The welfare state is everywhere in a state of flux. An important force behind the transformations taking place is usually crisis in state finances with ensuing austerity measures in public welfare systems. Compounding these challenges are widespread demographic changes, an increasing share of the elderly in the population, the fact that childbearing is being put off to increasingly higher ages and that fewer marriages are taking place – with people choosing to enter closer or looser partnerships – along with an increasing number of divorces. Added to these are such labour market changes as the increase in time-limited employment and demands for more extensive education.
How different welfare states adapt to these changes is given a detailed description in the book, The Welfare State and Life Transitions: A European Perspective, in which researchers in the fields of economics, sociology and political science in nine European countries present the results of their studies on the national development of state support for the welfare of the citizens of each country. The countries are Austria, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Spain, Sweden and the UK and the focus of the comparison is on support in five key areas: from education to first job, the transition to adulthood and independent living, gender inequality and parenthood transitions, transitions in prime age and the transition from work to retirement.
How well a country succeeds on the educational front is of great importance for how well that country is able to assert itself within research and in the development of new industries and business in general. From the point of view of the individual, education is therefore increasingly important. The labour force is increasingly being required to have both better basic knowledge and ability to adapt to the constantly changing specific demands for new knowledge. The total time spent on education is becoming longer, which accentuates the need for functioning systems to finance studies. In all the nine countries, education has exploded in recent decades, especially among women. Today, women acquire education to the same extent as men and sometimes more. The nine countries offer subsidies in the form of child benefit or tax relief to parents of children still in the process of obtaining their basic education. But when it comes to higher education, only Sweden has a study allowance and study loan system that is based on the individual and not means tested. In all the other countries in the study, subsidies are only given to children of low-income parents.
The age for first entry into the labour market has increased in all the countries, as has the share of young people with only temporary employment. Austria and Germany have systems of apprenticeship tightly bound to the labour market. The median age for entry into the labour market is also lowest in Austria, twenty-one years of age.
Differences in culture and traditions affect women's labour market participation, but so do economic incentives. Taxes and subsidies can influence women's decision to engage in paid work. Individual taxation, parental leave insurance and subsidised childcare encourage women to more continuous labour-market participation. Italy and Greece follow the Mediterranean model with few women in the labour force; Austria and Germany, on the other hand, no longer have the low female labour market participation generally associated with conservative welfare systems, and Germany is the country that has achieved the greatest changes in terms of support for women to be able to have both children and gainful employment. Childcare support has improved in all nine countries, but is relatively widespread only in France and in Sweden. The motives for these changes are mixed. In Germany, for example, the reason given is the low fertility among higher educated women.
An income-based parental leave insurance with a high replacement rate is a strong incentive to delay childbearing with the risk of reduced fertility. The median age for a first birth in Sweden – a country with generous parental leave insurance – is high, thirty-one years, compared with twenty-eight years in most of the other countries.
The book further focuses on career patterns and differences in wage development between men and women, as well as on the different countries’ unemployment insurance systems and labour market policy measures. Southern European countries give priority to high compensation levels when unemployment is high, but place less importance on active labour market measures and training.
From the 1970s to the mid-1990s, a clear trend emerged where men in particular tended to leave the labour force at an increasingly early age. However, the pension reforms of recent years have made such behaviour more difficult. The pensionable age has been raised and the connection between contributions and benefits has been strengthened in order to boost the incentive to continue working.
Longer length of life and increased mobility both within and between countries now raise the question of how eldercare is to be handled. This issue of eldercare is not included in the book's descriptions however, except very briefly in the chapter on Greece and Italy. How we are to organise the care of the elderly in society is a problem that in all likelihood will only become greater in the future. It would have been instructive to have had some light shed on how the separate welfare states differ in this regard.
The book gives a full description of the support offered to citizens by the welfare states of Europe and how these systems have developed. Unfortunately, the authors stop there. It would have been most interesting and helpful if they had gone on to consider some possible conclusions. Are we more or less on our way towards a European social protection? A certain tendency towards convergence in support structures is observed along with a certain reduction of the gap between the Bismarckian and the Beveridge types of social insurance systems. The traditional divide into conservative, liberal and social democratic welfare models is showing all signs of dissipation in certain areas. Is this a result of ongoing economic and demographic developments? With globalisation and increased cross-border mobility, a welfare system with benefits based on earnings is less susceptible to erosion than one with general or means-tested benefits. Aging populations have made it necessary to reform pension systems so as to place less of the burden on the wage-earning generation, to build in incentives to keep people working and to bring more women into the labour force. This latter, however, involves demands for subsidised childcare and paid parental leave.
This book offers, in an extremely clear and easily read manner, knowledge about the state of welfare in large parts of Europe; how systems have been developed and shaped in the various countries to provide support in different life phases. The book is well suited for social science students in general, and for students of social work, sociology and economics in particular.
