Introduction
The history of Islam in modern South Asia has largely been written through studies of texts, institutions and ideologies, caging it within a discursive framework. Consideration of the spiritual and faith-based dimensions of religion has been neglected, and consequently so has the history of religious practice. North Indian seminaries, political organisations and religious philosophers certainly articulated ideas about governance and society, but they wrote more about divinity and worship. Ideas which carried over from the institutional to the popular domain.
Sayyid Ahmed Bareilvi's movement was grounded in an effort to bring the teachings of the Quran and the example of the Prophet Muhammad to ordinary people. Sayyid Ahmed, himself a mediocre student, was linked to a venerated religious line and a seminary in Delhi which was central to the reformist movement. He argued that ‘ilm batani’ or innate wisdom was an appropriate foundation for individual practice, making the mediations of faith by the ‘learned’ unnecessary. Sayyid Ahmed has an iconic status in some modern Pakistani and north Indian Muslim intellectual traditions, a significance which has been attributed to his calls to jihad against ‘heresy’ in north India during the 1820s and his subsequent ‘martyrdom’. I propose to look beyond this simplistic reading of Sayyid Ahmed's movement to indicate the ways in which he translated highly intellectualised principles of worship into a system of locally enacted prayer and congregation, using principles of mystical devotionalism to communicate the rationale for orthodox, ritualised, individualised Muslim practice. His movement suggests some of the ways in which principles of orthodoxy defined at seminaries and in organisations and treatises were translated into popular practice.
Sayyid Ahmed used previously theoretically articulated reformist principles of Quranic study and emulation of the Prophet Muhammad as a basis for individual devotion, but explained this as a system of metaphysical thinking through a constant, daily awareness of divinity. Underlying this orthodox-mystical practice was the fraternity of village or town community on which the entire structure of reformed practice and its continuity was based. The community systemised ritual participation while at the same time providing a framework through which understanding of orthodox tenets such as prayer, fasting, undertaking the pilgrimage, giving charity and the principle of the singularity of God and the prophethood of Muhammad could be transmitted through community interpretation, leadership and authority within matters of faith which could continually be conferred, without the need for brick-and-mortar institutions of learning or political patrons.
Why another history of Sayyid Ahmed Shaheed Bareilvi?
The story of Sayyid Ahmed Shaheed who led a jihad against the Sikhs in the Pashtun north-west in 1826–31 is widely known and is often referenced as a moment of unusual and transformative political organisation and mobilisation by Muslims. Sayyid Ahmed Shaheed has long occupied a prominent position in European historiography of Indian Islam, an early landmark being the pamphlet written in 1872 by W. W. Hunter, entitled The Indian Musalmans – an accusation of ‘Wahhabi’ beliefs as underlying Muslim militarism during the anti-British uprisings of 1857 and after. Hunter claimed that Sayyid Ahmed was inspired to lead a jihad movement against Ranjit Singh's Sikh state in the Indian north-west, and encouraged anti-British rebellions in other parts of India owing to the contact he made with Wahhabis when he performed the pilgrimage in the early 1820s. After Sayyid Ahmed's death on the battlefield in the Pakhtun regions, a few of his followers remained at bases he had established in the region, refusing to return to an India which was largely coming under the control of the British.Footnote 2
Most popular accounts of Sayyid Ahmed's activities have remained focused on Sayyid Ahmed as a jihadi, notably Ayesha Jalal's recent Partisans of Allah.Footnote 3 Whether in an effort to critique the use of the term Wahhabi, or to reiterate and explore historic and modern fears about Islamic revivalism, is also a body of literature which refers to the movement as the Tariqa-i Muhammadiyya, the Path of Muhammad.Footnote 4 This term of reference was used by some colonial observers, and rightly indicated the Sufi premise for Sayyid Ahmed's activities by using the Sufi term tariqa or path to refer to Sayyid Ahmed's ‘religious order’.Footnote 5 However use of the term was misleading because it was in essence doing exactly what the term Wahhabi did – linking the movement of Sayyid Ahmed to an eighteenth-century millenarian Sufi movement of North-Africa known as the Tariqa-i Muhammadiyya which was based on mystical dreaming communion with the Prophet Muhammad as the source of metaphysical insight. The movement originated in Mecca and spread to what are now the Sudan and Libya. Because Sayyid Ahmed's followers lay across much of north India, and had taken up arms in both the Pakhtun north-west, and in Bengal in the north-east, and Sayyid Ahmed claimed mystical initiation by the prophet, his movement was thought to be linked to the Tariqa-i Muhammadiyya of the Arab world. In fact Sayyid Ahmed called his movement the Rah-i Nabuwwat. He only considered himself participant in the Tariqa-i Muhammadiyya because he too received a dream-visitation from the Prophet Muhammad.Footnote 6
Sayyid Ahmed's entire career has been written around the brief and catastrophic episode in the Pashtun regions in which he tried to create the model of the Muslim polity defined in the literature of the Waliullah line. Arriving in the Pashtun regions, then under the control of the Sikh Kingdom of Ranjit Singh, Sayyid Ahmed declared himself the Caliph-King, leader in the faith and matters of state, in a gathering of Pashtun leaders from across the region. Benefits accruing from position were that religious leaders among the Pakhtun clans read the khutba in his name, and the maliks or representatives of clans present all booty of war to him for appropriate distribution.Footnote 7 The experiment went terribly wrong when the Pashtun clans periodically turned on him, tried to poison him and then abandoned him in battle. Sayyid Ahmed's death on the battle field fighting the Sikh army at Balakot along with Shah Ismail and one hundred and forty-two other companions in 1831 has been seen the end of his movement and the failure of his scheme. But the survival of Sayyid Ahmed's movement was not based on the creation of an independent Muslim polity, or his own leadership. It survived through the system by which it introduced thinking about the self and the divine in a real world of community-based practice.
