Stephanie J. Smith's Gender and the Mexican Revolution brings a sophisticated, gendered version of the revolution to its ‘laboratory’: Yucatán under governors Salvador Alvarado (1915–18) and Felipe Carrillo Puerto (1922–4). Among the experiments run in this laboratory were the first feminist congresses in Mexico, both in 1916, and revolutionary policy formation specifically addressing women, giving the revolutionary period in Yucatán a feminist veneer. Cracking that veneer, Smith finds that at the local and personal level revolutionary policies did not overturn fundamental assumptions about gender roles and women's domestic responsibilities. At the same time, using court cases for which she scoured local archives, she shows how ordinary women, Maya and mestiza, put revolutionary rhetoric into practice to seek a better life for themselves and their children.
The book is organised into five thematic chapters examining different policy areas of Yucatán's revolutionary period: education and feminist groups; the judicial system, both military tribunals and constitutional courts; the church–state conflict; divorce practice; and debates about and regulation of prostitution. Throughout, Smith argues persuasively that the rhetoric of radical reform often ignored basic problems, such as a lack of resources to implement changes or the ways in which revolutionary policies reinforced pre-revolutionary hierarchies. Moreover, the direction of change was not inexorably towards greater equality and blind justice. Military tribunals established during the revolution to provide justice for the ‘poor’ heard diverse complaints, including lost honour, jilting, spousal abandonment and unjust working practices. In these courts women actually had a better chance of receiving justice than they did in the constitutional courts founded later, especially in cases of seduction and rape. During the 1920s concepts of modernity and scientific truth, represented by doctors' opinions formed through intrusive medical examinations of women, had greater weight in court than a woman's testimony. ‘While the revolutionary military tribunals from 1915 to 1917 allowed some women a means to manoeuvre within the judicial system’, Smith writes, ‘the court procedures of the 1920s often disadvantaged women and privileged male patriarchy by building gender inequality into a system supposedly predicated on the equality of all individuals before the law’ (p. 83).
The state became known, even notorious, both nationally and internationally, for the cases of divorce heard in its courts. Yucatán's liberalised divorce laws at one point allowed a spouse to petition for divorce not only without permission but without even informing the other spouse of the action; poor litigants were offered a 75 per cent discount on fees. Unhappy spouses arrived from other states and from as far away as Russia and Poland to end their marriages. Leaving to one side those who sailed to Yucatán having read about easy divorces in the New York papers, Smith focuses on local cases. In these instances abuse, both physical and emotional, was the principal reason that women sought divorce. Agripina Colina sought a divorce because of her abusive in-laws, who shouted obscenities at her, denied her adequate food and eventually threw her out of the house. Mercedes Cisneros de Petón, married for 34 years to a man of high society, testified to being forced to eat dinner alone in the kitchen and not having enough money to present herself appropriately in public, forcing her to borrow money from her servants. Cisneros was granted her divorce, on the grounds that this humiliation damaged her social standing. Despite cases like these, over the course of the 1920s divorce increasingly became a route that more men than women took. Smith concludes that while, especially for elite women, divorce proceedings could be empowering, women often fought not only their husbands but also their husbands' networks. It was particularly damaging for women when these networks included local officials who could help sway the case. Thus, as much as individual women used the courts to redress abuse and inequality in the domestic sphere, in practice liberalised divorce ‘further eroded women's position in society by enabling men to divorce their wives and leave them with little means to support themselves and their children’ (p. 144).
The government's efforts to reform the foundations of family life brought about a clash with the Catholic Church, as Governor Salvador Alvarado initially sought to purge the Church of employees and spaces, banishing priests and converting churches into museums or the homes of municipal bands. Meanwhile, printing presses churned out tracts and articles that ‘ideologically linked a modern country with a secular household freed from traditional religious ties’ (p. 100). But throughout, Yucatán women defended their churches and their right to attend them, at times successfully negotiating with the state for the return of seized churches or church property. In Ticul a group of 21 women asked the local military commander to unlock the city's main church, which he agreed to do (perhaps having already received orders to do so); the women left the meeting with the church keys in their hands. But the fireworks of the conflict must not overwhelm the ways in which Church and state found common ground, as Smith makes clear, especially in their shared views of women as guardians of morality and future generations.
While revolutionary Yucatán has a reputation as the ‘laboratory’ of revolution and a hotbed of feminist reforms, Smith's carefully researched and well-written monograph shows that ‘despite the volume and variety of … liberal laws, most of them failed to challenge entrenched notions of patriarchal privilege and instead left women without equal rights or status’ (p. 178). She also provides us with a unique and nuanced view of the values, concerns and daily struggles of these Yucatecan women. Focusing on how women used the opportunities of the revolution to improve their lives, Smith concludes that through taking cases of injustice to court and through direct political action, women began to make changes that would help create opportunities for future generations. In that way, perhaps, these women really were the guardians of the future.
