As we begin to grapple with the political reactions to the economic upheavals unsettling our own times, what more opportune moment than this for Classical scholars to be addressing the question of the political in our field: to take stock of the questions that we put to the ancient world, and to reconsider the definitions put by ancient authors to their understanding of the political.
This volume of essays limits its scope to the latter question — and then narrows that down even further to focus on the kinds of criticism that individual Roman authors offer of the Principate as a system of government, and, more particularly, of the individual emperors under which they write. Rather than situating literature within a larger political forcefield that encompasses gender, class and race, as the work of Tom Habinek has shown how, ‘politics’, in the hands of these editors, is defined and determined by the conscious intentions of the ancient authors included in this collection (no questions asked about the politics of what counts as literature).
The editors prepare us for the limits of their approach in their introductory essay (‘The Context’). Here, we are told, the ancient authors represented in this volume stand for the most part ‘outside’ the ideology generated by the centralized system of Roman autocrats, rather than determining its construction from within. Thus although Duncan Kennedy's seminal discussion of the ‘pro-’ and ‘anti-’ terms used to describe Augustan discourse is one of the most cited works in the introduction, the editors appear to have ignored his attempt to deconstruct the inside/outside polarity that scholars' constructions of Augustan ideology had hitherto assumed. In fact, the real ‘context’ for this volume's ensuing essays is provided by Steven Rutledge's chapter on the conditions for free speech during the Empire.
Then seven chapters on the literature of the first century b.c.e., including five on ‘Augustan’ poets, which, with the sole and significant exception of Matthew Roller's chapter on Livy, are particularly disappointing. Dominik on Virgil's ‘Geopolitics’ (for which read ‘eco-politics’: he deals not with Rome's territorial expansion, but with the impact of political violence on the Italian landscape), Bond on Horace's evolving political accommodations, and Wilson on the forms of political resistance represented by the genre of love elegy, summarize existing scholarship on these questions with varying degrees of transparency. Bond is at least strikingly open about his debts to others, quoting ten substantial portions of other scholars' work in the course of twenty pages. Throughout these chapters, the question of this volume's readership becomes a pressing one: these essays do not pretend to contribute anything new to the field and therefore do not address other scholars; but nor will they be recommended reading for students, in that their neat summaries simplify questions that teachers will want to open up and explore in more detail.
Roller's essay, however, stands out among these early chapters as an example of the best that this kind of volume can produce: a brilliantly lucid case-study of Livy's treatment of Appius Claudius Caecus, and of the ‘wheel of virtue’ through which the historian plays off this innovative figure's artes urbanae against his contemporaries' military talents. The connection that Roller makes between the shifting arenas of aristocratic competition in Livy's account of this moment in the history of the early Republic and the avenues of aristocratic competition that were being reconfigured by Augustus in the historian's own day offers a brilliant example of how to discuss the political without falling into the editors' methodological straitjacket. However, his excellent discussion of the issues involved in ‘writing politics’ at the start of this essay has the unfortunate effect of making the previous six chapters seem redundant: indeed, his assessment of how questions that focus on a particular author's opinion of the imperial regime have become outmoded and replaced by a broader definition of the political that explores the struggle for power in Rome along gender, ethnic and social lines, highlights the inadequacies of the editors' attempt to set out a methodological basis for the volume at the outset.
Discussion of the political livens up briefly as we venture out of Augustan Rome: Martha Malamud's essay is, along with Roller's, one of the highlights of the collection — a study of how Petronius and Lucan use the themes of hospitality and architecture to riff on the trope of moral decline in ways that reflect obliquely on the cultural excesses taking place in Neronian Rome. And James Ker has some insightful comments to make about the new functions that literature is forced to take on under the Principate, and about why moralizing discourse provides an effective arena for writing politics at this time. Yet as the volume proceeds, the price paid for not paying heed to the cultural materialist's view of the political becomes increasingly apparent: Steve Mason's discussion of Josephus, for example, has little to say about any form of ethnic contestation in which this author's work might participate, focusing instead on his critique of the system of hereditary succession exemplified by the Herodians and Julio-Claudians alike. And Steven Rutledge's discussion of Pliny's letters manages to focus on their author's preoccupation with acta diurna without mentioning the various forms of social anxiety that are expressed through his dealings with the quotidian.
There are signs in several of the essays included in this volume of a desire to redefine the political in ways that go beyond the restrictive view outlined by the editors in their introductory chapter. I wonder how different this volume would have looked had it been commissioned two years later. As it stands, I suspect it will come to be seen as representative of a moment of transition in scholars' attempts to redefine the politics of Latin literature. It should also serve to illustrate to readers the urgent need for the Companion and edited volume alike to aspire to a more consistent level of intellectual ambition.
