In recent decades, the study of Hispano-Roman villas has received increased attention due to the vast quantity of information available, mainly as a result of the continuous archaeological excavations that have been carried out in the region. In spite of this, villas in the Roman province of Hispania Baetica are conspicuous by their almost complete absence from both national and international contexts of research, with the exception of a few paradigmatic case studies. In an attempt to address this issue, the work Las villas romanas de la Bética, coordinated by Dr Rafael Hidalgo, constitutes the crystallisation of two research projects and a conference. It successfully fulfils the aim of filling an academic lacuna by providing a compendium of both rural and urban settlements from the ‘province of Baetica’. Given the diversity of contributions — 124 papers, written by 86 scholars and archaeologists — H.’s enormous endeavour in putting all of them together into these two volumes deserves recognition.
One aspect that initially catches the reader's attention is the territorial limits covered by the work. Although the (shifting) boundaries of Hispania Baetica are clearly stated within the volume, some case studies do not follow this criterion and are located within the boundaries of part (and not the totality) of the present-day autonomous community of Andalucía. As a result, only a part of the ancient province of Baetica is covered, while some territories belonging to the province of Tarraconensis are included. Although this problem is clearly stated at the very beginning of Volume I (18–20), the reasons provided are not fully consistent, and the partial use of such a modern territorial demarcation may potentially confuse non-specialist readers. As for the use of the Latin term villa, it must be noted that it is merely a convention to apply this term to the archaeological evidence. The limitations inherent in the application of such a Latin term to varied archaeological evidence do appear to be generally recognised among contributors (e.g. I, 20–3; 39–40).
Volume I presents the current state of affairs regarding studies focusing on villas and other types of rural settlements within Hispania Baetica. The themes include the region's economy and types of productive settlements; the diversity between rural and suburban sites; the representative architecture, baths, building techniques or associated funerary contexts; the discrete character of the decor; the fate of such sites in Late Antiquity; and debates on their current dynamisation. Although repetition of information given in the catalogue in Volume II can be perceived throughout Volume I, the first volume successfully contributes to scholarship by providing a comprehensive, critically informed discourse with novel and traditionally disregarded aspects, such as a thorough chronological overview of painted decor in this territory (I, 491–550). In both volumes, the extent to which functions attributed to some spaces are dependent upon ancient textual sources stands out; on the inconsistent use of Latin terms to attribute functions, see A. Chavarría in K. Bowes and M. Kulikowski (eds), Hispania in Late Antiquity. Current Perspectives (2005), 535 n. 18; P. M. Allison, AJA 105 (2001), 186. Besides this, Volume I provides valuable fundamentals upon which future research can be built.
Volume II consists of a gazetteer that presents a sample of 104 sites within Andalucía, organised according to their location in the present-day provinces. Although such a structure facilitates the use of the catalogue, it must be noted that not all the entries specify to which ancient conuentus iuridicus within the province of Baetica the villa/rural settlement belonged. As evidenced from the very beginning, and consistently stated in H.’s introduction, the disparity of case studies in each province is a reflection of the intensity of the archaeological work and research within Andalucía.
One aspect that complicates the use of the catalogue is that entries, although similar, do not follow a unified format. In this regard, it becomes difficult to look for specific aspects across entries, and each site description corresponds to the respective authors’ criteria. In spite of this, the general quality and quantity of data presented — in many cases previously unpublished — stands out. My main criticism of some entries pertains to the lack of information concerning decor: for instance, in the villa of Los Vergeles (Granada), the authors do not mention the presence of a border in (the so-called) opus figlinum technique, surrounding some of the pavements in the main representational rooms (Cat. 34: II, 291–4). In addition, in some cases, factual errors are present, such as in the villa of Mitra (Cabra), where it is suggested that the four sculptures found in late antique contexts belonged to the initial phase of the villa (the phase prior to the redevelopment seen after the mid-third century a.d.) (Cat. 19: II, 189–90). With regard to the latter, in my opinion, the fact that some of the sculptures have a second-century a.d. date does not prove that they were on display in the initial phase of the villa, since they could have been acquired at a later date. In other cases, such as in the villa of Salar (Granada), the decorative nymphaeum from the main representational space is inconsistently associated with a sanctuary consecrated to the nymphs (Cat. 40: II, 318). A noteworthy aspect of the catalogue is the way references have been organised at the end of each entry, constituting a very useful tool for researchers; that is, a separate section dedicated to studies relevant to the archaeological site is present, in addition to the bibliographical references used in the text.
Volume II unequivocally surpasses previous attempts to create a gazetteer for the study of villas and other types of rural settlements from the province of Baetica (see e.g., A. Fornell, Las villas romanas de la Andalucía meridional y del Estrecho (1999)) by presenting a representative sample resulting from a thorough process of data collection and collation. As stated in chs 1 and 3 of Volume I and in ch. 105 of Volume II, the thorough process of data collation also resulted in the creation of a related database, a digital archive and a GIS. The related database, despite being modelled upon previous ones, aims to create a unified corpus of information useful for scholars (II, 783). With regard to this, my main criticism is its non-open access character; furthermore, there is a lack of information within the work on accessing/consulting it. The potential of GIS for these types of studies is well presented in ch. 3. Finally, the general bibliography presented at the end of Volume II and the index of authors, with emails included to facilitate contacting them for further information, is worth mentioning.
Overall, both volumes present a good compendium and the information appears well cross-referenced between them. The work is complemented with a copious quantity of photos, drawings and plans, in black and white; these sometimes lack essential information such as the north arrow or scale; some chapters bear typos or use a different referencing system (e.g. ch. 2). Despite these points and the aforementioned critiques, the volumes are a welcome and long overdue successful addition to the study of Hispano-Roman, and especially Baetican, villas; this work will appeal to a wide spectrum of Roman archaeologists, students of classical antiquity and other non-academic readers interested in the field. The volumes constitute an essential base upon which further specialised studies may be developed, as stated at the very beginning and end of the work.