Creating a space for mystical learning and practice outside the seminary
Sufi scholarship and pedagogy was historically based in the space of the khanqah, the Sufi lodge and seminary. Prominent Sufi sages belonged to lodges which served as homes, schools for the study of language, philosophy, Quran and Hadith, and spaces for mystical meditational practices. In some Sufi traditions, seminaries would serve as spaces for recitations of devotional poetry. Unlike the makbarah, a Sufi tomb which was open to visitors and devotees to watch devotional musical and poetic performances and pray to or for a dead saint, the seminary was a private and closed space. Admission to it was only at the invitation of the head of the house, and was normally reserved for students or devotees who were pledged at the hand of the sage in bay'at, although it was also where those wishing to pay homage to, seek advice from, or bestow gifts upon a renowned sage were invited. Sufism, dominating the popular practice of Islam in early nineteenth century north-India, was for the layman based on observatory and not participatory attendance at shrines and learning and practice of devotionalism was jealously guarded by the Sufi fraternity. It was within this practitional and educational domain that Sayyid Ahmed, himself heir to the legacy of an eighteenth-century Sufi saint in Rai Bareilly, was accepted as a student by the renowned Sufi sage in Delhi, Shah Abdul Aziz (1746–1824).
Born into a family of Sunni ‘Sayyids’ who traced their descent from the Prophet Mohammad through his daughter and then her son Hassan, Sayyid Ahmed's ancestors had long proudly proclaimed their Arab ancestry.Footnote 8 Contemporary family histories highlight Sayyid Ahmed's descent from Shah Alamullah, a great mystic who spent his time between Mecca and north-India.Footnote 9 It was as a descendent of Shah Alamullah that Sayyid Ahmed was first received in Delhi and gained access to Shah Abul Aziz's seminary.Footnote 10 This institution had been set up by Shah Waliullah, the Sufi thinker of the eighteenth century who had wanted to systematically reintegrate study of Quran and hadith into Sufi practice and is credited as the father of modern reformist Muslim thinking in the Indian subcontinent. Waliullah's son, Shah Abdul Aziz, shared his father's ideas and sought to influence social and political thought through interpretations of the Quran and pronouncements on individual and social conduct. He pursued these commitments through his seminary. This institution was popularly referred to as a madrassa because of the reformist bent of its creator, and it was in his sermons at the madrassa that Shah Abdul Aziz gave religious pronouncements called fatwas, including his well known declaration that the coming of the British had made India Darul Harb or a house of war. The seminary however shared all the features of the classic seminary, including selective induction into the Sufi line, teaching of methods of mystical contemplation, philosophy and the sciences alongside language and study of the Quran and Hadith.Footnote 11
When Sayyid Ahmed applied to study with Shah Abdul Aziz, the sage sent Sayyid Ahmed instead to his brother Shah Abdul Qadir. It was only after much urging by Shah Abdul Qadir that Shah Abdul Aziz allowed Sayyid Ahmed to pledge the bay'at at his own hand and continued the latter's training in Sufi method himself.Footnote 12 Sayyid Ahmed received instruction and initiation in Qadiriyya, Naqshbandiyya and Mujaddidiyya method from Shah Abdul AzizFootnote 13 and began to study under conditions of strict personal discipline in residence at the seminary in an established tradition of studentship. Study under a Sufi master required initiates to master meditational exercises through observation and participation and also to learn Persian and Arabic and read the classical texts which privileged the ideal and the unseen over that which could be physically perceived. In addition Shah Abdul Aziz upheld a tradition of study of shari'a through fiqh literature and hadith – writing on Islamic law and compilations of verified sayings of the Prophet – produced in the Arab world, Persia and India over hundreds of years. But shortly into Sayyid Ahmed's course of study, a ‘miracle’ was said to have occurred. Upon opening a book, ‘the letters flew off the page’ and he was unable to read them. Shah Abdul Aziz was told of this incident, and dwelled on what his response should be. Finally, he declared that what had happened was a miracle and that Sayyid Ahmed must complete his programme of learning through God-granted epiphany rather than book learning.Footnote 14 In his few years of study, Sayyid Ahmed focused on divination and meditational contemplation, unable to engage in textual study owing to his ‘miraculous’ condition, akin to dyslexia. From the very start of his Sufi career, Sayyid Ahmed was developing a system of personal practice that excluded the complex literary, philosophical and medical knowledge that his teacher Shah Abdul Aziz was capable of imparting.Footnote 15
Around 1812, Sayyid Ahmed left the seminary to join the lashkar or army of Amir Khan, the Nawab of Tonk. He began to gain a reputation as a camp sage as he would prophetically anticipate the location at which the army would camp and could predict before the horn was sounded when the army would decamp. His sense of camaraderie with his fellow soldiers meant that his allegiance, his first insights and his testaments to future events were expressed first to these friends, and their meaning debated around the camp fire. He offered his skills to help other soldiers or tradesmen or visitors survive poverty and hunger through good advice, prayer, and the magical ability to make four spoons-full of lentils feed thirty men.Footnote 16 Sayyid Ahmed wrote wazifas or ‘prescriptions’ – magical combinations of God's names drawn on grids on papers. Writing wazifas, he helped a man get rid of debt taken on because of British taxation demands on his lands, and gave another man a rupee coin which, if it was never spent, would bring great wealth to its holder.Footnote 17 He ran his hands over sick people and read prayers over water which he then gave them to drink, causing them to become well again. His prayers caused a blind man to see again, sick oxen to be able to pull carts again, and a dried up cow to produce milk again.
