In March 2010, Congress enacted the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA)—instituting a broad range of reform provisions aimed at improving access, affordability, quality, and cost effectiveness of our nation's health-care system. Since then, it is the popular media that provide most accounts of the politics surrounding this landmark legislation, emphasizing its tremendous complexity from both a policy-analysis and political perspective. What we really need are broader accounts to help contextualize and understand these complex policy and political developments. Both of these books serve this vital role: explaining why the ACA's complicated policy design was inevitable, as well as how this design may be problematic going forward. Their availability so soon after enactment of the ACA will be critical in assisting scholars, students, and the American public to understand the causes, potential consequences, and future politics surrounding health reform in the United States.
Lawrence Jacobs and Theda Skocpol's Health Care Reform and American Politics was published just months after enactment of the ACA. This was possible because its authors—both long-standing scholars of health politics—undertook an ongoing systematic tracking of public opinion, media coverage, and elite discourse beginning in 2007, as the Democrats geared up for a presidential election likely to prioritize health reform. Supplemented by interviews in 2009 and 2010, these data allow for a real-time account of the political developments leading to enactment of the ACA. The authors aim to tell this story as “concisely, vividly, and understandably as possible” (p. 8), which they easily accomplish, making this a book likely to appeal to a wide range of audiences.
Jacobs and Skocpol begin with a concise review of the historical development of, and persistent problems with, the American health-care system. They then describe the political agenda in 2007 as Democrats prepared for the presidential race, which notably focused on health care as a priority long before it was evident that Barack Obama would be the party's nominee. They next detail key political developments advancing and blocking health reform up through its enactment in early 2010. To explain how a broad consensus that our health-insurance system was broken beyond repair devolved into bitter, partisan struggle (p. 8), they rely on core concepts in American politics: institutional and informal powers held by the president, as well as each congressional chamber; the influence of interest groups and policy analysis in shaping debate; ideological positioning of the median and pivotal legislator in each chamber and party; and alternative mechanisms for assembling majorities and supermajorities necessary to move controversial legislation out of committee, through both chambers, and into law. For this reason, the book would provide an excellent case study to help bring alive the concepts covered in any survey of American government.
In their discussion of the ACA, Jacobs and Skocpol devote substantial attention to two common political dynamics that Americans find particularly troubling: deal making (pp. 66–75) and partisanship (pp. 82–88). They provide a compelling rationale for politicians who undertake each strategic behavior, extending beyond individual-level explanations to the reasons that institutional constraints and requirements incentivize politicians to undertake side deals with key interest groups who hold the potential to undermine the entire reform package. Similarly, they explain how the high level of partisan conflict was “not the simple work of one villain, but resulted from mutual distrust in Congress, clashing electoral strategies and omnipresent pressure from dueling activists who credibly threatened painful retribution” (p. 87). Understanding the reasons that policymakers engage in these political strategies is essential for public evaluation of our policymaking process and institutions.
Paul Starr's Remedy and Reaction adopts a longer view to explain the politics of health reform in the United States. To explain how we ended up with the “most expensive health care system in the world and a rising proportion of people without health insurance” (p. 72), Starr identifies critical junctures in the development of American health insurance from 1915 through today. Echoing recent work in the field of American political development, he emphasizes the importance of the sequencing of policy development—notably the early decisions to subsidize employment-based private insurance and create separate categorical programs for the elderly and the poor. One of his key insights is that, by 1965, the United States had “ensnared itself in a policy trap, devising an increasingly costly and complicated system that has satisfied enough of the public and so enriched the health-care industry as to make change extraordinarily difficult” (p. 2).
The second section of this book focuses on the recent history of unsuccessful health-reform efforts from 1991 to 2006. Starr explains how that health-policy trap limited efforts by Democrats—most notably Bill Clinton—to expand our national health-care system, but also served to constrain Republican attempts to eliminate, block-grant, partially privatize, or roll back Medicaid and Medicare. Through detailed descriptions of alterative policy proposals, counterproposals, and compromises put forth during this time, Starr depicts a health-care system that is resistant to reform. In fact, he argues that—for both sides, again and again—the “negative political possibilities of health care seemed to be greater than the positive ones” (p. 151).
