In Unveiling the Harem, Mary Ann Fay argues that the harem is not simply a place but rather “an inscription on the woman's body as she moved through space” (p. 184). Whether gazing through the wooden latticed screenings (mashrabiyya) in her harem, riding on her donkey, going to the baths, or sitting in the family space of her home, she was part of a system that made elite women “socially invisible” yet allowed them to participate economically, socially, and even politically in the world of 18th-century Cairo. Fay reconstructs the lives of these women through the study of religious endowments (awqāf), travel literature, and the physical architecture of 18th-century homes that remain standing today. A dozen photographs demonstrating aspects of Mamluk architecture—mashrabiyya, window boxes, recesses, reception areas, galleries, and so forth—beautifully illustrate the author's points. Her archival research includes examinations of 18th-century Cairene waqfiyyāt with female donors, identifying the Mamluk elite by their household name, and she provides a chart with a female-centered genealogy of the Qazdughli household that is particularly useful. Through the analysis of a diverse collection of sources, Fay seeks to contextualize the lives of Mamluk women and weave them into the fabric of the social and economic history of Cairo.
Fay's work, which focuses on elite Mamluk women who once held slave status, builds upon the work that Daniel Crecelius, Jane Hathaway, and Ehud Toledano have done on slavery in 18th- and 19th-century Egyptian society. With respect to the economy and involvement in city life, she follows in the footsteps of Peter Gran, Nelly Hanna, Afaf Marsot, and André Raymond. Fay's first aim is to bring elite Mamluk women more fully into the historiography of 18th-century Cairo. Her second is to de-exoticize Middle Eastern women generally and the harem specifically. In her introduction, she links the usage of oppressed Muslim women and Western foreign policy historically and contemporarily: “By deconstructing Orientalist perceptions of women in the past, [we can] erode the foundation on which stereotypes of contemporary Muslim women have been constructed” (p. 5).
One of the strengths of this work is that the historiography of Middle Eastern slavery and Middle Eastern women is not “ghettoized” into a subfield or specialty that only those working in it would understand. Fay has cast the net widely to grasp the experiences of women as legal entities, as property holders, and as family members. By evaluating 18th-century Ottoman legal practice and comparing the lives of Mamluk women in Egypt, enslaved women in the American south, and elite women in 18th-century England, Fay argues that Mamluk women had distinct advantages over the others in terms of power and authority. Mamluk women make for an interesting comparison with these groups since they had slave origins but belonged to the ruling elite. Their ability to accumulate and distribute wealth in a system where power among men easily fragmented made them important in maintaining networks of power. Furthermore, Fay compares the economic and charitable activities of Mamluk women to those of women in other parts of the Ottoman Empire. For example, while similar percentages of women (20%–37%) endowed awqāf in many Ottoman settings, the majority of Mamluk women (57.6%) who set up charitable endowments had more than one asset or share in one asset, while a minority 42.4 percent were smaller-scale investors. In other Ottoman contexts, by contrast, few women who invested qualified for middle- and large-scale investment brackets
The scope of Fay's work is far-reaching, although at times she poses questions that she does not fully answer. In the chapter on “Mamluk Women and the Economy,” the author raises the issue of whether or not the designation of “white” and “black” in documents is an indication of a “racialized system of slavery” (p. 147). Fay goes on to argue that the endowment deeds themselves show a preference for white women as slaves and concubines. She suggests that “a system of racial privilege [was] developed within the Mamluk slave system” (p. 148) but she does not elaborate on this argument. Later in the same chapter, Fay notes that most awqāf stipulate that “children, male and female, would receive equal shares and slaves, male and female, black and white, would also share equally” (p. 152). Nevertheless, she notes that two powerful Mamluks made stipulations that their black female slaves and their children would be disinherited for marrying outside the household, and that they would inherit half of what their white and black male counterparts inherited. Furthermore, Fay speculates that marriage arranged outside the household or kinship group was generally reserved for white slaves from the Caucasus. A freed black slave would take her property and her children, which would break the bond with her former master. She would not be in a strategic, “fictive” kinship alliance that would keep her tied to him. Rather, she would be a client, and Fay concludes that “the threat of disinheritance” would be “a powerful incentive for marrying within the household's kin group” (p. 152). She does not explain, however, why differential treatment was not more widely practiced, if, indeed, there was a preference for white slaves. If there was an expression of preference for whiteness, how was this expressed? Were there simply higher numbers of white slaves taken as concubines, or did some other group of practices and attitudes confirm this bias?
While Fay is comprehensive in examining comparative literature on women, slavery, veiling, and seclusion, it is noteworthy that the volume does not include any discussion of the recent anthology edited by Marilyn Booth, Harem Histories: Envisioning Places and Living Spaces (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 2010), which reinforces some of the basic themes and arguments presented in the work. In fact, the bibliography in Unveiling the Harem appears a bit dated and the index slim.
Notwithstanding these minor criticisms, the work will be extremely useful in graduate and upper-division undergraduate courses on gender and/or social history. Given the author's comparative approach, the book might also be useful in courses on gender and slavery outside Middle East studies.
