Comparative history is not a new area — an interest in differing historical trajectories can be traced back to figures such as Alexis de Tocqueville and Max Weber (T. Skocpol and M. Somers, CSSH 22.2 (1980), 174–97), if not earlier (see Engels, 330–1). However, this field has found renewed popularity amongst historians of antiquity. It should be distinguished from the endeavours of some earlier proponents of world history who, while concerned with comparisons between ‘civilisations’, often adopted diffusionist viewpoints. By contrast, proponents of comparative history eschew such notions in favour of juxtaposing different societies — often having little to no contact (for geographic or temporal reasons) — in order to analyse the way in which they dealt with diverse political, socio-cultural and economic challenges. This book falls into this latter camp. As a side note, the recent growth in comparative history seems to parallel a rising interest in global history, although the two fields have quite different modi operandi (see S. Conrad, What is Global History? (2016)).
For historians of the ancient world, comparing Roman and Han societies has proved especially popular (for example, W. Scheidel (ed.), Rome and China (2009)). This is similarly the case with this volume, although several contributors also provide comparisons with Archaic-to-Roman-era Greek communities (chs 2, 6, 12 and 13). The volume's editors — Hans Beck and Griet Vankeerberghen — suggest that the Mediterranean world and China are well suited for comparative study since ‘their historical trajectories were independent’ (i) and they had only a hazy conception of each other's existence, thus making apparent similarities and divergences worthy of analysis. Whatever one might make of the depth or superficiality of particular points of comparison (on which individual readers will form their own judgement), the premise that these societies had limited knowledge of each other is fair. Despite attempts by some scholars to argue for the transmission of genuine (albeit garbled) information via diplomatic contact, it is clear that Graeco-Roman notions of the Seres (Silk People) and Chinese notions of Da Qin were heavily constructed through their own cultural lenses (see M. Cobb in H. P. Ray (ed.), The Archaeology of Knowledge Traditions of the Indian Ocean World (2021), 56–78).
The primary focus of Rulers and Ruled is on the notion of ‘the people’ and its manifestations in Greek, Roman and Chinese societies. Major issues addressed include ‘who “the people” were’, how they ‘constituted themselves through patterns of belonging and exclusion’, how their statuses, or lack thereof, were ‘charged with meaning’ and how they communicated those meanings (1). It is suggested that, regardless of societal or institutional peculiarities, a prevailing cross-cultural dichotomy exists whereby a small (but not necessarily close-knit) ‘group of individuals’, the rulers, can be contrasted with the vast majority ‘who, by definition, are not part of this group’ (2).
The introductory chapter does a fair job of justifying the book's thematic focus. However, more discussion of the raison d’être for a comparative historical approach would benefit those unfamiliar with the field. Beck and Vankeerberghen do briefly comment upon how comparative approaches rely on adopting a macro-historical framework, while also trying not to obscure the ‘cultural peculiarities of the civilizations they juxtapose’ (1; see also ch. 6, 193), but this point could be further developed (the reader is pointed to some additional literature in n. 2). Those less familiar with this field may find it useful to look at the discussion by Skocpol and Somers (op. cit.) and Conrad's (op. cit., 38–44) short overview.
The book is split into four main sections, the first part of which investigates the concepts of authority and socio-political distinction. In Vankeerberghen's ch. 1, a cross-cultural comparison is made of how late Republican and Western Han elites sought to emphasise their status. Miranda Brown and Zhongwei Zhang (ch. 2) follow this by a discussion of social memory in Roman Greece and Han China, specifically by looking at Chinese stele and Greek honorary statues. In the final chapter of part I (ch. 3), Carlos Noreña examines ‘suprafamilial, but submunicipal’ associations formed by artisans, retailers and others (102). It is striking that while private associations flourished in the Roman Empire, there appears to be a dearth of such collective bodies in Han China (109–10), probably because of the asymmetric concentration of power by the centre (115–16).
Part II of the volume examines the theme of agents and addressees. This entails a broad range of topics from oratory and communication between rulers and ruled (Francisco Pina Polo, ch. 4) to ‘female commoners’ (158) and the law (Robin Yates, ch. 5), the purpose and functioning of censuses in China and different Mediterranean societies (Hans Beck, ch. 6), and systems of food distribution and welfare (Moonsil Lee Kim, ch. 7). On this latter topic, Kim illuminates some intriguing points of comparison, including the differing primary recipients of these distributions (227–41) and the social expectations underpinning public banquets and communal dining (241–54).
Part III shifts focus to the topic of relations between ‘the people’ and autocrats. Alexander Yakobson's interesting, albeit heavily Roman-slanted, paper (ch. 8) explores the theme of manipulated versus spontaneous expressions of popular will, and how the Republican façade may not have been so transparent (in the 20s b.c.e.) for many among the lower orders when they clamoured for Augustus to adopt the office of dictator. For Garret P. Olberding (ch. 9), the slant is in the other direction, with an analysis of representations of tyrants and (would-be) tyrant slayers (particularly Jing Ke). David Engels (ch. 10) compares how the accumulation of power by talented, but flawed, autocrats — Julius Caesar and Qin Shi Huangdi — would, after their downfalls, eventually give way to more stable dynastic regimes. His chapter arguably provides one of the strongest articulations of the utility of comparative history. This is by demonstrating the benefit of analysing these juxtaposed examples as a means of addressing questions of personal agency (and accidents) versus ‘structural’ forces (348) in socio-political change. The section is concluded by Rebecca Robinson's (ch. 11) study of calendar reforms in the Roman and early Han empires: ‘far from being a purely scientific exercise’, these reforms were tied into the ‘consolidation of imperial authority’ (385).
Part IV contains the last two chapters of the volume, both of which focus on the theme of identity construction and the ‘barbarian other’. Yang Huang (ch. 12) argues that Chinese and Greek oppositional notions of the other developed over the long term and their inceptions can be traced back to the early Archaic period for Greece and the Western Zhou period for China. By contrast, Hyun Jin Kim (ch. 13) questions whether the notion of polarity may simplify a more complex reality, with views being at times ‘both aggregative and oppositional’ (421) depending upon context and ‘geopolitical and cultural needs’ (434).
To conclude, Rulers and Ruled offers a range of intriguing insights into different socio-cultural and political dynamics in (parts of) the Mediterranean and East Asia, roughly from the late Bronze Age down to Late Antiquity. The extent to which comparative historical approaches offer analytical benefits varies from chapter to chapter. Nonetheless, the book offers a useful addition to the existing corpus of comparative histories.