This section includes a particularly interesting discussion of the Clinton health-reform effort in which Starr draws on his personal experience as one of Clinton's health-policy advisors during this time. The author aims to correct what he views as misconceptions regarding how the Clinton plan was developed (most notably that it was developed by policy wonks without consideration of political realities; pp. 81–95). Although he does not exonerate Clinton from responsibility for the law's failure (p. 95), he aims to shift attention to the broader—and more persistent—political realities faced by the president. In particular, within the health-policy trap, efforts to mobilize broad public support is likely to antagonize large segments of the public who are protected by the current system, as well as to mobilize well-organized industry groups with much to win or lose as a result of reform.
The third section of the book takes up the more recent history, illustrating how this policy trap threatened development of the ACA as well. Starr attributes much of the success of the ACA to the political learning that followed the failure of the Clinton plan, in which many Democrats realized that they “would have to settle for a lot less in health-care reform than they believed was either just or necessary” (p. 128). A key insight in this section is how, after decades of struggling within the health-policy trap, reform advocates began to converge around a set of what Starr refers to as “minimally invasive reform[s]” (p. 177). The aim of these proposals was not to build a new system but, instead, to alter the current system in ways that promised to garner greater industry and public support. As a result, competing proposals were moved off the agenda (particularly two: elimination of employer-based insurance and a Medicare for All, single-payer plan), leading to a more narrow policy agenda that made it easier (but not easy) to hold together a coalition of support. Starr's account explains much about the ACA, how the adoption of this minimally invasive approach provided a “chance to pass legislation, though also limited the kind of legislation they could pass” (p. 237).
Despite differences in the scope of these two books, both include a penultimate chapter discussing the specific provisions included in the ACA. Jacobs and Skocpol focus their description on the benefits directed at different demographic groups, as well as at society as a whole. They conclude that the ACA “amounts to a very good deal for the great majority of Americans and for the country as a whole” (p. 146.). In contrast, Starr organizes his overview as an analysis of the public philosophy revealed by the specific provisions adopted (i.e., notions of fairness, responsibility, freedom, and federal responsibility). Despite these distinct approaches to cataloging the provisions in the ACA, both make similar points, and it is quite evident that they are describing the same piece of legislation. Together these two chapters provide an excellent primer for anyone wishing to understand the content of the ACA.
Both books conclude with a chapter speculating on the future prospects for the ACA. Jacobs and Skocpol adopt a more optimistic forecast, which may be explained by their earlier publication date—since the year between the two books' publication was characterized by a much higher level of resistance to, and persistent criticism of, the ACA than initially anticipated. Starr emphasizes that despite the belief among many of the law's supporters that the “normal process of implementing the Affordable Care Act would strengthen it politically” (p. 269), the intended and unintended delays in implementation now seem more likely to result in confusion and uncertainty than in broad political acceptance and support.
In addition, both books emphasize the complexity of the ACA's policy design—making clear that a “minimally invasive reform” approach typically relies on policy tools that are tricky to implement and oversee. Most notably, much of the policymaking authority was devolved to state governments and federal agencies—providing new policy venues for policy losers (particularly those represented by powerful interest groups) to work to roll back provisions that harm them. The degree to which industry groups are successful in this lobbying effort is likely to impact the success of the ACA, particularly its ability to constrain growing health-care costs.
Finally, both books address efforts to repeal the ACA. From the vantage point of summer 2010, Jacobs and Skocpol (correctly) viewed the constitutional challenges posed by state government as unlikely to overturn the law (p. 154). And both books emphasize the consequences of the 2012 Presidential and Congressional elections, noting how a “swing in power to the Republicans could therefore bring about a complete turnabout in national health policy” (Remedy and Reaction, p. 279). Further emphasizing the high stakes of political developments in the next few months and years, Starr relayed concerns among many of those involved in passing the ACA that this would be the country's last chance since “as health costs raise, the chance of ever passing a universal program again may slip away” (p. 281).