Sayyid Ahmed's demonstrations were considered to be more than the tricks of street fakirs or ascetics. He was well regarded as a Sayyid (a descendent of the Prophet Muhammad), for his association with the seminaries of Delhi and as a soldier of great military acumen and courage, and he lived and worked alongside those who sought his counsel. Unlike the other-worldly ascetics living in sheltered abodes or forsaking all material sustenance to wander the world with a begging bowl and in rags, Sayyid Ahmed was a man very much of this world, who sought to integrate devotion with a life of dignity and social and political purpose. His advice to his fellow soldiers who found themselves hungry and without food during a siege in a particularly barren region was not to deny the need for food, but to wait for it, for surely Allah would give.Footnote 18 And for all intents and purposes, Allah did give. At moments of the greatest need, whether through a donation from a devout follower or through the sabar (patience) of faith, Sayyid Ahmed's followers would find that their hunger would abate.Footnote 19
As his reputation grew, Sayyid Ahmed began to channel his mystical powers to illuminate the path of politics. He told prophesies in which he predicted the outcome of negotiations between the Nawab and his adversaries before they were publically announced. His renown spread so far that the Nawab himself summoned Sayyid Ahmed to his side to interpret his troubling dreams.Footnote 20 Once, after a particularly difficult siege of a Rajasthani state, the Nawab decided to open a dialogue with the British who were at this time in open discussions and creating treaties with rulers of many small states across north-India. Sayyid Ahmed warned the Nawab not to follow suit, stating that if he was to meet and accept lands, money or a title from the British, he would be incapacitated – he would ‘not be able to do anything’.Footnote 21 In a series of meetings that followed, Sayyid Ahmed repeated this statement, to no effect as the Nawab felt he had to concede and enter into a dialogue with the ‘firangi kufar’, the English heretics.Footnote 22 Unlike the relations of quiet advice, religious guidance and solicited prophesies in return for patronage which traditional Sufi saints and sages had had with rulers in Central and South Asia for centuries,Footnote 23 Sayyid Ahmed confronted the worldly and the political as affairs concerning him as much as they concerned those who came to him for advice. His magic and divinations began to centre more on his own role in the politics of man when, although clearly hit in the chest by a bullet, Sayyid Ahmed walked away unhurt. He later declared to his companions that he would not die there as he had received a vision of the future – that he would die fighting in jihad against the kufar.Footnote 24 The political advice which he offered the Nawab informed his own path and Sayyid Ahmed left the army in 1816–7, unwilling to serve after the Nawab entered into negotiations with the British and compromised his political independence.
Sayyid Ahmed returned to Delhi in around 1816, gravitating back towards the Waliullah family Sufi lodge, and towards the centre of mystical teaching and practice in Muslim north-India. His time as a soldier seems to have created a disdain for the restricted inductions of and the complex teachings of Sufism in his time, and he did not return to Abdul Aziz's seminary, although he did immediately visit and demonstrate his respect for his teacher on returning. Instead Sayyid Ahmed sought to set himself up as teacher in his own right. Living and working in a seminary involved participation in the established pedagogy of Sufi orders, and so Sayyid Ahmed chose to remain in the world outside the seminary. He took up residence in the living quarters of the Akbarabadi mosque which previously been inhabited by Shah Abdul Qadir, Shah Abdul Aziz's brother.Footnote 25 During this period Sayyid Ahmed focused on the concept of innate wisdom, lecturing scholars, ulama, Sufis and lay people on the importance of personal perception and the experience of worship.Footnote 26 He began leading ‘those who sought to acquire knowledge from him’ in prayer and mystical contemplations of God's divinity, initially reiterating just the Naqshbandiyya, Qadiriyya and Mujaddidiyya principles he had learned from Shah Abdul Aziz and later adding the Chishtiyya method.Footnote 27
Sayyid Ahmed's use of the mosque to lead a close group of chosen students in contemplations and meditation was not unusual – a point suggested by the fact that Shah Abdul Qadir had himself lived and taught in the hujra or living quarters of the mosque.Footnote 28 Sayyid Ahmed had inherited a space which belonged to another Sufi teacher, and did so with the strong encouragement and sanction of the leading sages in his Sufi line at that time, and through the resources which accrued to the Waliullah family. In the same way, despite his sidestepping of the rigours of Sufi seminary-based education and teaching, it should not be assumed that Sayyid Ahmed's skill as a mystic and a savant deviated from the demonstrations of traditional Sufis. Dream-visitations from dead saints or even the Prophet Muhammad which conferred accomplishment as a mystic and prophesies and divinations were not unknown in even the most important Sufi lines.Footnote 29 Sayyid Ahmed's deviation was in the pattern of his economic and personal life. Sayyid Ahmed had lived in a real world of Muslims, where money and food were scarce. His sense of fraternity was not restricted within Waliullah lineage, but had been demonstrably extended to the soldiers he fought alongside in the Nawab's army. His personal and economic life and not his connection to the seminary underlay his growing reputation as a Sufi. Choosing to conduct himself as a religious teacher and spiritual guide in a real world of people led Sayyid Ahmed think about the place of mystical elevation as he understood it, in daily living. He dissected the centuries-old religious practices of the seminaries which linked philosophical thinking and debate, knowledge of Arabic, study of Quran and hadith, asceticism and mystical ascension.
The method by which this could be achieved was articulated in a series of lectures Sayyid Ahmed gave in Delhi in 1817 which were then transcribed by Shah Ismail and Abdul Hai as Sirat-i Mustaqeem – ‘The Straight Path’.Footnote 30 It was written as an elucidation of the basic precepts of the Quran and hadith referred to as ‘shari'a’, alongside an explanation of Sufi mystical practices in an attempt to unite these principles in thought and religious practice. Sirat-i Mustaqeem was written for Sayyid Ahmed's companions and later his followers – some of whom were scholars, but others of whom had very little education, if any at all. Sirat-i Mustaqeem's logic hinged on the concept innate knowledge which Sayyid Ahmed identified as the basis for faith and devotion. Delivered in both public lectures and private dialogue as well as in print form, on the understanding that individuals did not need a detailed education to understand worship, Sirat-i Mustaqeem is the most comprehensive and detailed representation of Sayyid Ahmed's teachings.
Mysticism and shari'a in Sirat-i Mustaqeem
The principles of Sirat-i Mustaqeem are rooted in the Naqshbandiyya-Mujaddidiyya theosophy of Shah Waliullah's seminary, Shah Abdul Aziz's teaching and writing, and Sayyid Ahmed's own training. Basing his ideas on the Waliullahi reformism of his teacher's seminary which called for application of the teachings of Quran and shari'a, Sayyid Ahmed proposed using the simpler principles of Quran and shari'a as a method to engage in mystical, devotional practice. He also anticipated extending these principles to laypeople, at once making mystical practice and the tenets of shari'a accessible to them. This was a great development in established thinking in the Waliullah line, which separated Sufi mystical practice as a secretive devotional act, and relayed the lessons of the Quran to the world outside the seminary in a series of social and political directives or fatawa. Distancing himself from the involved philological underpinnings of Shah Abdul Aziz's reformism and mystical practice, Sayyid Ahmed suggested that a layman could adequately undertake devotional practice through the ‘intellectualising of the heart’, or qalabi fikr Footnote 31 as long as he was given sufficient guidance and interpretative support. And so, through Sayyid Ahmed's method, the arena of devotional practice and thinking could shift away from the Sufi centres of north India.
