Bolivia is one of those small countries that actually makes the pages of international newspapers, most recently for the election of Latin America's first indigenous leader and the consequent reaction, both positive and negative, in the nation and beyond. These two books, in contrasting ways, provide invaluable contexts to current events: one, Revolutionary Horizons, was written in direct response to the dramatic, even revolutionary, developments; the other, Bolivia, is a collection of essays mostly written long before Evo Morales was a political player on the national scene.
Although Bolivia has the capacity to spark the imagination across the world, it is not, as James Dunkerley reminds us, ‘for beginners’ (p. 3) and both books are written by historians who are no neophytes in exploring the twists and turns of the past of this landlocked nation, where global politics regularly clash with very local and particularistic concerns. Moreover, the politics of race and ethnicity in Bolivia require careful understanding if simplistic analyses are to be avoided. In this, both volumes offer their readers interpretations of events that are nuanced, provocative and sophisticated, yet strikingly different.
Forrest Hylton and Sinclair Thomson argue forcefully that the present in Bolivian politics is unintelligible without a sound understanding of the past. They offer the strong thesis that the election of Evo Morales is one in a series of revolutions that stretch back to the revolt led by Tupak Katari in the eighteenth century (a subject on which Thomson is particularly knowledgeable). This revolt, a scene in the closing act of the colonial period, which saw the siege of La Paz and almost achieved victory, is the first revolution. The second revolution is that of 1952, one of the most successful and far-reaching in Latin America's modern history, which overthrew the landowning oligarchy and ushered in a period of major reform and land distribution. The election of Evo Morales is the third revolution. This is, without a doubt, the controversial core to their book. Theirs is an archaeology of revolution where each epoch is sedimented onto its predecessors in ‘horizons’. They also invoke a very Andean understanding of history where the past is present in today, and indeed the title of the final chapter underlines this sense of the immediacy of the past by invoking the Aymara concept popularised by the Taller de Historia Oral Andina, ‘quip nayra uñtasis sartañani’, which can be loosely translated as ‘to walk ahead while looking back’ (p. 149). One could quibble about the phrase and its translation but the authors clearly read the present through the lens of past struggles or even the very same struggle reincarnated in the present. One cannot help but be reminded of Eugene O'Neill's description of Ireland having no present or future but ‘just the past happening over and over again today’ and, although Hylton and Thomson have a much more sophisticated appreciation of history than is suggested by this comment, they certainly seem to be tempted by it.
I would certainly not wish to argue with the importance of historical understanding in Bolivia or that contemporary politicians are not inspired by previous revolutions. I am not sure, however, how revolutionary present events are despite the rhetoric of Evo and his ministers. It may be too soon to tell (and I have the advantage of almost two years since the final draft of the book was produced), but although the changes are exciting and promising, there appears to be nothing on the horizon that suggests as profound a change in Bolivian society as produced by, for example, the 1952 revolution. In a similar vein, for all the invocation of ‘quip nayra’, the case needs to be made much more strongly that the rank and file demonstrators in 2003 were genuinely moved and inspired by Tupak Katari or even the 1952 Revolution. They appeared to be concerned about much more contemporary issues such as the sale of natural gas, coca eradication and the corruption of the government. I am not arguing that contemporary events do not owe much to the unfinished business of 1952 or the perdurance of colonial relations but rather that the arc of history is much less sharply drawn than Hylton and Thomson would have it.
In Dunkerley's book there is no arc of history. This is partly due to the fact that the essays presented here were written over a thirty-year period. Dunkerley celebrates the very haphazardness of history by presenting the essays in reverse chronological order and furthermore by providing the reader with neither an introduction nor conclusion, whether out of modesty or mischievousness I am not entirely sure. He does, however, begin with an essay debating the very Third Revolution posited by Hylton and Thomson (and others). Not only does he raise some of the concerns mentioned above but, perhaps more importantly, he also demonstrates much less confidence in the arrow of time. Dunkerley presents a history of the present, or perhaps more correctly, a series of histories of the present: the past irrupts into the present in unpredictable ways. The history of Bolivia may certainly be conflict (Zavaleta) but, as Dunkerley insists, ‘it is not always presented to us in predictable form’ (p. 13). The same would be true of the lines of conflict. He details, with the patience of someone who knows he is evidently right but with an appreciation of the power and allure of the more simplistic version, that Bolivia then and now cannot be divided in a simple dichotomous way between two Bolivias: indians and creoles, subalterns and oligarchs; rural and urban, neo-liberals and communitarians. For Dunkerley, history is clearly a messy business and Bolivian history especially so; the way to appreciate it is in the detail. He eschews the grand narrative and delves into the minutiae of events, such as a midnight embrace in 2003 between miner and soldier that ends in the fall of a government; the fact that new recruits in 1951 were drilling to accompany the corpse of Abaroa from Chile and were therefore unprepared for peasant militias; the US Airforce insignia that saved Barrientos from a mortal bullet and so on. In these small but significant details Dunkerley delights.
He is also fond of his charts, which detail events in chronological order. These are especially important in recent Bolivian history where things happen quickly. Evo Morales may very well style himself as the heir to Tupak Katari or the Inka Atawallpa but, as recently as 2003, Evo principally presented himself as the leader of the coca growers' union, not as an indian leader, which is why the more radical Qhispe contemptuously refers to him as a sindicalero. The vision of ‘quip nayra’ came late to Evo Morales. It is tempting to read current Bolivian politics in terms of indigenous peoples against creoles locked in a tightly choreographed dance where the costumes change but the steps remain the same, as all dance to the loud music of the brass band. But Dunkerley warns against the seductiveness of such a simplified view since the ethnic politics of Bolivia defies such a vision. Ethnic identity in Bolivia has never been clear-cut and indigenous people have long had a profoundly ambivalent relationship with the mestizo-creole state, including significant moments of supporting and maintaining it as well as those of undermining it. This rather messier view of historical momentum has the dancers less visible, the costumes damp with each other's sweat, and when the cold light of an Andean dawn arrives everyone is drunk on the floor, arms and legs entwined in an uncomfortable but intimate embrace; and it is by no means clear that there were ever only two groups dancing. As in all good Bolivian fiestas the band plays on, if not always in tune, and the bleary-eyed participants reach for another beer to cure their hangover of historic proportions and carry on dancing.
