Background
The World Health Organization (WHO) defines a mass casualty incident (MCI) as any event resulting in a number of victims that is large enough to disrupt the normal course of emergency and health care services.1 This scoping review focuses on sudden-onset MCIs that have an immediate impact on health care facilities. These incidents are uncommon, and only a few emergency managers will deal with these large-scale incidents during their careers.Reference González, Delgado, Álvarez and Alonso2 To respond to these situations, the American Academy of Emergency Medicine (AAEM) proposed five pillars, including planification and training, at its 2006 conference.Reference Bernstein, Boggs, Derlet, Handly, Hinfey and Kamens3 On the one hand, planning for MCIs requires a survey of regional surge capacities, and on the other hand, knowledge of the main types of MCIs as well as quantification of the number of victims is needed. Currently, practical training is mainly based on the anticipation of potential events (large public gatherings requiring medical supervision) and on the application of fictitious or MCI-based scripts.Reference Campanale, Maragno and Annese4 However, MCI experiences and feedback are not systematically reported or published,Reference Svensøy, Nilsson and Rimstad5 and reports of the quantification of the number of victims do not follow a uniform reporting method.Reference Turner, Lockey and Rehn6, Reference Khan, Fazli and Henry7
In the context of the recent evolution of French legislation on the conditions for reporting casualties in 2022 and the preparation for the Paris Olympic Games in 2024, there was a need to improve the knowledge of European MCI management. The study sought to characterize MCIs that have occurred over the past 30 years in Europe and to report the average number of victims for each MCI. The main objective was to estimate the median number of victims treated on site and the median number of victims transferred to hospitals, especially the number of victims who required immediate life-saving interventions. The secondary objective was to estimate the median and average number of victims for each major type of MCI.
Methods
This document consists of a scoping review on the quantification of the number of victims of MCIs with hospital admissions that have occurred in Europe over the past 30 years. The study was conducted according to the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses for Scoping Review (PRISMA-ScR) guidelines.Reference Tricco, Lillie and Zarin8 The collection of data was performed by 2 independent researchers according to the 2022 French decree, which defines the collection of victim reports.9
Data Sources
The sources used were PubMed, the Web of Science, Industrial and Transport Accident Reports from the Office of Transport Accident Studies (named the “Bureau d’étude des Accidents de Transport Terrestres” [BEATT]) and the Office of Analysis of Pollution and Industrial Risks (named the “Bureau Analyses des Risques de Pollution et Industriel [BARPI]), the Global Terrorism Database [GTD] and the International Disaster Database [EM-DAT]) in September 2022.
Search Strategy
In PubMed, the researchers selected Medical Subject Headings (MeSH) terms using the “or” and “and” particles. Other sources did not allow the use of these terms, replaced by search filters and keywords.
Inclusion Criteria
Sudden onset MCIs that occurred between January 1, 1991, and December 31, 2023, in Europe were included. The figures were determined on the basis of the number of victims transferred to the hospital over a short period of time, so this study did not include events with no hospital impact and therefore no impact on MCI medical planning. To differentiate MCI victims from patients receiving routine care, events involving ten victims transferred to hospitals were included. It was arbitrarily decided to make this cut-off after considering the methodology with several French MCI experts. In this way, it was possible to obtain a representative figure of the impact on the management of the capacity resources of health establishments.
Exclusion Criteria
All sudden onset MCIs with missing or unreliable numerical data were excluded, as well as those that occurred in the context of war or armed conflict.
Data Extraction
Events were counted in September 2022 and represented according to their location. Countries had to belong to the Council of Europe at that date.10 The data recorded included the date, place and type of event; the number of victims involved; the number of victims who died; the number of victims transferred to health establishments; and the number of victims categorized as life threatening (LT), defined according to the French Armed Forces Medical Service Scale derived from the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) scale, corresponding to “T1: requiring immediate life-saving interventions” in the NATO triage scale (Table S1, Supplementary Materials), which can be related to a “absolute emergency.” The report was compiled in accordance with the decree of the 2022 victim assessment and included temporary assessments, such as the number of deaths recorded on site, the number of victims who needed immediate surgery to save their lives with expected good survival, the number of victims whose lives were not jeopardized by delaying surgery with medical stabilization, the number of seriously injured individuals, and the number of slightly injured individuals.
The researchers followed a 4-step MeSH selection method for PubMed. First, “Disaster or Mass Casualty Incident” was entered; then, “Case Report or Experience or Lesson Learn or Review or Systematic Literature” and “Injuries or Victims” were added; and finally, “Terrorism or Explosive or Ballistic or Industrial or Toxic or Fire or Train or Bus or Rail or Flight” was entered. In the GTD database, selection by the search engine was proposed, and the terms defined by the researchers were as follows: “1991 to 2023,” “West Europe,” “East Europe,” and “Digital data available with ≥10 patients who were injured or died.” Events selected via the BEATT database were selected on the basis of the titles of all available documents and their full texts. BARPI events were selected by the following tabs: “1991-2023,” “European territory,” “injuries casualty,” and “human and social consequences 4 on the European scale of industrial accidents.” The Web of Science was used to determine the numerical details of sudden onset MCIs whose information was incomplete in the initial databases. The type, date, and location of the event were researched, and duplicates were eliminated.
Results
Selection of Mass Casualty Incidents
The study identified a total of 2,498 documents that occurred since 1991 in countries belonging to the Council of Europe at the date (Figure 1). Events that occurred in the contexts of war or armed conflicts listed in Table 1 were excluded.
Geopolitical conflicts in Europe since 1991