In classic Sufi thought, union with the divine, referred to as the mutalib or He who is sought, is the spiritual quest of every individual, referred to as the talib, the seeker. Desire for such union is described in the language and imagery of worldly, human passion, and the purpose and anxiety of the seeker explained as the acute awareness of and desire for another person. In an extension of the classic Sufi metaphor, Sayyid Ahmed explained how worldly love could be poisoned if it necessitated cutting ties of family, learning, earning or political loyalty. In the same way, he indicated, love for God must be iterated and pursued within a system of worldly obligations. Rah-i Nabuwwat was the ‘straightest’ path to union with divinity – a path which was based on shari'a derived temperance in day to day in order that the path to union with God should not require a departure from worldly responsibilities and living.Footnote 32
Classic Sufi method is based on the practice and teaching of mystical transcendence of the material through ‘meditational’ exercises or muraqaba and the repetitive invocation of God's name or zikr, and adherence to Quranic precept. The purpose of these exercises is to refine the ability to abstractly picture the self and to perceive the presence of God everywhere, thereby bypassing the inhibitions of body and space in the effort to witness divinity. Sayyid Ahmed was a master of these exercises – something which underpinned his entire religious outlook. He premised all his teachings on the importance of mystical perception and connection between individuals and the divine. Yet religious practice is described in Sirat-i Mustaqeem as taking two forms. On the one hand it can involve the elevation of the self through zikr and muraqaba towards a euphoric state of self-forgetting and closeness to God – the Rah-i Wilayati or The Saintly Path. On the other it requires elevation of the soul towards the divine by using principles of human conduct explained in the Quran (shari'a) to condition and control the carnal self in order to channel all human passion towards the divineFootnote 33 through the Rah-i Nabuwwat – the Way of the Prophet. It is important to note that the differentiation was between the intellectual exercises to be undertaken in order to effectively and constantly contemplate divinity, not between mystical thinking and shari'a.
Both paths – Rah-i Wilayati and Rah-i Nabuwwat – were based on accentuating perception of divinity and transcending the material – one through turning off the conscious mind, and the other by making consciousness pivot on the existence of God, making every moment and every movement an act of worship. Because of the importance of both ‘paths’ to witnessing divinity, the Rah-i Wilayati is described in great detail in Sirat-i Mustaqeem.Footnote 34 In fact two of the four chapters almost exclusively discuss the objectives and exercises of the Rah-i Wilayati. The remaining two chapters, two and four, deal with those habits which should be avoided, and those which should be embraced, and define the particular practices of the Rah-i Nabuwwat.
Sayyid Ahmed's commitment to classic Sufi practice, though in a simplified form, can be gauged through the Risala-i Ashghal, a short manual condensed from the explanation of the methods of zikr and muraqaba in different systems of Sufi thought in Sirat-i Mustaqeem which was circulated among Sayyid Ahmed's followers in the Pashtun regions in 1827.Footnote 35 In these three short essays, different means of imaging and elevating the ‘nafs’ or the self, through chanting God's names, and contemplations of profound philosophical questions of God's presence are described. The ‘nafs’ is pictured as leaving the body, and rises through the seven heavens to commune with the spirits of the Prophet and other great men of history, and finally to encounter the divine. The climactic conclusion of the metaphysical ascent is the state of euphoric fana’ and then visualising the complete negation of everything including the nafs. This negation required both the courage to both detach from the body, and to be able to return to it.Footnote 36
Despite teaching and leading practitioners in the Rah-i Wilayat, Sayyid Ahmed stated that only using meditation to seek God was ‘wrong’ as, despite the achievement of union, it leaves the practitioner feeling disconsolate and uneasy. This is presumably because the euphoria of a meditational state could not be preserved in daily and conscious living.Footnote 37 It was as a corrective to this failing of Rah-i Wilayati that Sayyid Ahmed proposed the Rah-i Nabuwwat – a way of life which would more effectively respond to the same human longing for union which was left unfulfilled by the short lived experiences and encounters with the divine which resulted from traditional zikr and muraqaba. Instead he prescribed a life of constant consideration of God's presence and God's will, so much so that the individual is filled with terror of God and is shaken to his core so much so that he invokes God's mercy through the verbal and emotional resonance of his taubah or repentance.Footnote 38 In place of extremes of experience he prescribed moderation but rigour in personal behaviour through closely following the Prophet's examples of personal conduct.
In Sayyid Ahmed's practice, as in most Sufi practice, the act of worship was a vocalised and an experiential one, based on the spoken language and internalised meaning as an invocation of the divine. He emphasised prayer and recitation of the Quran and as a source of mystical connection to God as it involved enunciation of God's own words.Footnote 39 The rational and philosophical debate over the meaning of the words of the Quran, what exactly constituted the example of the Prophet gleaned from sunnah and hadith, merely refined daily practices into more focused worship, but were not described as being central to the process of worship. Understanding the meaning of words in the Quran and the sunnat of the Prophet was important, but these did not have to be translated from the Arabic by each worshipper himself as such effort could be left to experts who could communicate the meanings of Quranic-Arabic words and terms to worshippers.
The meditational and contemplative features of the Rah-i Nabuwwat were based on the Mujaddidiyya contemplations of divinity which required the practitioner to meditate on certain of God's names. Sayyid Ahmed called this the zikr imani, and added that the meanings of the names could be ascertained with the use of an Arabic lexicon. He similarly recommended the Mujaddidiyya Sufi method of contemplations of God's sublimity (samdiyat) and divinity (aluhiyat), not as an introspective meditational act, but as an active process undertaken during ‘inspection of the Quran’. The zikr imani and the muraqaba of the Mujaddidiyya Sufi method and the Rah-i Nabuwwat were not the staged ascensions of classic Sufi meditation, requiring complex metaphysical imaging and transcendence, but rather focused on the resonance of sound and power within the worshipper. In older Sufi methods (such as the Chishtiyya and Qadiriyya), the climax of these exercises was a euphoric self extinguishing in the perception of God. In Mujaddidiyya method, rather than having to elevate the consciousness above the material to accomplish union with divinity, the extinguishing of the self (nafi) was a willful negation of personal desires and concerns which took place during contemplation exercises in order to more effectively understand God's will and the nature of closeness to God.Footnote 40
Sayyid Ahmed extended the Mujaddidiyya notion of an omnipresent God who could be perceived in this very plane of existence by basing the meditational experience not on an introspective blocking out of the world, but on imagining the self as though immersed in the ocean of God's sublimity and divinity, thereby recognizing the expanse of prizes offered by the Absolute Benefactor. Awareness of these aspects of God's qualities would imbue the practitioner with the amazement of perpetually perceiving something new. Eventually, the practitioner would reach fana-i iradah, the eradication of will, a state of union with God's will and a completion and resolution of faith.Footnote 41 All individual dealings with society were as an agent of God's will, as individualism and all longing should have been entirely eradicated by the path of the Rah-i Nabuwwat.
