This volume focuses on the emergence of a Protestant community in central Mozambique in the first half of the twentieth century. It is a study of the dynamics and constraints of building a Protestant church in the face of Portugal's pro-Catholic colonialism, as well as a study of the African grassroots activities to evangelise their brethren. The story unfolds over a period of 52 years during which one sees the rise of a religious community, the emergence of two African Christian associations, the collapse of missionary support, the eventual Portuguese prohibition of the associations, and the state's decision to fully favour and support Catholicism.
The volume is divided in two parts. The first contains four mostly chronological chapters that look at the American Congregationalist missionary work in Manica and Sofala from their start in the late nineteenth century to their abdication after 1940. It focuses on the missionary strategy, its successes and its difficulties. The second part of the book comprises six chapters that look at the Africans’ role in developing a Christian community. It starts with the emergence of small faith communities, deals with the rise of two rival Protestant associations, and finishes with a discussion of the nature of the church in central Mozambique. Straddling the two sections of the book is Kamba Simango, who was the missionary's main hope and the African communities’ leader until his ‘fall’ in the mid-1930s.
Leon Spencer, the author, began working on Mozambique in 1970, after he joined Talladega College in Alabama and became the head of the institution's small archive. To bolster the archive's collections, Spencer looked for new material, discovered the papers of the late Fred Bunker, and acquired them. Bunker had been a Congregationalist pastor in Manica and Sofala, had been the lead promoter of missionary work there, and had been mentor to Kamba Simango. After delving into Bunker's papers and history, Spencer engaged in a full investigation of the history of the Church in Manica and Sofala, something that led him to archives in the United States, England, and Switzerland, eventually resulting in the present book.
Spencer's opus is built on extensive research and it presents a uniquely rich account of how Protestantism developed in central Mozambique. It provides the first historical account of this community, something which is particularly important since historians of Mozambique have focused almost exclusively on Protestantism in the south of the country. It is also the first volume that delves into the life and work of Kamba Simango, who is held in Mozambique today as a hero – his name has been given to streets in the capital city of Maputo and the city of Beira. These two traits make Spencer's book a most valuable and welcome addition to the historiography of Mozambique.
The book's central argument is about African Christian independency. It advances that the history of Protestantism in Manica and Sofala is a unique case of Christian independency in that the African church developed not as a result of the separation from mission organisations, but as a result of missionaries’ separation from them. African Christian communities grew and developed into an autonomous church because the missionaries abandoned Mozambique as a result of their lack of funds and incapacity to overcome Portuguese opposition. Whereas Fred Bunker thought at the end of his life that he had failed in his venture to set up a church in Mozambique, Spencer reckons that his failure was actually a blessing in disguise as it permitted the development of a genuinely autonomous church.
The argument about independency is very interesting (a unique case indeed) and worthy, but it is also a bit out of date. It refers to a debate of the 1970s (when Spencer was doing his research) about the role of Africans in the development of Christianity in Africa, a debate led by Terence Ranger and Richard Gray who advised scholars to work on African Christianity rather than missionaries. The historiography has moved on since then, however, after integrating the argument and its lessons. It now focuses on both missionaries and African Christians to look at how religion shaped new ideas and debates, led to the creation of new networks and the circulation of missionaries and Africans, and, how missionaries’ work in Africa had an impact ‘back home’. Elements concerning these aspects exist in Spencer's book, but they are neither presented extensively nor argued systematically.
Another observation (not a criticism) concerns Kamba Simango. The author's analysis of Kamba is very rich – in fact unique so far – but it is constrained by the book's exclusive focus on religion. Kamba Simango may have been a missionary, but he also had other roles that explain his importance, then and now. He was a transnational intellectual, a cultural broker, and an activist who was building bridges within and between Africa, Europe, and the Americas. He attended the most famous Afro-American institutions, played a role in the Harlem Renaissance and the third Pan-African Congress, had unique role in shaping the discipline of anthropology, and played a significant role in influencing nationalism in Mozambique and Ghana. While Spencer provides an excellent first work on Kamba Simango and gives elements about the issues just mentioned, much more will need to be researched and written to do full justice to the man.
To conclude, Leon Spencer's opus is an excellent, original, and very solid piece of research. It is well written and enjoyable to read. It is a fundamental book for all those interested in religion and politics in Mozambique, those working on the development of Christianity in Africa, and those focusing on early African intellectuals and the building of a black international in the early twentieth century.