Cartography of European Council Member States in September 2022.

Numerical accounting was based on the number of victims, including life-threatening ones. This number was defined by the first on-site assessment conducted by the medical or paramedical team when more than one assessment and triage were detailed. If there was only one sorting, this was taken into account. The classification of the events into 7 causes was based on the experience of the researchers (emergency physicians with expertise in MCI).
Some data were missing, specified by the symbol * in the different tables. These included the number of patients transferred to hospitals and the number of life-threatening victims (concerning 5 events, 7% of the total events).
The Selected MCIs
Among 2,498 documents, 82 were selected covering 62 different events. The selection process corresponds to the flow chart (Figure 2) and a descriptive table (Table 2). The selection was made by reading the titles, then the abstract, and finally the full articles. In Europe, the median number of MCI victims was 73, including 9 who died on site (12%), 48 who were transferred to health facilities (66%), and 13 with life-threatening emergencies (17%). The average number of MCI victims was 233, including 20 victims who died on site (9%), 102 victims who were transferred to health facilities (44%), and 21 life-threatening emergencies (9%) (Tables 3 and 4).
PRISMA-ScR flow. Abbreviations: GTD: Global Terrorism Database, BEATT: Bureau d’Etude des Accidents de Transport Terrestre (office of transport accident studies), BARPI: Bureau d’Analyse des Risques de Pollution et Industriels (Office of Analysis of Pollution and Industrial Risks).

Data selection method

GTD: Global Terrorism Database; BEATT: Bureau d’Etude des Accidents de Transport Terrestre (Bureau of Transport Accident Studies); BARPI: Bureau d’Analyse des Risques de Pollution et Industriel (Office of Analysis of Pollution and Industrial Risks).
Inventory of MCIs in Europe. Information on the date, place, and type of event, the number of victims, the number of deaths on site, the number of victims transferred to a hospital, and the number of life-threatening (LT) victims was collected.

Note: Some data were missing, specified by the symbol *. References that come from the media are specified by the symbol ▪.
Average, median, and standard deviation based on the MCI census by typology

LT: Life-threatening victim.
The following 7 main causes of MCIs were identified: explosions, ballistic accidents, fires, road accidents, ram raids, railway accidents, and industrial accidents (Table 4). An MCI event could be included in several subgroups at the same time. The explosion subgroup was the most frequent, with 21 events. There has been an increase in MCIs related to terrorist events in Europe since 2010, particularly due to the appearance of the ram raids subgroup (medians: based on 68 total victims; 72% of victims hospitalized; 26% of LT victims) (Figure 3).
Evolution of event typology in number and proportion between 1991 and 2021.

