Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-z4zkx Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T05:53:05.892Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

The effects of vortex centroid dynamics on the sound generated by interactions between two coaxial vortex rings

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  05 June 2026

Zhenyu Zang
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Nonlinear Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
Zhiteng Zhou
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Nonlinear Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
Shizhao Wang*
Affiliation:
State Key Laboratory of Nonlinear Mechanics, Institute of Mechanics, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100190, PR ChinaSchool of Engineering Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing 100049, PR China
*
Corresponding author: Shizhao Wang, wangsz@lnm.imech.ac.cn

Abstract

The interaction of vortex rings represents one of the most fundamental flows for elucidating the generation of vortex-induced sound. Previous studies have emphasised the radial motion of vortex rings as the dominant factor contributing to sound source. However, during the ‘slip-through’ interaction of vortex rings with unequal strengths, we observe that axial motion intensity significantly surpasses that of radial motion. This suggests that the relationship between vortex ring dynamics and sound source must be re-examined across a broader parameter space. The objective of this study is to refine the mechanism of sound generation by vortex ring dynamics. Using numerical simulations, we systematically investigate the interaction process and sound source variations of viscous vortex rings under different initial circulation ratios and radius ratios. By expressing the acceleration and deceleration of vortex rings via the time derivative of the vorticity centroid, we identify the axial velocity magnitude as the key kinematic parameter governing the contribution of each ring to sound source. Furthermore, we analyse a previously reported phenomenon wherein the weaker ring dominates the overall sound output. It occurs only within a limited range of small initial radius ratios where the magnitude of the axial velocity of the weaker ring is higher than that of the stronger ring due to the intense interaction between vortex rings. When the initial radius ratio is large, the mild interaction between vortex rings does not change the relative magnitude between the axial velocity of vortex rings. The dominance of the weaker ring in generating sound source does not occur.

JFM classification

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2026. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.The initial configuration of the coaxial collision of two vortex rings (a) in a cylindrical coordinate system and (b) in a meridional plane $\phi =0^\circ$. (c) The vorticity distribution inside the vortex core of the stronger ring.

Figure 1

Table 1.All configurations investigated in this work, specified by the initial circulation ratio $\gamma$ and radius ratio $\eta$.

Figure 2

Figure 2.The grid convergence analysis of the numerical simulation. (a) The fluctuations of the source $Q^{(3)}$ and (b) the change in the negative peaks with the ratio between the grid length and the initial radius of the vortex core.

Figure 3

Figure 3.The comparison of (a) the moment and (b) the sound pressure at $| \boldsymbol{\mathit{x}} |=80$ between the present numerical simulation and that of Inoue et al. (2000).

Figure 4

Figure 4.The axial positions $Z_S,Z_W$ of two vortex rings with initial configurations of the representative initial radius ratios for initial circulation ratios (of a) $\gamma =0.3$, (b) $\gamma =0.35$, (c) $\gamma =0.4$, (d) $\gamma =0.45$ and (e) $\gamma =0.5$.

Figure 5

Figure 5.A classification of all cases investigated in our work. The symbol represents the case that the weaker ring exhibits reverse motion, represents the case that the stronger ring exhibits reverse motion, represents the case that both the stronger and weaker rings exhibit reverse motion and ‘’ represents the case that two vortex rings maintain their forward direction. The background is shaded with the total reversal displacement of two vortex rings $\delta {Z}_S + \delta {Z}_W$.

Figure 6

Table 2.Classification of patterns under different initial configurations.

Figure 7

Figure 6.The axial positions $Z_S,Z_W$ of two vortex rings in a representative case for (a) Pattern I $(\gamma =0.30, \eta =0.60)$, (b) Pattern II $(\gamma =0.45, \eta =0.75)$ and (c) Pattern III $(\gamma =0.40, \eta =0.60)$.

Figure 8

Figure 7.The interaction of the two vortex rings at (a) $t=0$, (b) $t=10.60$, (c) $t=13.00$, (d) $t=14.80$, (e) $t=16.80$ and (f) $t=19.40$ for the case $\gamma =0.30, \eta =0.60$ in Pattern I. The arrows along the curves indicate the direction of streamlines. The thick and thin arrows indicate the direction of vortex ring travel and the mutual induced velocity, respectively. Arrow lengths are not indicative of velocity magnitude.

Figure 9

Figure 8.The interaction of the two vortex rings at (a) $t=0$, (b) $t=9.80$, (c) $t=11.80$, (d) $t=14.20$, (e) $t=16.60$ and (f) $t=19.80$ for the case $\gamma =0.50, \eta =1.00$ in Pattern II. The arrows along the curves indicate the direction of streamlines. The thick and thin arrows indicate the direction of vortex ring travel and the mutual induced velocity, respectively. Arrow lengths are not indicative of velocity magnitude.

