Margaret Kartomi's Musical Journeys in Sumatra, an ethnomusicological survey of Indonesia's largest island, documents the diversity of Sumatra's local musical traditions in the context of its history, geography, ethno-linguistic groups, and religion. Through musical analysis and rich, thick description drawing on extensive ethnographic field research, which was primarily conducted during the 1970s and 1980s with her husband Mas Kartomi, she situates the arts of Sumatra in their sociocultural contexts. The main purpose of the book is to document, explain, and bring public and scholarly attention to the traditional arts of Sumatra—including the island's historically rich and diverse practices of music, dance, theater, storytelling, and martial arts—while also speaking to current scholarly issues, such as gender and Islam.
The book is organized into a preface and fourteen chapters, and Kartomi uses geography as a grid for mapping Sumatra's musical traditions. Chapter 1, “Sumatra's Performing Arts, Groups, and Subgroups,” introduces the book's contents, including a justification of its organization by geography. She writes, “We found that constructs of a group's artistic identity were related not only to its music, dance, and lingual factors but also its geographical terrain: whether its members lived in the mountains, the plains, or upstream, middle-stream, and/or downstream reaches of the many rivers” (pp. 1–2). Chapter 1 also introduces several of the book's major themes and topics: identity, ritual and ceremonies, religion, foreign contact, musical instruments and ensembles, dance, social class, gender, and education in the performing arts.
Chapters 2 through 14 divide the rest of the book into four parts, each of which begins with a concise introduction. In addition to introducing the influence of Islam on the island, an important theme that resonates throughout the book, part 1, “West Sumatra and Riau,” reveals both the distinct characteristics and the interrelated stylistic aspects that the Minangkabau and various Malay-speaking peoples have in common, such as the use of pantun quatrains, which are poetic forms full of allusions and parables found in many Malay genres. Part 2, “South Sumatra and Bangka,” highlights ways in which Sumatra's topography reflects the distribution of musico-lingual subgroups, and how politics, religious philosophy, and local customs or adat shape the region's expressive forms. Examples include famous legends and song-tales in chapter 7, “South Sumatra,” and the power and paradoxes of music, war, and nationalism in chapter 8, “The Wartime Creation of Gending Sriwijaya,” which highlights the province's official song. In chapter 9, “The Island of Bangka,” Kartomi discusses the various musical traditions, such as Chinese temple ritual music, that reflect the diverse groups and subgroups of this island.
In Part 3, “North Sumatra,” traversing forests, coastal plains, and vast highlands, Kartomi continues to emphasize the ways in which people connect with each other, ancestors, and the environment through music. This section highlights two primary musico-lingual groups: the Coastal Malays and the Batak. In chapter 10, “From Singkil to Natal,” Kartomi shows how musical traditions can reflect a combination of cosmopolitan influences, from Arab to Portuguese. Chapter 11, “The Mandailing Raja Tradition in Pakantan,” stresses the importance of interrelated musical, ritual, and bardic traditions in passing down adat through the generations, including pre-Islamic, dualist philosophies retained through these traditions.
In Part 4, “Aceh,” Kartomi discusses the musical traditions of one of the region's most important historical power centers as it evolved from a wealthy seventeenth-century sultanate to its present status as an Indonesian province. Islam is a significant part of the Acehnese identity, a fact that has interesting repercussions on the musical traditions, such as the changing of a musical genre known as phô from a symbol of female expression to a forbidden art form and back again. Chapter 14, “Connections Across Sumatra,” sutures the wealth of ethnographic data to the broader themes introduced at the beginning of the book. These last pages are among the book's most engaging, revealing the potential of this important ethnographic data mine and piquing the reader's interest in future research topics, such as examining the fragility of identity concepts, the place of cultural preservation through societal change, and shifting gender roles through performance analysis.
Musical Journeys in Sumatra contributes to current scholarly discussions about music and Islam in Indonesia. Along with recent works from Anne Rasmussen, David Harnish, and Timothy Daniels,Footnote 23 Kartomi's book accentuates diverse expressions of Islam and Muslim identities in Indonesia. Kartomi's work also shows how non-Muslim groups negotiate their experiences and identities in Muslim-majority societies and communities through performance.
By balancing an impressive level of regional detail with an overall sense of Sumatran culture, this book appeals to a general audience interested in Sumatra, but especially to scholars and students of ethnomusicology, history, and anthropology. The book contains a great deal of musical terminology, yet is accessible to the non-music scholar with its analysis of expressive cultures in relation to sociopolitical changes through history and human migration. Included with the book is an easily accessible website, which archives audio and audio-visual field recordings of the genres discussed. Furthermore, each chapter reads like an essay unto itself, a layout that is ideal for assigning chapters as part of a course. With straightforward maps and tables, a glossary, and appendices containing supplementary language, historical, and musicological information, Kartomi's work is both an extensive general reference and an engaging set of probing essays.
Musical Journeys in Sumatra is an important account of traditions as Kartomi experienced them through her encounters with individual teachers, performing arts schools, cultural festivals, rituals and ceremonies, and individuals passing time. Based on these experiences, she brings the diversity of Sumatra's musical traditions into focus, presenting them as inextricable from their environments and interrelated cultural groups. Kartomi's impressive compendium of data, combined with engaging scholarship, is an important contribution to Asian studies, one that will likely inspire many students and scholars to think about Sumatra in new ways through its history of expressive culture and performance.
