Altera Roma brings together scholars from classics, archaeology, art history and history in a productive discussion of the clash between the Spanish and Aztec empires brought about by the Spanish conquest of Mexico in 1521. This edited collection explores the ensuing dialogue between the Old and New Worlds through the lens of Classical art, ideas and tropes from the sixteenth to eighteenth centuries.
Walter Scheidel sets up the discussion with his assessment of the Aztec polity by the standards of the Roman empire. In a welcome move beyond discussing whether the Aztecs ‘really ruled an empire’, Scheidel explains that this pre-Hispanic polity shared with the Romans the basic model of central city-states growing to influence a larger international system, fostering long-distance commercial, artistic and social relationships. Scheidel advocates a comparative methodology in the study of empires (p. 29) which analyses structural properties; he criticises the tendency to restrict comparisons to geographically proximate imperial systems and in doing so sets the course for the volume.
Thomas Cummins, John Pohl and Leonardo López Luján frame their discussions diligently within the comparative framework between the Aztecs and the Classical world. In a discussion of the Spanish conquest, Pohl compares Cortés's exploitation of the Aztecs’ religious history with strategies of deity impersonation in Classical ‘theatre states’. Cummins explores the visual connections made by colonists between Aztecs’ religious iconography and their own artistic inheritance from the Classical world (p. 224). The sixteenth-century Ixmiquiplan murals display the Classical trope of civilisation versus barbarism as the Chichimecs, depicted as centaurs (a classical reference to barbarity), fight the cultured Aztecs (pp. 240–1). This discussion is one of the most interesting insights in Altera Roma. Moving into Mexico's viceregal period, López Luján examines the impact of the excavations of the ancient Roman town of Herculaneum on eighteenth-century Mexico's own policy towards antiquities. He argues that the ensuing reappraisal of the past was a political strategy to promote a national spirit in the movement for independence (p. 332).
I found Cecelia Klein's discussion of depictions of human sacrifice in Western imagination to be one of the collection's most exciting chapters. Using sophisticated chronological methodology, a rare and difficult approach when studying the Aztecs, Klein traces depictions of human sacrifice from the pre-Hispanic stylised images which merely alluded to death and cannibalism to colonial-period depictions which privilege images of gushing blood and child murder. She argues persuasively that the sensational depictions reveal far more about contemporary European anxieties surrounding witchcraft, plague and disease than they do historical truths about Aztec human sacrifice. She concludes that human sacrifice ‘was rendered in ways far more familiar to [Europeans] than it would ever have been to the Aztecs themselves’ (p. 293).
It is well known that that the Florentine Codex (a major source for the study of pre-Hispanic and colonial Mexico, created by Franciscan friar Bernardino de Sahagún in collaboration with indigenous informants and artists) contains references to the Graeco-Roman pantheon. However, Andrew Laird and Guilhem Olivier make important contributions by demonstrating, in their complementary analyses, that the friars strategically invoked these references and ‘cleverly identified the Greek and Roman gods with the demons driven out by Christ in the Gospels’ (p. 171) to abet their evangelising mission. Laird provides a pithy reminder that we should interpret the friars’ actions as practical strategies, for in colonial New Spain ‘the need to convert the Indians was far more pressing than the pursuit of comparative anthropology’ (p. 182). Olivier deliberately explores Sahagún's inconsistent approach to documenting the Mexica deities, which he suggests ‘shifts back and forth between recognition of parallels with the Graeco-Roman pantheon, euhemerist theory, the presence of the devil, and the trace of a possible evangelization prior to the arrival of the Spanish’ (p. 205).
With rare exceptions, the Aztecs did not impose infrastructure in their vast, yet disparate empire, relying instead on hegemonic power to control their subjugated lands and ensure regular tribute. Scholars have previously discussed ideological domination as a method of indirect control and Eulogio Guzmán, Jonathan Edmonson and Emily Umberger continue in this tradition by examining the use of monumental architecture in order to exert external political influence. Of these contributions, Umberger's analysis of imperial expansion is the most compelling. Underpinned by the Aztecs’ obsession with controlling their natural environment, Umberger argues that the fertility and nature gods found at state-sponsored shrines in the empire were purposefully installed in order ‘to keep local agricultural conditions favorable’ (p. 138). Edmonson builds on the use of architecture as a political mechanism by using the case study of the Spanish town of Mérida, the so-called ‘Spanish Rome’, to show how this Roman provincial city's built environment provided the setting for the transmission of imperial ideology (p. 92). Guzmán uses social contract theorist Thomas Hobbes's Leviathan (1651) as a framing device to argue that the Aztec and post-Civil War English states both legitimised their authority by convincing their vassals that they controlled a single, confederate body. However, the Aztec empire was principally an economic system based on trade and tribute; political unification was not the aim. In this way, while he presents a fresh, comparative approach, I was not persuaded by Guzmán's argument that the Mexica showcased imagery to present their authority so as ‘to convince their constituents of the Mexica belief in many peoples, one government’ (p. 35).
In an effort to endorse the Aztecs as masters of a ‘real empire’, scholars have often alluded to one of history's greatest civilisations, the Roman empire, in their analyses of Aztec imperial strategies. Taking inspiration from Sabine McCormack's work on Roman Iberia and colonial Peru, Altera Roma makes a solid contribution to comparative approaches to studying the archaeology, history and art of empires.