Figure 10

Figure 9.The interaction of the two vortex rings at (a) $t=0$, (b) $t=9.60$, (c) $t=11.60$, (d) $t=13.40$, (e) $t=15.80$ and (f) $t=19.00$ for the case $\gamma =0.50, \eta =0.60$ in Pattern III. The arrows along the curves indicate the direction of streamlines. The thick and thin arrows indicate the direction of vortex ring travel and the mutual induced velocity, respectively. Arrow lengths are not indicative of velocity magnitude.

Figure 11

Figure 10.The interaction of the two vortex rings at (a) $t=0$, (b) $t=8.00$, (c) $t=10.60$, (d) $t=16.60$, (e) $t=22.80$ and (f) $t=25.00$ for the case $\gamma =0.40, \eta =2.20$ in Pattern IV. The arrows along the curves indicate the direction of streamlines. The thick and thin arrows indicate the direction of vortex ring travel and the mutual induced velocity, respectively. Arrow lengths are not indicative of velocity magnitude.

Figure 12

Figure 11.The details of the fluctuation of the sound source for $\gamma =0.50$ and $\eta =1.00$.

Figure 13

Figure 12.(a) The effect of the initial radius ratio $\eta$ for a fixed initial circulation ratio $\gamma$ and (b) the variation of negative peaks with the initial radius ratios. (c) The effect of the initial circulation ratio $\gamma$ for a fixed initial radius ratio $\eta$ on sound sources and (d) the variation of negative peaks with the initial circulation ratios. (e) The variation of the absolute values of negative peaks with all initial configurations investigated in our work.

Figure 14

Figure 13.The validation of the decomposition and the test conducted on the time derivative of circulation for (a) $\gamma =0.30, \eta =0.60$, (b) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =1.00$, (c) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =0.60$ and (d) $\gamma =0.4, \eta =2.2$.

Figure 15

Figure 14.The decomposition of the third-order time derivative of $Q$ for (a) $\gamma =0.30, \eta =0.60$, (b) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =1.00$, (c) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =0.60$ and (d) $\gamma =0.4, \eta =2.2$. For the sake of clarity, the first two terms $T_1, T_2$ are not presented due to their significantly smaller magnitudes.

Figure 16

Figure 15.The contributions to $Q^{(3)}$ from the stronger ring $T_{3S}$ and the weaker ring $T_{3W}$ for (a) $\gamma =0.30, \eta =0.60$, (b) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =1.00$, (c) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =0.60$ and (d) $\gamma =0.4, \eta =2.2$.

Figure 17

Figure 16.The evaluation of the contributions from the two vortex rings. represent the cases of the weaker ring contributing more to the generated sound and represent the cases of the stronger ring contributing more to the generated sound. The background is shaded with the natural logarithm of ratios between peaks of the terms related to the weaker ring and stronger ring ${\mathrm{ln}}|T_{3W,p}/ T_{3S,p}|$. The fitting equation of the critical initial radius ratio $\eta _{s}$ is also provided in this figure.

Figure 18

Figure 17.The peaks of the source related to (a) the stronger ring $T_{3S}$ in the second pulse, (b) the weaker ring $T_{3WL}$ in the negative pulse and (c) the natural logarithm of the ratios between the peak values.

Figure 19

Figure 18.The axial velocity of two vortex rings with initial circulation ratio and radius ratio (a) $\gamma =0.30, \eta =0.60$, (b) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =1.00$, (c) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =0.60$ and (d) $\gamma =0.40, \eta =2.20$.

Figure 20

Figure 19.The radial acceleration of two vortex rings with initial circulation ratio and radius ratio (a) $\gamma =0.30, \eta =0.60$, (b) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =1.00$, (c) $\gamma =0.50, \eta =0.60$ and (d) $\gamma =0.40, \eta =2.20$.

Figure 21

Figure 20.The ratios between the peaks of (a) the velocity component in the $z$ direction of the vorticity centroids $\beta _1=\mathrm{ln} |Z_{W}^{(1)} / Z_{S}^{(1)}|$ and (b) the acceleration component in the $r$ direction of the vorticity centroids $\beta _2=\mathrm{ln} |R_{W}^{(2)} / R_{S}^{(2)}|$. (c) The relationship of the ratios between the source term $\varepsilon =\mathrm{ln} |T_{3W,p}/ T_{3S,p}|$ and the ratios between the axial velocity of the vorticity centroids $\beta _1=\mathrm{ln} |Z_{W}^{(1)} / Z_{S}^{(1)}|$.

Figure 22

Figure 21.The perturbed initial vortex ring radius of the stronger ring.

Figure 23

Figure 22.The sound pressure obtained by the axisymmetric simulation and the full three-dimensional simulations.

Figure 24

Figure 23.The sound source generated by the coaxial head-on collision of two vortex rings with initial configurations of $\eta =0.6{-} 2.5$ for (a) $\gamma =0.30$, (b) $\gamma =0.40$, (c) $\gamma =0.45$ and (d) $\gamma =0.50$.

Supplementary material: File

Zang et al. supplementary material

Zang et al. supplementary material
Download Zang et al. supplementary material(File)
File 162.6 KB