In the mid-nineteenth century, municipalities throughout the world developed and improved systems to bring water to homes. Although the clean fresh water could be a great improvement, the service pipes through which it passed were usually made of lead, a toxic metal. The Great Lead Water Pipe Disaster is the story of the pernicious effects of lead-tainted water and of the political and social frameworks that enabled this public health catastrophe to continue largely unabated and ignored for nearly 150 years. Werner Troesken draws on historical accounts, medical research, and social science research to weave a compelling tale of public denial, regrettable decisions, and disease. Troesken employs varied disciplinary frameworks to bring an important environmental disaster to light.
The book opens with a sensational story of the suspicious death of a man in New York City in 1868. After intentional poisoning was ruled out, a chemist hypothesized that continuous exposure to lead from lead water pipes may have been the cause. The New York Herald urged official investigation of the safety of lead pipes, but only modest inquiries were made. In fact, New York City did not address its lead pipes until 1992, more than 100 years later. This story effectively sets the stage for a thorough investigation of the significance of lead water pipes. The story's broad outline—an unexplained death, a modest inquiry, and little general concern—recurs throughout the book.
To lay the groundwork, Troesken provides an excellent review of the extensive medical literature on the effects of lead on cardiovascular function, fetal health, pregnancy, and other health troubles. Troesken also establishes a useful benchmark, showing that a few glasses of Massachusetts tap water circa 1900 contained about as much lead as black-market abortion pills. At this point we are introduced to two physicians, Alfred Swann and Norman Porritt, who tried, unsuccessfully, to raise awareness of water-related lead poisoning. We are also introduced to a town, Milford, Massachusetts, that addressed the potential threat relatively quickly, and two cities, New York and Glasgow, that did not do so for more than a century. Through these period accounts and other appeals to a wide-ranging literature, Troesken paints a nuanced picture of a silent epidemic in which lead's pervasive yet often imperceptible and varying effects usually evaded notice. The next chapters round out the discussion by outlining the role of politicians, legal institutions, and other key actors (such as plumbers, journalists, and scientists) in perpetuating the use of lead and the myth of its safety.
The most important contribution of Troesken's work is in identifying and describing a long-ignored public health disaster of epic proportions. The Great Lead Water Pipe Disaster is indeed a new story, and one that grips the reader, covers a long period of time, and spans locations across the globe. We are told of cities in which people were continuously exposed to lead levels that were hundreds or thousands of times the current EPA standard. Troesken adeptly weaves a dramatic narrative of the insidious effects of lead. Indeed, he does this so effectively that at points the narrative becomes rather heartbreaking as the same mistakes are repeated over and over again by different actors in different places and times, from Glasgow to Cape Town.
As readers of Troesken's vivid account, we watch the crisis unfold in seeming painful clarity. It is not that there were no canaries in the coal mine. On the contrary, there were several flocks of canaries; they were just ignored as they sickened and died. We are naturally led to wonder how this public health disaster remained largely neglected for so long. This is where Troesken's sophisticated analysis shines: by deftly drawing on varied disciplinary frameworks, he provides insight into the forces and structures that enabled this silent tragedy to unfold. First, because lead has so many biological effects, the clear stamp of lead was often not obvious. Illnesses were reported and some doctors spoke up, but the illnesses were explained away and the doctors were discounted. Through these narratives, Troesken's account highlights the crucial importance of close adherence to the scientific method: the vast majority of physicians did not see what they were not looking for.
Troesken also argues that ideology contributed to the persistence of the use of lead pipes. In the late 1800s and early 1900s, the public health community was focused on reducing the transmission of infectious diseases such as cholera or typhoid. In contrast to the vague effects of lead, the toll from these diseases (death) was obvious and the solution (clean water) was also obvious. So it is easy to understand how new water systems were deemed great successes, despite the fact that they may have provided a steady dose of toxic lead. Moreover, we see why public officials were content to appeal to the scientific “doctrine of protective power,” which held (incorrectly) that lead pipes were almost always safe.
One might think that litigation could be the last bulwark against the insidious effects of lead: if someone could be held responsible, perhaps the situation could be improved (indeed, Coase would certainly agree). Troesken answers this query as well, drawing on legal accounts to show that ill-informed consumers usually bore all risk associated with lead pipes, resulting in a situation in which even simple and effective strategies were not pursued.
In the end, Troesken's sophisticated use of multiple disciplinary frameworks— medicine, economics, history, political science, law—creates a nuanced and compelling portrayal of this series of important events. The only fault I find with the book is that, in some cases, it is too restrained. The author could have incorporated more econometric analysis in the text (it is currently relegated to the appendices). Particularly in cases in which inferior historical evidence is recounted in detail, economists would likely find it refreshing to see a nice regression with sound identification. Many readers might also appreciate a more complete assessment of the role of lead pipes in public health history, particularly in the mortality transition. Most importantly, this reviewer would like to see the author go further when discussing the book's broader implications. These implications appear to be substantial, but while Troesken gives us enticing leads he does not always complete the thought.
In sum, The Great Lead Water Pipe Disaster is a powerful narrative that elucidates the complex anatomy of political inaction and social denial in the face of grave public costs. It has far-reaching ramifications for public policy and for environmental disasters of many kinds, and should be of great interest to readers concerned with public health, the environment, politics, or history.
