At a time when mobilisation against the Tía María mining project persisted for more than two months, and countless attempts to get negotiations under way have failed, it is clear that all parties involved need to understand the processes underlying natural resource conflicts in Peru. This book makes an important contribution towards this by using Peru as a case study to examine the relationship between economic liberalisation, democracy and protest.
More specifically, the research questions that guide the book concern the political conditions that help explain the national variation of protest across countries, the subnational variation of protest within democracies and the impact of protest movements on their environment. Reviewing the literature, Arce identifies two competing views: depoliticisation, which emphasises the disorganising effects of economic liberalisation that undermine collective action under democracy; and repoliticisation, which argues that collective action in the aftermath of economic liberalisation simply changes, rather than vanishes.
Building on the social movement literature, the author proposes a political process model combining the analytical frameworks of political opportunity structures, resource mobilisation and framing processes as one which best explains social mobilisation and protest. When tested against cross-national data and cross-regional data within Peru, the model confirms the repoliticisation hypothesis and the role of political conditions in generating protest and conflict.
When Arce employs the Cross-National Time Series dataset for the Latin American region to compare levels of strikes and protests from 1980 to 2004 he identifies two waves of protests: against the austerity measures of the 1980s and following the deepening of economic liberalisation policies at the end of the 1990s, indicating that the repoliticisation effects of economic liberalisation under democracy are widespread. However, when the presence of democracy is employed to explain variations in protests within Peru it overlooks the high degree of heterogeneity and complexity and underestimates the effects of subnational mobilisation on national politics.
By analysing an original dataset of protests in Peru from 1980 to 2010 he examines the role of political opportunities, the first component of the political process model, in explaining protest in two steps. First, he finds that there is a close relation between political protest and democracy in Peru over the period, suggesting that it is political liberalisation rather than economic liberalisation that inspires protest. However, since this does not explain why apparently similar resource-abundant subnational units within the same national democratic regime have different levels of protest, he then examines the relationship between resource wealth, political conditions and protest across Peru's 25 regions and finds that political fragmentation, defined as the number of political parties competing in regional elections, is more closely associated with protests than a variety of indicators of mineral wealth. This leads him to conclude that ‘the empirical results show that regional politics affect protest activity, but in a manner opposite to what advocates of decentralisation had anticipated. The presence of weak regional parties, rather than improving decisions over resource governance, led to the escalation of protest activity as a mechanism to influence those who govern’ (p. 64).
The second half of the book presents a detailed description and analysis of three emblematic conflicts: the Tambogrande and Yanacocha mining projects and the Amazonian indigenous protests that culminated with the massacre in Bagua. These case studies show how strategic framing allowed opposition groups to build associational power (organisational capacity) and collective power (coalitional capacity). In the author's own words, ‘insofar as political conditions were favourable, both framing processes and resource mobilisation transformed localised, segmented outbursts against resource extraction into larger opposition movements that affected national-level politics’ (p. 65).
Through this combination of methodologies and data sources Arce sustains his assertion that political conditions are central to anti-market mobilisations. His cross-national analysis illustrates the moderating role of democracy in shaping societal responses to economic liberalisation, and how economic liberalisation in democracies stimulates the repoliticisation of political activity. Thus he contracts those who argue for the peaceful coexistence of free markets and democracy.
His detailed analysis of the Peruvian situation leads him to conclude that ‘the fragmentation of [political] parties in Peru impairs the mechanism of responsiveness that are typically associated with political competition and creates incentives for the use of confrontational, disruptive strategies to influence those who govern. Thus, while subnational elections are highly competitive, competition does not enhance government or policy responsiveness; rather, it is associated with higher levels of subnational political protest’ (p. 120). Finally, his analysis presents a rigorous test of the political process model, demonstrating that ‘in the presence of favourable political conditions (political opportunities), as in the context of democracy, societal actors can build a master frame linking resource extraction and injustices (framing processes), which in turn allows for the building of broad coalitions with diverse sets of actors (resource mobilisation)’ (pp. 120–1).
This book is a valuable contribution to the literature on social movements and political mobilisation because it attempts a more rigorous empirical test of the political process model than is usually the case. It also subjects the debate over the relationship between economic liberalisation and political mobilisation to rigorous empirical analysis. Finally, the combination of the analysis of inter-regional political protests within Peru and detailed studies of emblematic cases helps us to understand the political and institutional conditions that give rise to natural resource protests and political mobilisation and provides insights into some of the institutional and policy changes needed to improve the country's governance and enhance the capacities of all actors involved in such conflicts to contribute to their equitable resolution.
