Renée Jeffery’s innovative new book, Amnesties, Accountability, and Human Rights, grapples with the persistence of amnesties despite the normative shift toward accountability over the past two decades. Through careful empirical analysis, Jeffery argues that the resilience of amnesties can be traced to their role in: 1) safeguarding transitions to democracy during the last quarter of the twentieth century; 2) facilitating the truth component of truth and reconciliation commissions in the late 1990s and early 2000s; and 3) mediating violence, particularly civil conflict. The combination of Jeffery’s careful theoretical argumentation and empirical analysis makes this book a compelling read for anyone interested in the politics of transitional justice, the tensions between competing norms in the international system, and the future of human rights.
Jeffery, like other transitional justice scholars, argues that amnesties in particular and transitional justice mechanisms in general provide important political tools for domestic political elites (see, for example, Jelena Subotic 2009; Leigh Payne, Tricia Olsen and Andrew Reiter 2010; Francesca Lessa and Leigh Payne 2012; and Louise Mallinder 2012). While perhaps less optimistic about the so-called justice cascade than others (e.g., Kathryn Sikkink 2011), Jeffery’s analysis points to the persistent back-and-forth between long-term normative change and short-term political considerations. While Jeffery’s work argues that amnesties remain and are likely to remain a cornerstone of justice after atrocity, her careful research also demonstrates that the political space for amnesties is shrinking.
Jeffery employs a multi-method, interpretive approach that combines large-N analysis with case studies that range from Africa and East Asia to the Southern Cone and Central America. Her large-N analysis contributes to a growing body of databases on transitional justice, such as the Transitional Justice Database, produced by Payne, Olsen and Reiter; Mallinder’s Amnesty Database; and Sikkink and Hunjoon Kim’s trials database. Notably, Jeffery’s amnesties database conflicts in some cases with the Mallinder and Payne et al databases. While Jeffery does explore these inconsistencies (p. 35), there is much more for future scholars to mine here, particularly as quantitative analyses of transitional justice become more mainstream in the discipline.
Jeffery uses the quantitative analyses to document the changing trends regarding amnesties. Namely, the data traces the beginning of the popularity of amnesties as a way to facilitate the transition to democracy, through the facilitating of truth and reconciliation commissions, and finally to the question of mediating civil conflict. Once she establishes the basic trends of amnesties, Jeffery dives into illustrative case studies that demonstrate the ways in which amnesties have been deployed over the past quarter century. While her interpretative approach does not lend itself to generalizability, the breadth of the analysis convincingly demonstrates some broad patterns about the politics of amnesties.
One of the innovations of Jeffery’s analysis is that she does not simply identify the number of amnesties but instead considers them in their political context. She generates a tripartite classification schema that groups amnesties into one of the three aforementioned categories: amnesties to facilitate transitions to democracy, amnesties to support truth and reconciliation commissions, and amnesties to induce an end to violent conflict. This disaggregation by their perceived political utility suggests that amnesties are indeed quite versatile, and that this versatility goes a long way in explaining amnesties’ continued relevance.
In addition to demonstrating the ways in which a variety of political actors have come to rely on amnesties, Jeffery’s careful research also shows how others have pushed back against amnesties. While Jeffery documents this debate from the perspective of a handful of scholars and policymakers from the late 1980s through today, the idea that amnesties will continue to have a place within the justice cascade is perhaps most salient in Jeffery’s discussion of the ICC. As the former head prosecutor of the ICC, Luis Moreno-Ocampo, argued with respect to Uganda, “Basically, we are doing a case on four people, all the others could be handled using different mechanisms” (p. 153; originally cited in Greenawalt 2009, p. 142). By framing the ICC as a mechanism for justice for a select few individuals, Moreno-Ocampo kept the door open for amnesties in Uganda. It thus seems that even those working at the highest levels of transitional justice are unable or unwilling to affirmatively eliminate the possibility of amnesties. This high-level ambiguity allows other actors to continue to use amnesties to delay or evade accountability.
Implicit in these actors’ unwillingness to eschew amnesties altogether is an underlying question about the efficacy of amnesties. Despite the fact that the normative tide has turned against amnesties, outgoing perpetrators, mediators in ongoing conflicts and the orchestrators of truth and reconciliation commissions continue to rely on them. Is this indicative of their success? In the penultimate section of the book, Jeffery argues, “Amnesties … persist because of the outcomes they are thought to produce for peace, democracy, and truth. But do they actually bring about these sorts of outcomes?” (p. 207). Earlier in the text she notes, “Arguments for and against amnesties thus seemed to have been based on ‘soft’ predictions of outcomes, informed speculations based on limited numbers of cases, and theoretical relationships between amnesties, prosecutions, democratization and the rule of law” (p. 87).
Jeffery’s analysis suggests that shared perceptions about the ability of amnesties to bring about democratization or truth or peace exceed their actual success rate. Moreover, given the many cases of amnesties being overturned that Jeffery documents, amnesties are no long an effective shield from accountability. These implications raise two questions for future work. First, do amnesties actually produce the outcomes they are meant to produce? And second, if they do not, why do perceptions about their efficacy continue, both on the part of those who might be held criminally accountable if not for their immunity as well as for those who use the promise of amnesties to facilitate other political goals? This second question is quite closely aligned with Jeffery’s central thesis—amnesties persist because they fill important political roles—but inquires after the gap between the intent of amnesties (Jeffery’s principal enterprise) and their actual effectiveness.
Ultimately, Jeffery reminds us that amnesties are a fundamentally political undertaking. So, too, are all transitional justice mechanisms, including accountability trials, which the text occasionally relegates to the judicial realm. Accountability trials can serve many other purposes that are just as “political” as amnesties, including removing potential threats from the political sphere by ensnaring them in long trials and ultimately jail sentences, demonstrating a commitment to the rule of law and human rights to outside observers, and empowering the judicial system to support the executive’s agenda. Although Jeffery’s work focused on amnesties and their political utility, Amnesties, Accountability and Human Rights provides the architecture for a new generation of transitional justice scholars to ask how the normative frameworks around and perceived utility of transitional justice mechanisms, especially accountability trials, are shifting. I recommend it highly.
