (but of course by no means new) questions on Barth's radical ‘exclusion’ of any autonomous human capacity to know God apart from revelation and on the ensuing ‘drastic restriction of the theological horizon’ (p. 489). But it is not immediately clear how these sections help one understand the relation between biblical exegesis and dogmatics in Barth's theology. The fact is, the subtitle of the book is slightly misleading, since Bourgine's book does not provide a close study of the relation between exegesis and dogmatics in CD IV. To do that Bourgine would have had to pay attention to the specifically exegetical sections of that work. The book does not contain anything close to that. But the title of the book, on the other hand, accurately reflects its purpose and ambition. Bourgine has indeed written a very clear and helpful book on the main characteristics of Barth's theological, i.e. dogmatic hermeneutic. As such, it is essential reading for anybody interested in this topic.
