This copiously annotated monograph discusses the role of women in old Macao. The focus is on the early seventeenth century, when the Portuguese were still active in Japan, and on the period immediately following the cycle of events which led to economic decline in Macao and forced local merchants to search for alternative trade options, especially in Southeast Asia. The book looks mainly at the internal situation inside Macao, at different power factions and the rivalries emerging between them. It is within this complex constellation that women sometimes became important.
Upward mobility inside the ‘colonial’ elite of Macao depended on wealth and connections, more than on anything else. As in many other urban settings, the well-to-do enjoyed much prestige and not infrequently they also had access to administrative and other posts of influence. By and large the social status of women was related to the status of their husbands. After the death of her husband, a widow often had little to live on, which could easily entail social decline; remarriage or entering a monastery were two other options. However, in some cases women received sizeable funds, and not infrequently a rich lady would later pass on large sums to her children, distant relatives, friends, former maids and domestic ‘slaves’. These are some of the socio-economic mechanisms exposed in Penalva's account.
There were also cases, where the so-called Santa Casa de Misericórdia – an institution found in many Luso-Asian locations – would assist the poor and the ones in distress. The Misericórdia in turn received money from influential merchants and also from wealthy women. The last point is of particular concern to the present book, which provides much evidence for such transfers. Differently put, through its ‘redistributive’ functions the Misericórdia, sponsored by men and women alike, contributed to the internal stability of Macao. In the absence of non-domestic employment opportunities and a traditional family structure (of the kind one can encounter in sixteenth-century Portugal or China), it was one of the few institutional bodies in traditional Macao that were able to render valuable services to the city's social well-being over extended periods in time.
Clearly, the clergy played a key role in this environment, as Penalva's account suggests. The well-to-do often maintained close relations with the Catholic fathers, especially the Jesuits. Not infrequently, the latter would consult the rich, encouraging them to attend mass and confess their sins, and to donate money to the Church – funds that were urgently needed for the missions inside China and the Church's quasi-diplomatic representatives at the imperial court in Beijing. But this is not all: Confession implied the potential to receive and pass on information. Therefore some profit-minded merchants were cautious, urging their wives to stay at home. Again, Penalva provides some interesting material on these dimensions of Macao's daily life.
Such stories show that Macao's women took up different functions. At times they remained in the ‘background’, on other occasions they became active ‘players’ on the city's stage. There is, for example, the well-known case of Leonor de Fonseca (various spellings), who led a very ‘free’ life, much to the distress of some of her contemporaries – and certainly not quite in conformity with the ‘socio-religious’ conventions of her times. The Church was alarmed and her conduct was later investigated in Goa. On this subject readers may also consult an interesting study by Miguel Rodrigues Lourenço in Bulletin of Portuguese Japanese Studies 17 (2008). Penalva, one may add, has been working together with Lourenço on various occasions, and she herself has also produced a number of scholarly papers that ‘overlap’ with the present book. This includes another article in the same journal, as well as her “Women in Macau, 1633–1644”, in Luís F. Barreto (ed.), Macau during the Ming Dynasty (Lisbon, 2009). All these studies offer new material on the internal structure of Macao's society and are, to some measure, based on Penalva's doctorial dissertation.
Another very special aspect of Mulheres concerns the relations between Macao and Manila – both before and after the end of the Luso-Spanish double monarchy. Some merchants in Macao dreamt of expanding trade along this ‘axis’. When the situation in Japan turned worse, the idea of stronger Luso-Spanish ties became even more popular. Interestingly, the nuns of St Clare (Clarissas) were closely associated with the ‘Manila faction’ and several merchants belonging to that ‘caste’ sent their daughters to the Convento das Clarissas (on which one can also consult various older works by Manuel Teixeira). Penalva provides a meticulous analysis of this complicated scenario in which the Clarissas often functioned like a pressure group. The Jesuits, naturally, would not side with this ‘camp’, although they harboured hopes of re-entering Japan by way of Manila. It will be recalled here that the Church had suffered from severe persecutions in Japan and that efforts to re-establish relations with Macao had ended in utter failure. Benjamin Videira Pires’ famous Embaixada mártir (Macao, 1965), a more recent account by Valdemar Coutinho, as well as other works, narrate all the relevant events. But they are not really concerned with the role of different factions inside Macao and not with the Clarissas, something that Penalva's study adds to the overall picture of this period.
Finally, there is the story of Isabel Reigota, a lady of Japanese descent who had escaped the anti-Christian movement in her own country. She spent many years in Macao, where she became involved in the commercial world. This mainly concerns the trade in sandalwood, a commodity regularly obtained from Timor and Makassar during the middle of the seventeenth century. Reigota was also in close touch with the clergy. Again, Penalva has reconstructed all the relevant details. There are not too many biographies of individuals who had a share in Luso-Asian trade during the middle of the seventeenth century. Francisco Vieira de Figueiredo's colourful life, outlined in one of Charles R. Boxer's books, is a rare exception. Reigota's case was of course much less spectacular, on account of its limited scope and the “miniature” sums she was dealing in, but the description of her activities is a welcome addendum to the historical panorama of this period.
As was said, Penalva's account is based on a multitude of sources. It is well-researched, clearly structured and can be profitably read side-by-side with other works by the same author. Nevertheless, it also becomes evident that much more research is still required to fully disentangle the complex power mosaic inside seventeenth-century Macao. This also means that more attention should be given to certain ‘rudimentary’ dimensions – for example different expressions used to ‘categorise’ women in early Macao (see especially pp. 21–23). Finally, the analysis presented by Penalva mostly concerns the ‘colonial’ elite; whether contemporary sources would release as many details for the ‘rest’ of Macao is highly questionable. True, some women mentioned in the text (and listed in the most useful tables) belong to the lower ‘classes’, but the author's focus is essentially on the upper layers of the urban ‘organism’; the gaps at the ‘bottom’, I am afraid, cannot be filled, neither through Portuguese documents (some of which are appended to the book), nor through Chinese material. There are, for example, several Chinese studies with long paragraphs on the ‘blacks’ of seventeenth-century Macao, but they contain little on the role of women.
I may round off my observations by assuming that Penalva tried to be fair to all sides. She does not dwell on the (true or alleged) misconduct of specific individuals, nor on the fact that certain groups inside Macao were quite ‘special’. She does, however, convey the impression that material concerns were sometimes overstressed in the ‘City of the Name of God’, as Macao was then called. Such ambitions left their imprints on the minds of many citizens. Parts of the clergy, so it seems, tried to counterbalance these trends, but good-natured efforts did not always produce the intended results. Psychology mattered, this is one of the tacit messages Penalva's book seems to convey. Indeed, there were many ‘actors’ and ‘actresses’ on this multi-ethnic stage – real jurubaças, cultural ‘go-betweens’, and ‘guanxi masters’ – all of whom skilfully moved along invisible ‘frontiers’.