The primary difference between Mujaddidiyya method and the Rah-i Nabuwwat was that it was structured in a manner that a layperson could master its techniques without extensive scholarly study of the philosophical treatises, the Quran or logic. Nor did the practitioner need extensive training in meditational transcendence in order to achieve nafi. Rather than making the intellectual or spiritual negation of self the prerequisite basis for practice, a simpler exercise of the contemplation of bounty, mystery and the grace of the creational force was the beginning of the exercise of comprehension of God. Many of the exercises of the Mujaddidiyya method were designed to bring on prophetic visions of the full set of possibilities in the living and after-world as an extension of preceding traditions which sought to open up the human mind to the mystery of creation. Rah-i Nabuwwat enhanced a worldly, living experience.
Shari'a-based prescriptions were described generally and without the complex arguments of traditional fiqh writing in the Sirat-i Mustaqeem, affirming that intimate knowledge and understanding of shari'a was not proposed as the cornerstone of practice. Sayyid Ahmed's most detailed enunciations about what comprised shari'a were compiled as the second background chapter of Sirat-i Mustaqeem as “that which should guide worship”. This entire discussion was comprised of ideas which had been developed in the Delhi seminary such as encouraging widow remarriage, avoiding ostentatious celebrations of marriage and circumcision, the fallacy of Shi'a rituals of commemoration and avoiding bid'at or the worship of Sufis under the misguided belief that the rewards bestowed by God upon the great Saints will be bestowed upon their devotees.Footnote 42 Believers were urged to undertake direct worship of God to gain insight and communion with divinity.Footnote 43
In the final summation of the features of a personal practice, the following acts were listed: regular prayer, fasting, recitation of the Quran, zikr, jihad and distributing charity.Footnote 44 Of these, only prayer, fasting, and charity are actual cornerstones of Muslim practice, as ascertainable from the Quran and hadith. The focus on jihad, zikr and recitation of the Quran were Sayyid Ahmed's efforts to bring the theological principles of confronting hereticism, studying the Quran closely and achieving meditational transcendence into a system of ritualised religious practice.
The transmission of Sayyid Ahmed's teachings across Muslim North India
The device through which Sayyid Ahmed communicaced his ideas was the bay'at or the pledge of the student and seeker of enlightenment at the hand of a teacher and spiritual guide. The first of these occurred when an unknown man presented himself to Sayyid Ahmed and asked to take the bay'at at his hand and receive instruction from him. In an anecdote transcribed by Shah Ismail, Sayyid Ahmed said that God told him to accept the man's request and administer the bay'at as this man would come to number among thousands of Sayyid Ahmed's murids.Footnote 45 At this time Shah Abdul Aziz also began to recommend Sayyid Ahmed's services as a Sufi teacher. Shah Abdul Aziz told a Bukhari scholar who had travelled to see him that he should offer himself in Sayyid Ahmed's service as what ‘Sayid Ahmed could teach him in twelve days, the Bukhari Mulla would not even be able to learn in twelve years of study’ with Shah Abdul Aziz.Footnote 46 Shah Abdul Aziz also told Shah Abdul Hai, his own son, and Shah Ismail, his nephew, that the two should seek instruction with Sayyid Ahmed as he himself no longer had the strength to sit for extended periods.Footnote 47 By every account, Shah Abdul Aziz willingly, knowingly invested the authority of his highly scholarly line in this less learned, energetic, independent thinking man and formally gave him ‘ijazat’ or permission to confer the bay'at in his own right.Footnote 48
Initially, the two cousins were skeptical of Abdul Aziz's endorsement of this unlettered man and had wanted to be instructed in Sufi method by Shah Abdul Aziz. They both began to change their minds when Sayyid Ahmed woke up day after day, having dreamed prophesies which quickly proved correct, and speaking of meeting with the Prophet and with God in his dreams.Footnote 49 They became finally and forever ‘slaves’ of Sayyid Ahmed when he met their challenge to make him feel the glory of worship that the Prophet's own companions had felt. Late one night Sayyid Ahmed called his friends to prayer in a voice that made them turn cold – Abdul Hai testified that he kept repeating his simple two-rakat prayer all night long in a terror and awe of God – a terror that he later realised was akin to what the Prophet's companions were said to have felt before God.Footnote 50 They were followed by a number of other members of the Waliullahi line including Abdur Rahim Wilayati, himself one of Abdul Aziz's students, and Shah Ahlullah, Shah Waliullah's brother.Footnote 51 Sayyid Ahmed then went on to administer the bay'at widely, to communicate a greatly simplified and individualized system of personal practice.
Shortly after the bay'ats by Waliullahis at Sayyid Ahmed's hand, Sayyid Ahmed decided to return to Rai Bareilly – in time for Ramadan 1234 AH.Footnote 52 He spent a year organising his followers and then returned to the Akbarabadi mosque in Delhi, where he spent a few years practicing tasawwuf. And it was at exactly this time that Sayyid Ahmed initiated his most unique and religiously transformative acts – widely, without reservation, accepting pledges of studentship in communal public settings. This was the foundation on which Sayyid Ahmed would go on to widely disseminate the principles of faith and spirituality. The teaching that he imparted was premised in the fundamentals of Sufism, the individualised teaching from teacher to student, actual demonstration of the method of meditational exercises and invocations of God's name in zikr. But it deviated from the established system of mystical training in a number of ways. Students did not learn individually from their teacher, but in congregational settings, making it possible to induct and teach many students at once. They did not travel many miles and many years and deny all worldly rights and responsibilities to seek their training. Rather their teacher came to their village, created inclusive spaces within which they could, after their working day and alongside their womenfolk, be trained in the technique of prayer, the performance of meditation and the invocation of God's name.
