By centring on texts and the textual, Averil Cameron stated in a review of Michel Foucault's Histoire de la sexualité, Christianity demands and attracts ‘a hermeneutical process of such intensity that it tends to become an end in itself’ (JRS 76 (1986): 268–9). Raphael Cadenhead's The Body and Desire illustrates the continuing value of Cameron's remarks even now, more than thirty years after the first three volumes of Foucault's generative Histoire first appeared. Published in 2018, the very same year as Les aveux de la chair, the final, posthumous instalment of the Histoire, C.'s study sets out to resist the ‘excesses’ of decades of postmodern, Foucault-inspired readings of Gregory of Nyssa by presenting a chronological restatement of Gregory's entire œuvre. The body and desire were at the centre of Gregory's thought, C. argues, but not because he was concerned about gender and sexuality per se. Instead, Gregory's project involved the pursuit of an ‘erotic transformation’ in response to an ‘ascetical theology’ (C.'s terminology) that linked spiritual intimacy to disciplined self-mastery.
The Body and Desire begins with an introduction and prelude outlining the theoretical and historical orientation of the book. Eisegesis characterises the twentieth-century return of Gregory to the centre of the study of early Christianity, C. avers, and therefore a more comprehensive and less anachronistic account of what Gregory actually argued is in order. Divided into three parts, the main body of the study answers the introductory chapters by presenting an account of the maturing of Gregory's ascetical theology over time, with his journey from youth to old age interpreted as a guide to the development of his thought. What the saint began in De virginitate (371 c.e.) reached full flower in De vita Moysis (392) and In Canticum canticorum (391–394), as Gregory moved from a valorisation of celibacy over married life (chs 1–3), through grief at the loss of his siblings and a concomitant adjustment to his anthropology (chs 4–6), to a theory of the soul's ascent that invited all Christians, celibate or not, to strive for intimacy with Christ (chs 7–8). Throughout, close readings of Gregory are marshalled against a series of interpretive errors, including: the overidentification of pederasty with virginity (52); the failure to integrate Gregory's teachings on celibacy within his larger disciplinary scheme (61); the confusion of ‘contemporary typological accounts of sexual identity’ with Gregory's ‘moral evocations of male and female characteristics’ (68–9); the identification of fraternal love with sexual desire (137); and an inability to recognise the triumph of female passion in the Virgin Bride of Christ (145). The conclusion offers advice for a more correct repurposing of Gregory's theology and ethics for the contemporary age: Nyssen's insights should encourage Christians to recognise that bodily practices are vehicles of moral transformation with social consequences. Only by overcoming the ‘slavery to the passions’ can (rich) Christians discern ‘the face of Christ in the poor’ (160). The volume is rounded out by a useful chronological appendix, extensive notes, a bibliography and an index. This is a handsomely produced book, volume four in the Christianity in Late Antiquity series of the North American Patristics Society.
C. should be congratulated for his thorough investigation of Gregory's theological language and commitments. His analysis leads to important insights about the saint's repurposing of Plato's Symposium, for example, and a thoughtful account of the impact of what was a long life on one man's theological reflections. His anxiety about anachronism, however, reveals just how poorly he understands the real challenge of Foucault. From a Foucauldian perspective, every interpretation involves an anachronistic attempt to impose a direction on what has come before (e.g. Language, Counter-Memory, Practice: Selected Essays and Interviews, (1977), 151–2). A desire to set the record straight in the face of ‘exoticized reading’ (12) and ‘ever-new and ever-subversive gender theories’ (158) should therefore be recognised for what it is: an attempt to reorient the writings of a fourth-century Christian saint-impresario toward Cadenhead's own purposes. Accusing others of anachronism while insisting that some anachronisms are more correct than others reinstates the divide between a narrow historical theology and a ‘secular’ early Christian studies that The Body and Desire was ostensibly intended to bridge (12), exacerbating a rivalry that Cameron has also described (JECS 28.2 (2020), 283–302). Gregory's writings are complex, engaging and capable of supporting many diverse, defensible interpretations, including by Foucault himself (Les aveux de la chair, 177–205, 251–4, 295–9). The valorisation of a ‘disciplined’ reading that mistakes its subject for its forgone conclusions, however, does not undermine the feminist and queer readings of scholars like Virginia Burrus, Sarah Coakley and Verna Harrison — particular targets of Cadenhead's critique — so much as explain why such interpretations have been wanted.
