In Latinx Theater in the Times of Neoliberalism, Patricia Ybarra examines how Latinx playwrights have confronted the economic violence of “savage capitalism” from 1992 to the present (ix). Ybarra offers close readings of texts from US-based Latinx playwrights writing about Mexico and Cuba in relation to the United States and convincingly argues that theatre, despite and because of its limitations, offers a particularly effective site through which the consequences of neoliberalism can be made palpable. As such, Ybarra asks that her readers consider the playwrights as theorists who employ the languages of theatricality to expose what it is to live with sustained economic violence, be such violence hypervisible—like the spectacle of femicide in Juárez—or silent, as in the slow starvation of Cubans during the Special Period.
In the critical introduction, Ybarra articulates neoliberalism as an escalation of capitalism, the effects of which include NAFTA, immigration policy shifts, the industrialization and militarization of borders, and austerity programs. She point outs that neoliberalism is most insidious in its involvement in subject formation. Under neoliberalist conditions, daily life is increasingly economically instrumentalized, a process that erodes distinctions between social and national belonging and between economic participation and agency. Historians and scholars have often attributed the violence of neoliberalism to a failure of the state. Ybarra contends it is the opposite. Such extreme violence depends on states strong enough to participate in neoliberal practices of “capitalist accumulation,” a realization many of the plays she examines articulate (6).
In Chapter 1, “‘Never Any Other Time but This Time No World but This World,’ or Staging Indigeneity in Neoliberal Times,” Ybarra focuses on Latinx writers’ engagement with indigenous “culture, cosmology, and identity” (xii). Ybarra devotes most of the chapter to an extended analysis of indigeneity in Cherríe Moraga's work. Contextualizing key pieces of Moraga's dramatic oeuvre in relation to her poetry, essays, and collaborations, Ybarra situates Moraga as firmly transnational in her political thinking and theatrical aesthetics. Particularly compelling is Ybarra's careful tracking of how Moraga's changes to The Hungry Woman, made between 2000 and 2005, expose a nuanced struggle with “secular teleology” (43) as an ineffectual strategy of representation. Similarly realized by the Zapatistas in Chiapas, Ybarra sees this as a turn away from underexamined engagement with indigenous histories to a postrevolutionary, decolonizing enactment of indigenous cosmologies, a counterpoint to the neoliberalist consumption and instrumentalization of indigenous bodies.
During Cuba's Special Period, extreme poverty plagued the population. In desperation, thirty thousand Cubans fled the country on rafts, identifying themselves as balseros. As Castro and Clinton reacted to the situation, the balseros revealed anew the fraught legacies of US–Cuba economic-political relations. Multiple Latinx playwrights wrote about the balseros crisis. In Chapter 2, “Havana Is (Not) Waiting: Staging the Impasse in Cuban American Drama about Cuba's Special Period,” Ybarra analyzes work by María Irene Fornés, Eduardo Machado, and Nilo Cruz, among others, and focuses on representations of time, travel, and commerce/exchange. Deftly adapting the work of Lauren Berlant's Cruel Optimism, Ybarra demonstrates that the plays expose how neoliberal policies create and maintain constant affective states of low-level anxiety on a transnational scale.
In Chapter 3, “Neoliberalism Is a Serial Killer,” Ybarra examines plays about femicide in Juárez. Ybarra focuses on each play's engagement with economic violence in relation to an ethics of representation, including challenges to the Latin American testimonio. Her close readings of texts are particularly acute in this chapter, and she offers unflinching yet generous interpretations of the plays’ complicated and contradictory images. For example, Ybarra tracks how Marisela Treviño Orta, in Braided Sorrow, writes Alma as a protagonist both exceptional and ambivalent, but one whose very name nonetheless demands we acknowledge the damage done to both bodies and souls under neoliberal conditions.
Beginning with Octavio Solis's Santos y Santos (about the pre-NAFTA 1980s) and moving through plays by Victor Cazares, Tanya Saracho, and Matthew Paul Olmos, Chapter 4, “Swallowing the ’80s (W)Hole: Millennial Drama of the Narcoguerra,” gathers up many of the ideas of the foregoing chapters in its focus on the narcoguerra, ostensibly represented as US–Mexico-centric but profoundly hemispheric in its economic reach and violence. Ybarra demonstrates that theatre's inability to represent the massive violence of the narcoguerra in the Americas serves as a historiographical intervention that destabilizes mainstream representations of neoliberalism in the Americas, including heteronormative, patriarchal, and heroic “performance[s] of entrepreneurship” (193). In the conclusion of the book, Ybarra drives home this point, reiterating her adamant call that we must not be satisfied with representations of our violent present. Rather, we must look to the theatre to imagine our way out.
Ybarra offers a number of content-based and methodological interventions. She intentionally uses Latin American scholarship to analyze US “cultural production,” rather than the more familiar reverse strategy (23). Simultaneously, she departs from a focus on ethnic identity in order to emphasize the ways that Latinx theatre enacts critiques of global politics and economic violence. Both moves prioritize Latinx theatre as a site of theory in its own right, dependent on neither US nor European aesthetics, dramaturgies, and criticism. The inclusion of a chapter on Cuba serves as a useful counterpoint to the other three chapters, centered on Mexico. That said, more than a single chapter devoted to Cuba, or an explicit rationale for not returning to Cuba, would have been welcome, particularly as the book's treatment of plays about US–Mexico relations under neoliberalism is so robust.
In Latinx Theater in the Times of Neoliberalism, Ybarra powerfully articulates the urgency of apprehending neoliberal violence as systemic. She also convincingly argues for the value of the theatre's—and, in particular, Latinx theatre's—unique ability to critique economic violence and imagine other ways of being. The book promises contributions to multiple fields, from theatre history to Latinx cultural studies. Yet even more compelling is the fact that her work offers clear models for taking up these modes of analysis, effectively issuing a firm and generous invitation to join her.
