This impressive and wide-ranging collection of essays makes a significant contribution to the church's mission to a wider culture in acute need of authentic hope. In a world in which optimism has been eclipsed by ambiguity, and vulnerability and fragility mark our natural and social environments, the essays of this book offer a retrieval of hope present in biblical and church tradition, which serves the contemporary public mission of the church. The product of a seminar and conference sponsored by the Seminars in Christian Scholarship programme at Calvin College, The Future of Hope brings together the reflections and proposals of theologians, social scientists, historians and philosophers and offers a stimulating interdisciplinary treatment of the ground, content, shape, scope and possibilities for a vibrant message of Christian hope to a cynical and world-weary culture.
The volume is divided into three sections, with three essays in each section. The first section provides a historical and cultural criticism of modernity. The second draws upon pre-modern articulations of Christian hope in order to address concerns and needs of contemporary culture. The third section offers distinct proposals for how Christian hope might critically engage postmodern culture.
The lead essay, ‘Progress and Abyss: Remembrances of the Future of the Modern’ by Jürgen Moltmann, ably sets the agenda for the entire volume, by insisting on the intrusive coming of God as the hope for the world and the church's social and political task as preparing the way for and bearing witness to the kingdom of God. Moltmann tells the story of modernity and hope in overarching terms and with the goal of articulating how there is indeed Christian hope for the contemporary social and political world, which in the last two centuries has seen the ascent of fantastic progress and optimism and the decline of incomparable catastrophes and crimes against humanity. Moltmann strikes familiar chords and calls the church to political action on behalf of the world and for the sake of the poor, powerless and oppressed that is empowered by hope in the coming reign of God.
Essays by Daniel Johnson and William Katerberg round out section 1. Johnson presents a sociological description of the tendency of evangelicals to gravitate towards decline narratives and negative expressions of social hope. Katerberg, building upon the work of Hans-Georg Gadamer, issues a forceful programmatic call for a new historiography to overcome modernist historiography, which silences, even kills, the past.
In one of the volume's strongest essays, Nicholas Wolterstorff opens the second section with a compelling reflection on the question of the type of hope that is required by the task of working for justice. This essay highlights the clarity of Wolterstorff's thinking as he makes critical distinctions among types of justice in order to articulate the precise content of Christian hope, as grounded in God's diverse ways of relating to the world. Wolterstorff sets his own account of hope over and against Thomas Aquinas' claim that Christian hope is hope for consummation – blessed union with God that transcends history. In Wolterstorff's judgement, this account of hope is too limiting, as it neglects real hope in the midst of the struggle for justice in this world. He summarises the storyline of the biblical narrative as an account of God's particular acts of deliverance from injustice. Wolterstorff then highlights the royal office of Jesus Christ and his kingship that consists in struggling to overcome present injustice. Wolterstorff ends his essay with a swift and harsh dismissal of any attempt to wed Christian hope with secular optimism. Here he notes a theme that appears again and again throughout the essays of the volume: Christian hope must be shaped by humility and directed to God's surprising and disruptive redemptive action.
Kevin L. Hughes carries on this theme of authentic humble Christian hope by drawing upon mystical theology and precisely the apophatic tradition. Hughes presents a compelling argument for a ‘disciplined hope’ – a hope that can ‘navigate between the presumption of claiming to know too much and the emptiness of knowing nothing at all’, and which is based on hope ‘in the infinite mystery of God’ (p. 103).
David Billings' essay ‘Natality or Advent: Hannah Arendt and Jürgen Moltmann on Hope and Politics’ creatively brings Arendt and Moltmann into conversation. However, given Moltmann's call in this volume for a socially and politically active Christianity, his argument is not entirely convincing that Moltmann needs Arendt's emphasis on the potential for the new that is within humanity in order to avoid quietistic waiting for the coming of God.
John Milbank begins the third section with a declaration of various affinities between Christian hope and postmodernity, along with suggestions for a radical redirection of postmodernity. Most significantly, Milbank insists that, in the face of the powers of today's economic and political globalisation, i.e. American empire, Christian hope lies in the counter-empire of the city of God.
The thoroughly interdisciplinary essay by Robert Paul Doede and Paul Edward Hughes integrates the disciplines of biblical theology, philosophy – M. M. Bakhtin, Martin Heidegger and Emmanuel Levinas – and photography, in order to argue for the hopeful elements of vision and the possibilities that ‘the camera can indeed function as a hermeneutical tool through which we may see our way to a new ethics of vision, a moral vision informed by transcendence, imagination, indeterminacy, and community’ (p. 199).
An exceptional essay by James K. A. Smith serves as a strong and fitting conclusion to the volume. In ‘Determined Hope: A Phenomenology of Christian Expectation’, Smith critically engages the expressions of postmodern hopefulness in the work of Jacques Derrida and Richard Rorty. Smith is unrelenting in his critique of Rorty's account of hope, specifically his judgement that history as the ground for Rorty's hope is insufficient. This leads to Smith's charge that Rorty's version of hope is illusion and wishful thinking. Along with addressing the question of the ground of postmodern hopefulness, Smith also explores the object or content of this hope. He acknowledges the reasoning behind Derrida's emphasis on the indeterminacy of justice, namely to ‘safeguard against the inevitable hubris which would want to identify a particular political system or policy with the very advent of justice’ (p. 220), and sees this as a needed correction to triumphalist Christians. However, he refuses to accept Derrida's proposal that equates determination with violence. Against Derrida, Smith presents a robust and positive account of Christian hope as confident expectation in the coming not of an indeterminate Messiah but of a determinate Messiah – Jesus Christ. The church proclaims God's demonstrated and promised faithfulness, as grounded in God's revelatory presence, particularly in the cross and resurrection of Jesus Christ, and it is God's faithfulness as manifested in Christ that serves as the ground and content of Christian hope. This proclamation offers a compelling and coherent alternative to postmodernity's groundless, empty and contentless hopefulness.
The strength of this volume is the breadth of intellectual approaches to the pressing issue of the church's public theology, action and proclamation in a world that has lost and forgotten hope. It could be improved by more precise attention to constructive, doctrinal, theological discussion and reflection, yet it could be said that it serves an important ground-clearing purpose that will give rise to further doctrinal construction. The Future of Hope thoughtfully encourages the church in her mission to proclaim boldly yet humbly the hope found in God's promises to an ambiguous, fragile, vulnerable and beleaguered world. As the closing words of the book maintain, the rigorous critical engagement with modernity and postmodernity in these essays clears the way for ‘Christians to unapologetically proclaim a hope that does not disappoint’ (p. 227).