The process by which Sayyid Ahmed began to enact this vision, the events which gave such significance to the teachings of Sirat-i Mustaqeem, began shortly after Sayyid Ahmed receiving the sanction from his teacher and accepted the bay'at from his colleagues. He then decided to do two things: to perform Hajj, and then to undertake the jihad in which he had predicted that he would die. This agenda took him east to Calcutta then on a ship to the Hijaz in a journey that took a few years, then back to Calcutta and then directly on to the Pakhtun north-west. The years of travel were conducted at an unhurried pace. He stopped at serais or rest houses on the way, and each stop was made remarkable by his interactions with locals in the capacity of a renowned sage. The feature which distinguished him on his travels was that he tapped into local systems of authority wherever he went. During his time in the UP, he normally sought introductions to residents of the small Muslim townships, the qasbahs, through respected members of the communities. In Muradabad, the local Qazi hosted him – an association which made locals realize that he was not a ‘dewana fakir’ or a mad ascetic seeking alms.Footnote 53 The Qazi suggested that Sayyid Ahmed convene meetings at several different locations in the city in order to maximise the influence he could have, and was asked by the Nawab Muhammad Khan of Muradabad to remain in the town for a week because it was possible that under his influence the discord between the people of the town might be resolved.Footnote 54
Sayyid Ahmed made easy alliances with the sharifs – the old Muslim nobility – of the towns he visited, and the religious leaders of note – alliances which were based on his demonstrations of miraculous power. In Bareilly, he made a local Nawab's sick oxen well again through prayer. The Nawab and his entire extended family came that evening and took bay'at at Sayyid Ahmed's hand.Footnote 55 In Lucknow he went to Shah Pir Muhammad mosque and was admitted to its private quarters, inhabited by a well known local ascetic who had not been seen by anybody in almost forty years. After many hours of intense, supposedly telepathic discussions with this ascetic, he made it known that the ascetic had taken the bay'at at his hand, and that this was the culmination of an alliance ordained by God and shown to him in a vision many years prior.Footnote 56 The ease with which these alliances were created, and their reliance on miraculous demonstration suggest that Sayyid Ahmed did not present a highly aberrant persona but used a familiar public guise, that of the wandering ascetic. As he told a follower who was worried about how they would feed their growing retinue – ‘hum fakir log hain’ – ‘we are ascetics’ – we will make do.Footnote 57
The first phase of these travels was a ‘dora’ or a tour around Lucknow and the United Provinces. At each stop at small qasbahs or townships around the area, despite his purported hurry to return to Rai Bareilly before the start of Ramadan, and despite receiving news of the death of his brother, Sayyid Ahmed took bay'ats from people and communicated the principles of mystical method to them.Footnote 58 In Amroha, Sayyid Ahmed met with and talked secretly and at length with powerful and well known mystic called Abdul Sami, making him a murid and a staunch proponent of his own method.Footnote 59 When visiting these townships, Sayyid Ahmed accepted dinner invitations at the homes of local notables (never accepting twice at any one home), shared a meal with all in attendance, then gave a sermon and led everyone in namaz or prayer. The details of this practice are not described in accounts of the movement, but it is probable that following the prayer, a brief introduction to exercises in contemplation and invocation of God's name followed, in the manner described in Sirat-i Mustaqeem. The evening invariably ended by Sayyid Ahmed giving the bay'at to everyone present, including, very often, the women of the home.Footnote 60 In these intensely personal settings, his position strengthened by the etiquette that his host had to exhibit and the competitiveness between locals desiring to also have associations with this traveller of note, Sayyid Ahmed established a reputation and connections in a number of different towns between Delhi and Rai Bareilly. When Sayyid Ahmed came to Calcutta for three months on his way to Hajj in 1819–20, an observer among Sayyid Ahmed's companions stated that the bay'at was conferred in a mass gathering of five hundred to one thousand men, loudly, with several of Sayyid Ahmed's unraveled turbans stretched through the crown in order that each man could touch them as they took the pledge to learn from him.Footnote 61
In the most important instance of Sayyid Ahmed's religious and social experiment, his time in the Pashtun ‘tribal’ regions, Sayyid Ahmed continued to widely receive the bay'at. When camped at Hashtnagar, a town close to the city of Peshawar, news of Sayyid Ahmed's presence and leading tawajju in local mosques spread, so much so that the youngest brother of the newly crowned Afghan King Dost Mohammad Khan, encamped at the Bala Hissar Fort in Peshawar, came to participate in the prayers and meditation along with his large retinue. The afternoon ended with all present taking bay'at at Sayyid Ahmed's hand in such numbers than he had to once again spread a length of cloth to include everyone simultaneously in his induction.Footnote 62 Local religious leaders also took the bay'at at Sayyid Ahmed's hand, and were briefly tutored in his mystical method, after which they were authorised to guide devotees on their own authority. One of these men was Sayyid Akbar Shah who would later become the King of the small local state of Swat.Footnote 63
Sayyid Ahmed's method was further enhanced by the fact that he could, within days, often the very night of the initial induction, authorise new murids to guide other initiates in contemplations owing to the simplicity of the zikr and contemplations, and the purpose of instilling awareness of divinity rather than teaching mystical ascension. In Hapar he led new initiates in the contemplation just once before allowing them to lead other new initiates in these exercises. They were able to do this so effectively that some of those whom the new initiates were teaching were able to successfully undertake the exercise of divination.Footnote 64 Sayyid Ahmed gave the bay'at to a man who demonstrated tremendous spiritual power of his own and immediately conferred the title of khalifa or official representative on him and allowed him to lead all members of the town in tawajju’.Footnote 65 Hence Sayyid Ahmed's teachings were self propagating, extending even in his absence, under the authority of those whom he deputized to take his place.
