In recent years scholars have turned their attention to the cultural and intellectual relations between the nations of Europe and the western hemisphere, and not simply limiting their attention to trade, immigration and diplomacy. The exchange occurs with ideas, disease, and agricultural products. A book by Karen Kupperman, The Atlantic in World History (2010), summarizes the scholarship of the Atlantic world. Fojas and Guevarra, in this collection of essays, have also turned their attention to the western hemisphere, but instead of looking east they look west to the Pacific and Asia. The essays focus on Latinos, the United States (including Hawaii), Asians and the peoples of the Pacific. These are interesting essays about various aspects of Transnational Crossroads, but limits of space make it impossible to consider these fifteen essays (especially in detail) and if I do not give proper attention to some, it does mean that they are unworthy.
Some essays are heavy on jargon and others use only a few sources. Claudia Sadowski-Smith, for example, employs novels in the discussion of Chinese immigrants. The discussion is suggestive but rests basically on three novels. Just how influential were these books? Were they revealing of how large numbers of Americans thought? Reliance on novels and literature can be difficult. One would like to know how many copies were sold and where.
Another case of limited sources is the interesting essay by one of the co-editors, Camilla Fojas, who examines travel books after the United States secured an empire in the Philippines, Puerto Rico, Hawaii, and Cuba. She relies heavily on Jose de Olivares and Charles Morris, and again it is not certain how important the books were, but her approach is certainly suggestive about how Americans thought about the emerging American empire. The author is aware of the limits of the evidence she presents and she gives a generally convincing, nicely written case about American imperialism and colonialism after 1900. She notes that travel books were important because these writings “were essential to the popular understanding of the new role of the United States since few North Americans knew anything about the Philippines, Cuba, and Puerto Rico and had only a limited view of the Hawaiian islands” (58). One might also note that the guides accepted the basic racial view of the day and the belief that American capitalism was needed in these new islands.
One of the strongest essays is by Erika Lee on the “Yellow Peril” in the United States and Peru. After noting the hostility to Japanese immigrants that grew almost upon their arrival, she discusses the anti-Japanese movement that led to a ban first on unskilled immigrants and then eventually on nearly all Japanese in 1924. Canada had also restricted Japanese immigration by 1928. Once the Japanese were blocked from entering the United States and Canada, Latin America, especially Peru and Brazil, in part picked up the slack as Japanese migrants headed there in the late 1920s and early 1930s. White immigrants were preferred by the governments of Latin America, but Asians did not face significant hostility until the 1930s, the era of the Great Depression.
In the 1930s racism reared its ugly head against the Japanese newcomers. The immigrants were increasingly seen as a menace by the public and the government. As a result the government of Peru enacted anti-Japanese laws in the 1930s, restricting entry and limiting their rights in Peru. Riots against the Japanese also erupted in 1940. Then came World War II. The United States invited Peru and other Latin American nations to send dangerous enemy aliens to the Untied States for internment. As a result 2,118 Japanese in Latin America were interned in the United States during the war. Eighty percent hailed from Peru.
Not all of the essays deal with conflict. Rudy P. Guevarra Jr. reminds the reader of the cooperative efforts of some Asians and Mexicans to form unions. Although both Filipinos and Mexicans faced considerable hostility, especially in the 1930s, their efforts for unionization were not entirely a failure.
One whole part of the book deals with the American Pacific, especially Hawaii. The authors deal with the native Hawaiian population and their struggles for recognition, including issues of citizenship and land rights. Among some Hawaiians the election of President Barack Obama as the first nonwhite President is seen as a cause for celebration. It has also prompted some politicians to proclaim the beginning of a “post-ethnic” society. But as Maile Arvin writes, for native Hawaiians the celebration is “problematic for several reasons, including the continued erasure of their culture and lack of recognition of Hawaiian political claims for land, nation, and even identity” (240). And with time the claims of native Hawaiians become weaker, largely due to the forces of assimilation.
In sum, these essays cannot answer all questions about an emerging field, especially in view of the fact that many deal with narrow issues. Nonetheless, by turning our attention west they are a good beginning in an area that will expand.
