Robert Olson is a well-known expert on Ottoman Turkish–Iranian relations and the history of Kurdish nationalism and politics. The book under review is in various ways a continuation of his earlier works, The Kurdish Question and Turkish–Iranian Relations: From World War I to 1998 (1998) and Turkey's Relations with Iran, Syria, Israel, and Russia, 1991–2000 (2001), and numerous articles. As in his previous works, Olson examines Turkish–Iranian relations through the lens of the “Kurdish question.” The book is composed of recent articles by Olson published in various journals and various chapters of his earlier books.
The book consists of eight chapters. The first chapter examines relations between Turkey and Iran from the Iranian Revolution to the toppling of the Welfare Party in Turkey in 1997. The second chapter is devoted to the six crises between Ankara and Tehran that occurred from 1997 to September 2000. The third chapter focuses on major developments in Turkish–Iranian relations (restoration of diplomatic relations, the Taliban and Ocalan affairs, issues concerning northern Iraq) from 1997 to 2000 that relate to the six crises discussed in the previous chapter. Chapters 4 and 5 examine the geopolitics of the Caspian Sea, Azerbaijan nationalism, and the Kurds and northern Iraq in Turkish–Iranian relations throughout 2000–2002. The sixth chapter discusses Iraqi issues and their implications for the two governments before the U.S. invasion of Iraq in 2003. Chapters 7 and 8 are devoted to Turkey–U.S. and Iran–U.S. relations during the first months of 2003, as well as the results of the U.S. invasion of Iraq and its implications for Turkey and Iran.
The book aims to survey a quarter century of relations between Turkey and Iran. It does not attempt to cover all aspects of Turkish–Iranian relations. Instead, it focuses on the influence of the “Kurdish question” on both countries and in northern Iraq, on issues of Azerbaijani nationalism, on Islamist politics, and on the Caspian Sea.
Olson accepts Steven R. David's “omnibalancing” theory in international relations as the best tool to understand the foreign policies pursued by Turkey and Iran. Omnibalancing theory stresses the external–internal threat of the transnational Kurdish (and Azeri) question(s), in addition to the powerful challenges from the Kurds in Iraq to the two neighbors. Olson also employs a method from R. Hinnebusch and A. Ehteshami's book, Syria and Iran: Middle Powers in a Penetrated Regional System (1997), invoking characteristics of midlevel powers to explain Turkey's and Iran's foreign policies.
The book offers three main theses. First, both in Turkey and Iran, the ideologies that fueled their respective politics for the past twenty-five years were constantly challenged throughout this time. At the end of this period, Ankara seems to have proven to be ideologically stronger and more flexible than Tehran. Second, in terms of the geopolitical competition between Turkey and Iran, Turkey is in a much stronger overall position than Iran. Third, Olson argues that by mid-2003, Turkey had definitely strengthened its relations and its geopolitical presence in the Middle East, Caucasia, and Central Asia in relation to Iran. After the United States invasion of Iraq, Turkey has the advantage. Furthermore, because Olson still considers Iran to be an obstacle to the creation of a new Middle East, he predicts and foresees “regime change” in Iran.
The book has some weaknesses. First, although the scope of the book is from 1979 to 2004, only forty pages of the book describe the years from 1979 to 1997. Second, Olson generally uses newspaper material but ignores (except in chap. 1) other primary and secondary sources, including memoirs, think tank reports, journal articles, diplomatic sources, and the flowering Turkish foreign policy academic literature. Among the newspapers, he most often cites Hürriyet. Although Hürriyet is a very important newspaper in Turkey, it is problematic to use only this newspaper in order to understand the complex nature of Turkish internal and foreign policy and especially Turkish–Iranian relations and the Kurdish question. Third, Olson has employed Turkish sources (sources produced in Turkey) much more than Iranian sources. Therefore, the book primarily seems to be a survey of Turkey's relations with Iran rather than a study of their mutual relations. Fourth, there are some mistakes in the text—the spelling of Turkish names, the listing of titles, and in translations—that easily could have been avoided.
Despite these shortcomings, the book fills a gap in the literature. It is recommended as the only book on this subject that presently exists.
