Saul Dubow's study focuses on the development of science among English-speaking settlers in the Cape Colony from 1820, through union (of South Africa) in 1910, up to the victory of the Afrikaner nationalists in 1948, examining how these changes shaped ideas about national identity. The latter part of the book brings the story up to 2000, a period that saw the decline of the liberal ‘South Africanism’ developed in the preceding period.
Dubow's description of how a Cape colonial identity was forged is one of the book's strongest contributions – a meticulous reconstruction of the development of a network of individuals, publications, societies and institutions. The British colonial government at the Cape was conservative and autocratic, and the settlers soon felt neglected and looked down upon. They expressed themselves through the establishment of a free press and the creation of a public sphere by means of libraries, journals, scientific societies, art galleries and other institutions. There was no powerful aristocracy to hold back the mercantile and agrarian middle class, and while there was rivalry between the Dutch- and English-speakers, they were united in wanting to protect and develop their racial hegemony. What Dubow calls ‘knowledge-based institutions’ provided opportunities for collective advancement and individual distinction. Prominent citizens and the governor himself would give the annual address at the South African Library, and among the lower echelons of society the amateur collector could make important contributions to knowledge and colonial pride by placing interesting finds in the South African Museum. The founding of the Cape Monthly Magazine greatly boosted the growth of an anglophone colonial intelligentsia, disseminating a wide variety of information on everything from literary works to disciplines ranging from botany to geology and anthropology. Through the Monthly the Cape intelligentsia built up a collective sense of self and narratives of national existence.
The alliance forged in the 1870s between Cecil Rhodes and Hofmeyer's Afrikaner Bond represented the maturity of Cape colonial nationalism. This alliance was shattered by Rhodes's reversion to militant imperialism in pursuit of capitalist aims in 1895. Patriotic colonialists, both English- and Afrikaans-speaking, tried to defend their legal and constitutional traditions, but the South African War of 1899–1902 was a further blow to their alliance. After the war, Dubow argues, the ideology of South Africanism ‘emerged to inhabit the space left by a retreating imperialism and a temporarily broken republicanism’ (p. 5). Social Darwinist ideas were used to emphasize the shared Teutonic roots of the British and the Afrikaners, rather than, as previously, to deplore the degeneracy of the latter. Black Africans, in this view, were clearly further down the evolutionary ladder. In this context, Dubow argues that science was used to express universality and progress within the imperial ‘chain of civilization’ (p. 6), and was regarded as a means of uniting moderate Afrikaners and British colonials in a positive and progressive patriotism. Leading magnates and politicians promoted significant scientific and cultural projects. Preservationist and conservationist movements led to the founding of the Kruger National Park, and a patriotic pride in the South African landscape was evoked, with Table Mountain as the ultimate symbol of national unity. At the 1929 meeting of the South African and British associations for the advancement of science, Smuts celebrated what he called the ‘South Africanisation of science’ (cited on p. 8).
Dubow shows that the First World War reopened ethnic divisions and challenged South Africanism, with the Afrikaner republican Hertzog's national determinism winning supporters from Smuts's pro-imperial stance. The war saw a consolidation and increased reach of the state, which began to sponsor scientific research. In the interwar period the Carnegie Corporation of New York initiated sociological research in South Africa into ‘poor whitism’, and when the corporation withdrew their funding the government replaced it with a National Research Council, founded in 1938. The need to mobilize for the Second World War, and keep up morale by offering a vision for a better future society, led the Smuts government to integrate social and scientific planning, drawing on academic experts, and to found institutions such as the Council for Industrial and Scientific Research. This reinforced relationships between the government, industry and the universities. These relationships and their technocratic assumptions were in turn put to work by the apartheid government from the 1950s, in the service of white, and particularly Afrikaner, supremacy. This development put paid to the inclusive notion of South Africanism, and the government clamped down on civic institutions like the press, universities and churches.
Dubow pays little attention to Afrikaner and African nationalisms, concentrating instead on what he argues are the neglected ‘political traditions that held the centre ground’ (p. 11). His final chapter sketches a rather different phase, glossed as the ‘renationalization of knowledge’ (pp. 247–8), touching in passing on the politics of indigenous knowledge in contemporary South Africa. This phase (1948–2000) saw ‘the eclipse of Smutsian South Africanism’ (p. 247). Key episodes in ‘apartheid’ science are covered, notably the building of gigantic concrete dams and water schemes, the successful development of nuclear power, and propagandist claims and arguments surrounding Chris Barnard's pioneering heart transplants. The book concludes with a discussion of the ‘Africanisation’ of knowledge under the African National Congress government post-1996, a new and more benevolent nationalization of knowledge under the aegis of President Mbeki's (now apparently defunct) African Renaissance, and how this has played out – less benevolently – in the context of the debate around HIV/AIDS.
Dubow's grasp of the historiography and his deft use of archival and secondary sources make this an invaluable book for intellectual historians. More broadly, he is illuminating on the ways in which science has been used by successive colonial and postcolonial elites to establish, assert or bolster their identities and authority, and, as in his previous book Scientific Racism in Modern South Africa (Cambridge, 1995), he shows there is much exciting work to be done on the history of science in the region. In particular, his Cape focus, while justified, leaves much to be done on other parts of South Africa.
