Rural Mozambicans are both citizen and subject (in the sense of Mahmood Mamdani) and this book shows how rural institutions try to take account of various kinds of authority and history and their changing interactions. People accept kinship, cultural and spiritual relations and thus are subject to societal norms and authority figures with various forms of reciprocity, responsibility and punishments – sometimes violent – for transgressions. But they are also citizens of a democratic state with a legal and judicial system which, at least in urban areas, gives them a different set of rights and responsibilities. Conflict resolution in rural areas is semi-formal and can be seen as ‘customary’, but only in the sense that custom is changing rapidly.
In just 30 years Mozambique went through colonialism, socialism, a brutal apartheid-imposed civil war, and finally what Juan Obarrio calls ‘the rule of law in the state of structural adjustment’. Initially chiefs and clans heads were part of the colonial administration, then after independence they were replaced for Frelimo secretaries, then sometimes replaced to local warlords, and now chiefs have been reinstated and made part of the state administration system. But leaders of both Frelimo (which remains the ruling party) and Renamo (the guerrilla movement which became the main political opposition) now also have authority. Often these people were chosen from the same local elite families. Rural Mozambicans initially were subject to arbitrary colonial administration, then socialist People's Tribunals which tried to replace colonial and ‘traditional’ justice system with a modern and more fair systems, then rough military justice, and now a mixed system with a market-oriented legal structure.
Tradition and custom are hugely malleable and rapidly changing, but Obarrio argues that in rural and peri-urban Nampula province where he did his research in 2003–4, kinship relations and responsibilities, matrilineal systems, beliefs in a spirit world, and formalised beliefs in Islam or Christianity all continue. Part of his fieldwork was to look at People's Tribunals, which were the lowest level of the socialist legal system (effectively magistrates' courts) but which continue as a form of ‘customary’ court even though they have no legal standing. At the time of the fieldwork they remained important locally in dispute resolution and his case studies show how these courts work with the whole range of local authority figures – police, Frelimo and Renamo leaders, local Muslim leaders, clan heads and others – while also maintaining the framework of the formal state legal system.
The theoretical parts of the book are overwritten and repetitive, perhaps reflecting the book's very long gestation. But the fieldwork and stories are fascinating and amply justify his argument that a new form of ‘customary citizenship’ has developed in rural Mozambique.
