It is tempting to think that everything our forebears did had a purpose. After all, if we try hard enough, we can locate directions and decipher motives in past actions, even if no one acknowledged them at the time. I imagine we are more tempted to impute motives when the people we are studying are obscure or when we have strong feelings about them or when we are young. One does need to be a bit blasé to believe that a cigar is sometimes just a cigar.
Mary Campbell's Charles Ellis Johnson and The Erotic Mormon Image is loaded with cheeky insights into people's motivations and bold assertions about their larger meaning. Many readers will like this unconventional book, but I found it tiresome. The writing is relentlessly clever, the organization is confusing, the argument is reductionist, the title misleading, and the material is never allowed to speak for itself; Campbell imposes connections and divines commonalities in the unalike and the invisible.
The book focuses on the career of a Salt Lake City photographer, C E. Johnson, about whom Campbell knows relatively little. Johnson owned a studio, published a book of views of Salt Lake, went on tours of Europe and the Middle East, and died in the 1920s in California. He took pictures of buildings, people, some scantily clad women and a few sentimentalized nudes. His bedroom, which he photographed, had reproductions of artworks featuring nude women on the walls. He appears to have been more active than talented; he may have had a long-term relationship with a non-Mormon he did not marry; and he does not seem to have been active in the Church of the Latter Day Saints (LDS). These add up to the interesting fragments of a life: chaotic, contradictory, and impenetrable. Why was a man who did not express strong religious beliefs hired to take official photograph of so many of the LDS's spiritual leaders? What, if anything, do his risqué pictures tell us about late nineteenth-century sexuality? Was there an agenda informing Johnson's boosterish impressions of Salt Lake City? Did he choose stereoscopy for a reason? As the written evidence is thin, Campbell reads Johnson's photographs in search of answers, using what she sees as the main current of Mormon religious history to inform her interpretation.
Campbell believes that a concerted and systematic effort was made in the late nineteenth century to transform Mormonism from a radical, mystical sect in which people could attain eternal salvation through polygamy to one in which they worked in more conventional ways toward exaltation in the afterlife. Art played a major role in that transformation, as the Saints “increasingly adopted aesthetic strategies to fight for a type of national toleration and, ultimately, assimilation” (44). Campbell sees Johnson's bland photographs as conscious contributions to this project. The fact that his erotic images lack distinctiveness is evidence that the exotic and perverted sexuality “Gentiles” saw in Mormonism was being recast into something more familiar to monogamous Americans. His maudlin street views demonstrate that Mormons wanted to make their businesses and public buildings look like everyone else's. For this interpretation to work, we have to assume that polygamous Mormons had a different aesthetic sense and a different erotic impulse from other people. But Campbell does not establish that early Mormons, for all their unusual beliefs, were unconventional in the clothes they wore, the art they preferred, their image of success, or the sex they engaged in. Without the evidence to show a change, the “strategy” may have just been business as usual.
Campbell's approach is quirky and she has a good eye for the bizarre. But the quirkiness is superficial, contained by an impulse to dissect, diagnose, and reduce. Fittingly, even the prurient interest aroused by the title is turned back on itself. Only two chapters deal with anything approaching eroticism, and Johnson's photographs do not reveal anything specifically Mormon in their winging sensuality. Since Campbell does not believe that the subjects of Johnson's sexy pictures were Mormons or that he sold these photos to Mormons, one isn't really sure where the “erotic Mormon image” comes into it.
Oddly, the subjects no one photographed—the mystical, unfathomable converts to the early faith—produce Campbell's loftiest reflections. In the last chapter, she dwells on a variety of photos and paintings that show how subsequent generations lost touch with early Mormonism. Once again, Campbell imputes a change based only on her reading of the endpoint of the trajectory. Johnson pops in and out of the book through its latter stages. After disappearing for a couple of chapters, the photographer reappears toward the close as a fragmentary reflection in a mirror, standing on a table in his new home in California. As one might expect, the uninspiring snapshot is subjected to high-flown interpretation.