The number of victims transferred to health care facilities was >50% for ballistic accidents, railway accidents, and ram raids. Concerning the number of life-threatening victims, the estimated number of victims varied according to the type of event. Industrial accidents remained the event type with the highest number of victims but with a low hospital impact (average of 634 total victims with 26% hospital transfer), with only 3% of victims experiencing life-threatening emergencies.
Limitations
In this scoping review, there are 20 French MCIs corresponding to 32% of all the data observed. There is a risk of the overrepresentation of events in France compared to other European countries. Indeed, some of the sources used were French analysis offices whose data collection was less exhaustive or not exhaustive outside of France. The addition of reports from similar offices in other European countries could support this work.
There is a publication bias in the management of these difficult situations and their corresponding victim reports, which is sometimes supplemented by research from the press. Thus, the different sources used for this review have varying levels of evidence. The GRADE or Oxford scales were not applicable to this review, but a proposal to separate sources from scientific publications and status reports from other sources is made. Those that come from the media are specified by the symbol ▪ in tables, accounting for 11 references (12% of all sources). Additionally, the numbers of victims were more accurate for recent events, probably thanks to more detailed and accessible publications.
Discussion
Knowing the number of victims expected or proven in an MCI is an important point for the adjustment of response plans by planners and for training health care teams to dispatch the flow of victims across all accessible hospitals according to their available resources. This first inventory shows the importance of continuing research in this direction to obtain better knowledge of the impact of past MCIs on hospital capacity. As failing to be able to anticipate or predict future MCIs can be detrimental, these data provide numbers of past victims to evaluate medical response possibilities and trainings. For large gatherings requiring on-site medical teams, this work helps to determine resource needs according to the level of risk.
This work provides numerical data on the number of victims and defines 2 thresholds of preparation (average and median events) for emergency medicine rescue teams and hospital surgical departments by estimating the surge capacity needed. To illustrate, each hospital has different resources, but they can all train on average and median casualty volumes. In this way, they can determine their own breaking point and work on ways to improve their response plan to sudden onset MCIs. These data, associated with knowledge of territorial hospital capacities, allow stronger planning for MCIs, with gauges for training. It also allows to predict the effects by region, as defined in the national response plan,11 and to adjust the knowledge of the expected number of life-threatening victims (9% of the total victims or 20% of the transferred victims). The method of identification was based on the triage scales recommended for MCIs in France.Reference Cesareo, Raux and Soulat12 A simple scale derived from the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) was developed and is very similar to the scale used by the French military health service.Reference Sockeel, De La Villeon, Goudard, Goin, Monchal and Pauleau13 Any casualty described as requiring immediate care according to the NATO scale, regardless of the final anatomical injury, was categorized as a life-threatening victim. In this way, the scale allows over-triage to limit under triage to a minimum number of victims, as recommended in the construction of triage scales. Moreover, some types of accidents naturally involve a tendency toward over triage (such as industrial accidents).
In the literature, most of these casualty counts were focused on one type of MCIReference Mayo and Kluger14 and were not geographically distinguished. For example, in a study of mass killings that have occurred worldwide since 1980, only 8 of the 50 events reported provided victim statistics.Reference Melmer, Carlin and Castater15 The number of hospital transfers was also not recorded, preventing the evaluation of the impact of these events on hospitals. In other cases, reviews of the typologies of corporal damage have been conducted.Reference Mayo and Kluger14, Reference Desel16 Most of the studies aimed to empirically analyze the responses to each of the events. Publications that allow the quantification of a precise number of victims are rare. The lack of a scientific protocol survey of the medical management of these uncommon events has been documented. In view of this, a team has proposed a study of MCI events based on media sources via NextUni. MCIs have arbitrarily been defined in Rwanda as those involving ≥3 injured people or ≥1 death since 2010, allowing a median number of 11 injured people. Reference Velin, Donatien and Wladis17 However, this methodology does not consider the type of injury (serious or not) and does not correspond to the same population and societal risks as those in European countries.18
Conclusions
The analysis defined the average victim numbers in MCI that have occurred in Europe over the past 30 years, which are imperative for European MCI preparedness, especially for French planification. The number of victims transferred to hospitals and the number of victims requiring immediate life-saving interventions are the main details needed to evaluate the impacts of MCIs on hospitals. Annual updates could make it possible to keep the list of the latest incidents corresponding to the selection criteria up to date. In preparation for the 2024 Olympic Games in Paris, this work provides an additional planning tool.
Supplementary material
The supplementary material for this article can be found at http://doi.org/10.1017/dmp.2025.10218.
Data availability statement
The datasets used and/or analyzed during the current study are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request.
Authors’ contribution
LH and AA: Define the method and scoping review work, writing article. LaGa, AK and CO: Word on inclusion and exclusion criteria, help writing the article, and organize tables and figures. LyGu and RM: validation methodology and reviewing.
Funding statement
The authors did not receive any funding for this study.
Competing interests
The authors have no competing interests.
Ethics approval and consent to participate
This work did not involve any human persons, as it only consisted of a review of publications concerning MCIs. This study was not concerned with article R1121-2 of the public health code and was therefore outside the competence of the committee for the protection of individuals. This study involved noninterventional research without patient participation or access to medical data.
Consent for publication
Not applicable.
Authors’ information
References 18 to 86 each correspond to an investigation report of a disaster situation. These references correspond to the events retained in the literature review and are cited in Table 3. We believe that they are important to include in the references of the manuscript. However, they may be included as supplementary material to comply with editorial recommendations.
Previous communication to a society or meeting
Short oral communication on June 8, 2023, at the national congress of the French Society of Emergency Medicine 2023.
