During the late 19th century and early 20th century, Central Asian jadīds (Muslim reformists or modernizers) blamed women's illiteracy for keeping the Uzbek nation from becoming modern. Russians targeted Uzbek women's ignorance as the symbol of backwardness. Muslim scholars shunned women for being superstitious. Tatars viewed the same women as deprived noncitizens of a long-gone traditional life. According to Marianne Kamp, despite such unforgiving rhetoric against them, Uzbek women were by no means voiceless victims of a cultural transformation. Kamp demonstrates with the example of the otin, the female teacher of girls, that Uzbek women fought to stay active during this era of cultural change between the late 1880s and 1930s. She provides a nuanced history of a complex era in Uzbekistan in her new book.
Kamp's approach to this era is a departure from two previous histories of Uzbekistan by Gregory Massell and Douglas Northrop. By effectively using oral accounts and Uzbek-language materials, Kamp writes about the ways in which Uzbek women experienced this time of change. As a product of these formerly untapped sources, her book argues that when discussing education and unveiling, “women's subjectivity” must be more closely analyzed (p. 11). Kamp leaves the history of “the improvement of Uzbek women's lives” to official historians and “the workings of the Communist Party” to the scholars of Soviet documents (p. 4). Instead, she writes about Uzbek women's own responses to the hujūm (the party's campaign or attack or assault on Islamic traditions such as the veil, which began in 1927). Furthermore, Kamp rejects Northrop's argument that the hujūm was a failed colonial project, suggesting that the “counter-Hujum,” a violent struggle against this campaign, was not an anticolonial battle (p. 11).
Kamp argues that Uzbek women, by participating in or rejecting unveiling, defined “Uzbekness” in the 1920s and 1930s. She emphasizes that the gendered nature of party membership and Soviet citizenship in Uzbekistan defined the ways in which women entered the revolutionary era. Her account of this transformative period works particularly well because of the structure of the book. Following a concise background of Russian colonial conquest, the book offers a chronological layout of social reform. It begins with jadīds' attempts at reform and ends with the antiveiling murders of the 1930s. The final chapter considers the consequences of the hujūm during the 1950s and the post-Soviet period.
The New Women in Uzbekistan offers detailed and useful background information about the debates among jadīd writers, including some Tatar women on underage marriage, polygyny, marriage gift, and bride price. It reveals some important but rarely discussed moments during the pre-Bolshevik era, such as Uzbek women's riots against wartime labor conscription of their menfolk. It shows how complex it was for women to be both subjects of intellectual debate and the agents of change. The stories of the female editors of Uzbek-language magazine Yangi Yo'l (New Path) illustrate this precarious circumstance.
One of the strengths of the book is the comparative treatment of the official women's emancipation policies in Turkey, Iran, and Uzbekistan. Although the Iranian case seems to fall by the wayside in this comparison, the analysis suggests that both in republican Turkey and Soviet Uzbekistan, women constituted the goal and the criterion of modernity. Both states forged women's emancipation policies, which rendered women the representatives of social transformation but not necessarily the heroines of their own freedoms. These conclusions point out that although in Turkey wives did not fully gain equal rights, in Uzbekistan Soviet law protected women's rights in marriage and divorce. Another significant difference between these two projects of modernity refers to the speed and rigidity of new regulations and laws. The Soviet government permitted some of the traditional courts to operate in Uzbekistan for a while. In Turkey, the state did not compromise when prohibiting any of the religious courts from operating. According to this analysis, although Soviet leaders asserted coercion more effectively, they did so more gradually than their Turkish counterparts. Unlike in Turkey, progressive activists, not the state, organized and implemented the popularization of unveiling.
The book comes alive when Kamp incorporates her interviews with Uzbek women into the larger history. The stories of Saodat Shamsieva and Rahbar-oi Olimova enliven the bleak story of the pre- and post-hujūm era. Shamsieva's story reflects the experiences of activists who began fighting against the veil well before the hujūm. Olimova's story demonstrates the resilience of women who stood firm against criticism and violence against unveiling. Kamp clarifies that the counter-hujūm murders of unveiled women were an extension of the 1916 anti-Russian uprising. This shift from state-centered and Stalinism-oriented history is welcome. A few questions emerge, however. Did ethnic factors matter? Did the Tajik or other ethnic groups respond to these events the same way? Was “Uzbekness” so clearly defined?
Marianne Kamp's book is a welcome addition to the recently published works of Paula Michaels, Douglas Northrop, Adrienne Edgar, and Francine Hirsch. With its carefully selected maps, illustrations, glossary, bibliography, and an index, I highly recommend this book for Central Asian, Middle Eastern, women's studies, and oral history courses.