Khalifas or deputies were community-based leaders who were authorized to guide their communities in the Rah-i Nabuwwat, and to induct new devotees on their own. This feature created longevity and the ability to self-propagate to Sayyid Ahmed's mass-inductions and demonstrations of religious worship which otherwise would not have been sustained. Initiates included the imam of Akbarabadi mosque in Delhi,Footnote 66 Pir Sibghatullah Rashidi ‘on the banks of the River Indus in Sindh’, Agha Shah in Shikarpur,Footnote 67 Sayyid Mohsin Shah among the Baloch,Footnote 68 Shah Ramzan Rurki in Saharanpur,Footnote 69 a religious leader from Kabul,Footnote 70 and followers in Bengal who created a new base of the movement which Sayyid Ahmed got news of in the year of the Battle of Balakot and his death, 1831.Footnote 71 Inevitably, the question arises as to how this leadership operated in Sayyid Ahmed's absence, often without any further direct contact with the order at all. A possible answer lies in the notion of ‘fana-i iradah’ – ‘the extinguishing of personal will’ described in Sirat-i Mustaqeem as the spiritual conclusion of the Rah-i Nabuwwat. While the core principles of the practice of Rah-i Nabuwwat outlook were premised on systems of personal conduct and the individual's path to mystical union with divinity, the contemplations forced practitioners to dwell on the nature of God's will, and to make their own will an instrument of God's design. This precept, forming the core of individual devotion, suggested that those very accomplished in the Rah-i Nabuwwat would at once act autonomously and in pursuance of ‘God's will’ which was generally defined by the teachings of the order – worship by shari'a.
Tenets of Sayyid Ahmed's ideology and its perpetuation were inscribed through the congregational domain.Footnote 72 Sayyid Ahmed turned to mosques in locales as the inclusive and open domain of religious practice by the people. When he found that the central Jama’ Masjid in Bareilly had no regular imam, he took it upon himself to appoint one in consultation with local people.Footnote 73 After a vision about a mosque whose roof had not been cleaned in over one hundred years, an climbing the to the roof of that mosque to clean it himself, he told locals that because he had done so, God had given him a reward for which there were no words to even utter thanks. On another occasion Sayyid Ahmed took extra pains to save the floor of the Akbarabadi mosque from being befouled, Sayyid Ahmed similarly described being given an indescribable ‘prize’.Footnote 74 When he met the imam of a mosque who worried that the quality of his voice did not please people hearing him give the call to prayer, Sayyid Ahmed recited prayers which made the imam's voice sonorous and he began to draw people to the mosque.Footnote 75
When visiting other townships across north India, Sayyid Ahmed sought out spaces in which he could lead the prayer which were big enough to accommodate his cohort and local inductees into his order.Footnote 76 Where it was possible, he asked for spaces to be designated for use by the community as in Lucknow where they were given a haveli by a well wisher in the Qandahari quarter. This compound was used as a mosque and a hujra or living accommodation by the group. Locals from the city were encouraged to come and listen to the sermons conducted there.Footnote 77 In the one place he was able, his own hometown of Rai Bareilly where he had personal wealth and authority as a landowner, Sayyid Ahmed established two new mosques and appointed imams to each for those ‘observant worshippers who had trouble always presenting themselves at Sayyid Ahmed's own mosque’, located on his ancestral property.Footnote 78
This use of mosques was an innovation – not the fact of congregational prayer, but for the structured use of mosques as platforms for communication. It was this space which could be appropriated or recreated anywhere, allowing pedagogy and religious authority to flourish outside of the confines of the seminary within the community of worship. After the ritual prayer and the recitation of verses from the Quran in a sequence prescribed by religious scholars. The author of Waqai Ahmedi notes that Sayyid Ahmed or his companionsFootnote 79 would then lead people in zikr.Footnote 80 Owing to the very limited time that Sayyid Ahmed spent on his proselytising tours, it seems necessary that these should have only been the meditational exercises prescribed for the Rah-i Nabuwwat such as contemplation of divinity, and contemplation of verses from the Quran.Footnote 81 In addition to prayer, Sayyid Ahmed also ensured that he gave a sermon after each prayer, or nominated one of his companions – often Shah Ismail or Abdul Hai – to do so, wherever he was.Footnote 82 These sermons were on points of shari'a – the incorrectness of worship at Sufi shrines, the nature of heresy, and recitations of anecdotes from the Quran.Footnote 83
In an essay on congregational prayer, with its obligatory supplications, prayers and invocations of God, Shah Ismail stated that this must be the form of worship taken by Muslims in order that they be distinguishable– not from others, but to one another. If a Muslim saw another Muslim in prayer, he would know that this man considers him to be a brother, and he should consider him faithful.Footnote 84 While this idea is not expressed in Sirat-i Mustaqeem, it has great value for it establishes that concrete thinking about community and identity was taking place within the order. Shah Ismail's essay has a deep resonance with Sayyid Ahmed's ideas which was not, I believe, purely abstract. Communities of practice were created to be self-consciousness and to sustain themselves as differentiated devotional and ideological entities.
Sayyid Ahmed's time in the Pashtun regions and the system of local bay'ats exemplify his belief in community-based religious practice. Implications of community-based Muslim identity are deeply political – suggesting a pre-history of communalism – but to understand their logic as part of the movement, we must first think about community-identification and practice as a system of metaphysical thinking. A set of tenets, purported to be the bay'at conferred on people in the Pashtun areas, offer a rare insight:
Bay'at Ahl-i Suffah (Bay'at of the descendants in study of the Prophet's teachings) Any man, whether his poverty is greater or lesser, will not satisfy his need through anyone but God. That which he has pledged he will consider necessary and binding on himself. Nor will ever ask any Muslim brother to act against the principles of that pledge. That which he prefers for himself he will prefer for his Muslim brothers. Those that take the pledge will consider the poverty and need of Muslim brothers’ superior to their own poverty and need. Every act will only be undertaken by the leave of God. A prayer follows.Footnote 85
Sayyid Ahmed confronted the most material determinant of the human condition – poverty. The commitment which Sayyid Ahmed elicited from his murids in the Pakhtun regions acknowledged the debilitating effects of economic deprivation, but pointedly placed this as secondary to devotion, fraternal consciousness, the suffering of others, and belief in God's own grace, asking them to only satisfy their poverty by means acceptable to God, and to deem the suffering and faith of their fellow men as superior to their own. This did not dismiss the fact of poverty or make little of the need of individuals to cut carnal need and want out of their own psyche, as classic Sufi asceticism did. Rather, it rationalised forbearance in the face of poverty and personal suffering by joining systems of participation – in God's service and in the unity of men – participation which could emotionally mitigate the effects of extreme personal deprivation or a sense of injustice.Footnote 86 Faith and its associated hope were channelled into a daily system of participation in worldly affairs. Devotees did not have to separate their understanding of divinity from the exigencies of living, rather they had to subordinate hunger, anger and fear to faith, compassion and camaraderie.
