This book makes a valuable contribution to our understanding of gender norms and how they shape the dynamics of political recruitment. Meryl Kenny addresses the question: How do political parties encourage or inhibit women’s access to political office? The author’s central argument is that previous research on women’s political recruitment undervalues the extent to which gender norms alter the supply and demand of female candidates, and previous research utilizing the supply-and-demand approach often oversimplifies the complexities of the model. To address these shortcomings and to advance the current literature, Kenny adopts a feminist institutionalist approach. She builds on the conventional supply-and-demand model of political recruitment by highlighting the ways in which gender norms and the nuances of political institutions structure the candidate recruitment process. She brings to bear considerable empirical evidence to illustrate the utility of her argument by combining a macro-level analysis of candidate selection and institutional reform in postdevolution Scotland with a micro-level case study of the candidate selection process in the Scottish Labour Party at the constituency level. As such, this book represents an important advancement for scholars studying women’s political recruitment—particularly for those who are interested in understanding recruitment through a feminist institutionalist lens.
In an effort to move our understanding of women’s political recruitment forward, the author provides a review of the conventional candidate selection and political recruitment literature. In doing so, Kenny offers a theoretical critique of Pippa Norris and Joni Lovenduski’s supply-and-demand model (see Political Recruitment: Gender, Race and Class in the British Parliament, 1995). She contends that while the supply-and-demand model offers a useful framework for evaluating selection and recruitment, the model has two principal shortcomings. First, the conventional model does not adequately consider how gender norms shape the political recruitment process. Second, research on political recruitment that applies the supply-and-demand framework fails to sufficiently account for the nuances developed in the original argument. As Kenny explains, these nuances are important to consider because “parties may select their candidates on the basis of subtly gendered criteria, which shapes the available supply of female candidates and may also result in women selecting themselves out of the process” (p. 23). For example, when leaders attempt to identify quality candidates, they may place more value on male attributes and masculine characteristics; this shapes both the supply and demand of female candidates. Since there are likely fewer female than male candidates who possess male attributes, the supply of “quality” female candidates may be low. Moreover, if parties privilege masculine characteristics, this also reduces the demand for female candidates. Yet previous research does not account for these gendered norms in the recruitment process. These limitations in extant research have restricted our understanding of the ways in which gender shapes political recruitment and may provide incomplete explanations of women’s numeric underrepresentation.
In light of these limitations, Kenny maintains that a feminist institutionalist approach—one that “integrates insights from feminist and new institutional theory”—is needed to advance our understanding of political recruitment (p. 9). This approach explicitly acknowledges that gender is a key aspect of political recruitment and recognizes that the formal and informal institutions that define political recruitment are gendered. It emphasizes the role of institutions, institutional continuity, and institutional change. In particular, the book stresses the need to examine “incremental and internal processes of change” in an effort to fully appreciate the gendered nature of political recruitment (p. 10).
The author argues that adopting this approach establishes gender as a central dimension of political recruitment. In doing so, Kenny contributes to the small but bourgeoning body of literature that bridges the gap between feminist scholars and institutionalist research. She argues that in order to understand the political recruitment process and how it shapes women’s numeric representation, scholars must consider gendered power inequalities in politics and the continuity and change of deep-rooted gender norms over time. Political institutions have long been male dominated; men established the rules of the game and structured institutions to benefit those in power (i.e., men). This privilege serves to perpetuate the gendered power structure. As a result, if scholars want to understand the gendered aspects of political recruitment, it is essential to understand the complexities of individual institutions.
Kenny evaluates the utility of this argument using a case study of candidate selection and recruitment in the Labour Party in postdevolution Scotland. She employs theory-guided process tracing and draws on 15 in-depth interviews to identify the gendered dynamics of the political recruitment process. The multimethod (both qualitative and historical) analysis represents another unique contribution of this research. She focuses on regional politics to examine how multilevel settings and newly established institutions both foster political openings for potential female candidates and impose constraints on them. The constituency-level analysis is necessary in order to shed light on the ways in which informal institutions are gendered and how difficult it is for potential female candidates to surmount obstacles posed by entrenched gender norms. Where it would be extremely difficult to identify these nuanced and complex aspects of institutions in a large-n analysis, the single case study is ideal for illuminating these features in the political system. The analysis is very well done and should serve as a model for students who seek to carry out micro-level case studies. Additionally, the interview evidence brought to bear in the analysis provides particularly persuasive support for, and examples of, the ways that implicit gender norms shape the political recruitment process. The compelling use of interviews and the meticulous process tracing represent a major strength of the book.
While the author’s analysis is well executed, provides detailed insights into the gendered nature of political recruitment, and is appropriate for this study, the micro-level analysis represents one of the challenges of case study research. In particular, the author acknowledges that there are some limitations to the generalizability of the research. As such, readers should carefully consider the conclusions from this research to discern how factors present in other institutional contexts, but not in postdevolution Scotland (or vice versa), might modify women’s pathways to power. Indeed, the goal of this book is not to generate a general theory of politics; instead, the core of this research is the recognition that the nuances of institutions—which are highly variable across space and time—structure the supply and demand of female candidates.
Political Recruitment provides a thorough critique of the state of the political recruitment literature. Norris and Lovenduski articulate the case for a feminist institutionalist approach to studying women’s recruitment. Gender and Political Recruitment provides a nuanced theoretical framework, along with an in-depth case study of women’s recruitment in postdevolution Scotland in an effort to provide new insights about the ways in which gender and institutions influence women’s access to public office. Kenny’s book will be particularly useful for scholars who are interested in the micro foundations of instructions and how they shape political leadership, for scholars interested in feminist research, and for those studying political recruitment more generally.
