David Wolfsdorf’s Pleasure in Ancient Greek Philosophy is an encyclopedia of ancient contributions to the philosophy of pleasure. Wolfsdorf addresses these contributions in terms of two questions; “what is pleasure?” (which he also calls the ‘identity’ question) (P. 3), and “what categories do pleasures fit into?” (which he calls the ‘kinds’ question) (P. 4). Wolfsdorf engages the reader in an historical investigation of these two lines of inquiry beginning from a historical location that precedes the articulation of the identity question, when only the categorization of pleasures was being addressed. He traces a line of historical development from early Greek thinkers, like Democritus and Aristippus, who inquire about pleasure from an ethical standpoint, through thinkers in the early physical tradition, such as Diogenes of Apollonia and Empedocles. This is followed by an in depth look at the work of Plato. Wolfsdorf claims that Plato wrote more about the question of the identity of pleasure than any other ancient source and thus devotes a large and thought-provoking section to Plato’s ontology of pleasure, as well as Plato’s categorization of pleasures. Wolfsdorf goes on to illustrate Aristotle’s view of pleasure, his debts to Plato’s thought, as well as subtle differences and developments. Wolfsdorf continues with an exploration of Epicurus as well as Cyrenaic theories of pleasure as they relate to one another. His final section on ancient philosophy inquires into the thought of the old stoics. Wolfsdorf closes with an historical assessment of ancient contributions to modern understanding of pleasure. In his concluding chapter, Wolfsdorf claims, “most [of the ancient accounts of pleasure] fall into the sphere of ethics.” (P. 269) This contrasts with the treatment of pleasure by modern thinkers, such as Ryle, who situate questions of the identity of pleasure within larger questions of conscious states and other concerns within the philosophy of mind. Wolfsdorf illustrates that ethical inquiry is better suited to categorizing pleasures, while philosophy of mind based perspectives prove more fruitful in the exploration of the identity question.
Wolfsdorf begins by juxtaposing pleasure in the ancient Greek ethical tradition with pleasure in the early Greek tradition of “physiologia.” This difference in philosophical foundation sets the stage for the thrust of the book, because Wolfsdorf thinks that only a limited number of questions can be posed given an ethical grounding. It is not until pleasure is examined from a physical perspective that the question “what is pleasure?” arises. Wolfsdorf claims that Diogenes of Apollonia was likely “the earliest Greek philosopher to answer the identity question” (P. 35) and he did so “specifically with a physical account.” (P. 35) While Diogenes maintained that pleasure was accounted for by air pervading the body, lightening the blood and thus lightening the mood, there is no evidence that early Greek ethical thinkers “attempted to define pleasure properly speaking.” (P. 28) If it is a fact that inquiry stemming from a physical perspective raised the question of the identity of pleasure, while ethically based thinking did not raise this question, this provides support for Wolfsdorf’s conclusion that ancient, ethically based treatments of pleasure “focus rather heavily on the objects of pleasure…more so than on the hedonic attitude or intentional mode.” (P. 270) While ethically based treatments of pleasure are able to categorize pleasure, they are less able to address questions of the identity of pleasure.
Wolfsdorf’s sections on Plato are some of the most fruitful and illuminating of the book. He begins with Plato’s discussion of the identity question, followed by Plato’s categorization of kinds of pleasure, which works to further flesh out the identity of pleasure. According to Wolfsdorf, Plato’s understanding of the nature of pleasure lies in an idea Wolfsdorf calls ‘restoration’. The subject begins in a state of equilibrium or fullness; “the natural state of the body of a living being is health.” (P. 40) The subject loses this fullness like a leaky jar; this can happen slowly, in which case the subject will not notice the depletion of his resources, or it can happen quickly and experienced as pain. Pleasure is the restoration of this natural fullness. Wolfsdorf provides an example of the pleasure experienced when eating a good meal, returning one from a skewed state of hunger to a restored state of gastronomic satisfaction. Wolfsdorf illustrates that Plato’s understanding of pleasure is heavily based in ethics, and thus Plato’s discussion of pleasure leans toward the categorization of pleasure rather than an inquiry into pleasure itself. When Plato does discuss the nature of pleasure he often talks about it in physical terms, illustrated by hunger and thirst, characterized by what Wolfsdorf calls “sense-perceptual affectation.” (P. 51) This framing of Plato’s work serves to support Wolfsdorf’s thesis that the ethical standpoint cannot adequately answer the identity question.
In his book, Wolfsdorf accomplishes two things. He provides meticulously researched and encyclopedic knowledge of ancient philosophical views of pleasure regarding the questions “what is pleasure?” and “what kinds of pleasure are there?” Wolfsdorf also illustrates that inquiry into pleasure, from the standpoint of ethics, fails to adequately address the identity question, though the ethical standpoint is informative when it comes to the kinds question. On the other hand, the question of identity can be fruitfully explored from the standpoint of philosophy of mind, as foreshadowed in ancient philosophy’s physically focused inquiry. For those interested in the history of pleasure in ancient philosophy, or those who wish to have a more comprehensive understanding of modern examinations of pleasure, I would certainly recommend this book.