Conclusion: personal agency, proselytising and the survival of Sayyid Ahmed's movement
Embedded in Sirat-i Mustaqeem are descriptions of city-based polities, the rule of law, political leaders of communities, and the place of scholars and studies in fiqh and hadith as had been defined in the Waliullah family scholarship.Footnote 87 Sayyid Ahmed, trying to enunciate what this structure meant for communities of individual practitioners, privileged those trained in Arabic language and as scholars of the Quran and hadith and sunnat as a scholarly support system for individuals who wanted assistance in interpreting religious prescription. These were referred to as the Ahl-i Hadith, the people of the hadith – who could most accurately guide people in their daily personal discipline.Footnote 88 In addition to religious leaders he nominally named the political leader as the ‘King’ or Badshah who was to create courts of justice and law, and should better be thought of as a Khalifa-Badshah who privileged religion over worldly glory.Footnote 89 The role of the sages or pirs was the prophetic divination of events past and yet to come.Footnote 90 Together these leaders were to afford individual worshippers protection, guidance and encouragement in their mystical quests. Yet despite this reiteration of Shah Waliullah's imagined ideal political order, the core of Sayyid Ahmed's teachings privileged individual agency and independence in faith in a manner which superceded any political or social hierarchy.
Practitioners of the Rah-i Nabuwwat were accorded the right to interpret tenets of the faith and conduct practice for themselves, so once in practice the aspect of Sayyid Ahmed's message which most immediately began to fashion a political objective was not the one which accorded ultimate authority in faith to the learned, as in the Waliullah tradition of political thinking, but the paradoxical tenet which accorded such authority to all who had taken the teachings of the order and who were not necessarily learned. The significance of the autonomy vested in the individual was elaborated in Sirat-i Mustaqeem itself under the principle of what was called amr-bil maruf wa nahi anal munkir, ‘do that which is celebrated, and to prohibit that which is deviant’, more commonly translated as ‘the promotion of virtue and the prevention of vice’. This charge, reiterated a few times in the treatise, obligated individuals with a social responsibility to communicate the moral apparatus of shari'a more widely ‘to the trans-regional community of the Prophet Muhammad's followers’.Footnote 91 In spiritual terms, this led distraught, needy seekers of communion with the divine, despite their own desperation in their search for God, to sacrifice of themselves to make the search for God easier for other, less spiritually astute people.Footnote 92 In practical terms this was a system to widely disseminate principles of reformist conduct such as widow remarriage, communal prayer and recitation of the Quran at masjids and disallowing Sufi worship.Footnote 93 Both the spiritual and the social mandate worked through the community, encouraging spiritual-fraternal thinking, and regularisation and control of observable religious practices.
That Sayyid Ahmed's followers took up the charge of amr bil maruf was established in colonial records of Bengal, Patna, and the post-mutiny trials in India which point to their preaching of reformist practices.Footnote 94 In the Pashtun regions, local religious leaders who were inducted into the Rah-i Nabuwwat explained principles of social conduct and ritual according to ‘shari'a’ to their communities while passing on the bay'at more selectively.Footnote 95 Among these was the Akhund Ghaffur, a local religious leader in his own right, already inducted into the Naqshbandiyya and Qadiriyya Sufi lines. Akhund Ghaffur became a close ally of Sayyid Ahmed, and went on to transmit the principles of amr-bil maruf to his own murids who passed them on to their murids, enshrining Sayyid Ahmed's teachings in a system of bay'ats. The descendents in Akhund Ghaffur's line went on to established mosques, encourage congregational worship, and emphasise their knowledge of Quran and hadith and their own legitimacy as enforcers of public morality. In later years these local religious leaders openly referred to their mission among the Pakhtun clansmen as ‘amr bil maruf wa nahi anal munkir’ – testimony that it was the direct legacy of Sayyid Ahmed's teachings.Footnote 96
Among the Pashtun religious leadership were varying levels of training in the religious sciences. Akhund Ghaffur was a Sufi mystic in a local Naqshbandiyya line. While he had great acclaim, he did not have detailed linguistic training in Arabic or Persian, nor in fiqh or hadith. The same was true of many of Sayyid Ahmed's deputies in the Rah-i Nabuwwat. Din Muhammad, an earnest companion and one of the primary informants in Waqai Ahmedi, had converted from Hinduism, and soon after became an important emissary of Sayyid Ahmed.Footnote 97 Sayyid Ahmed himself assumed an innate understanding of the faith and a right to comment upon it. Investing the authority to personally conduct inquiry into the tenets of the faith, and to communicate that understanding to others created the layman's right to ownership over religious interpretation and preaching which had until now belonged to the ulama and the learned Sufis. While Sirat-i Mustaqeem charged individuals to seek guidance and interpretation from the more learned, it allowed individuals the discretion to decide which interpretation they would seek, what they would highlight and what they would choose to carry forward and enforce upon others. From being a closely controlled intellectual sphere and system of interpretation, authority in matters of faith could accrue to individual practitioners through mere inclination to claim it. This principle of personal interpretation has remained preserved in and is a central feature of contemporary Islamic revivalist practice and organisation.
The link between the contemporary revivalism and Sayyid Ahmed's representation of the proselytizing principle and agency and personal authority in matters of faith is not accidental. It is in fact the very basis for the survival of Sayyid Ahmed's teachings. Several of his devotees took up his exhortations to personal ownership of faith, its interpretation and its spread. Among these were the Shah Mohammad Ishaq and Shah Mohammad Yaqub, grandsons of Shah Abdul Aziz, who created the group known as the Ahl-i Hadith, scholars of Arabic who organised community based study of the Quran, prayer and proselytisation. The proselytizing movement of the Tablighi Jamaat, deeply influential across South Asia, attributes an intellectual and pedagogic debt to Sayyid Ahmed. Both of the groups which took up the exhortation to jihad – one in the Pashtun north-west and the other in Bengal – touted the principles of autonomous community based practice, leadership and governance. Other inheritors of Sayyid Ahmed's ideas and practices have come to the fore of socially and politically coercive sectarian, anti-imperialist and anti-state movements in the more recent past. All of these movements assume authority over interpretation of religion on the basis of faith and piety and a right to interpret the words of the Quran and Hadith irrespective of scholarly training while sustaining the principle of devotion within a worldly existence.
