Rob Skinner's new history of South Africa seeks to reposition that country within a transnational frame. This country's history, Skinner explains, is ‘marked by global contacts, exchanges and interactions’; only with a transnational perspective can we understand modern South Africa's ‘cosmopolitan nature’. The book builds on scholarship that connects imperial and global history, as well as on a much wider body of theoretical literature that is sometimes referred to as the ‘transnational turn’.
The exceptionalism of South Africa, Skinner shows, involves a paradox. It was during the later twentieth century that the country came to be imagined around the world as exceptional — the systematic racial oppression that defined apartheid operated at odds with shifting currents of world opinion. But it was also during the apartheid years that we see South Africa most obviously connected to the wider world, not least through the very belief in its exceptionality. The international anti-apartheid movement brought the politics of southern Africa into the homes of many millions of people in Europe, America, and elsewhere, while the struggle against apartheid galvanised opposition to colonialism, in Africa and beyond. South Africa was understood on the global stage as unusual or extreme at the very moment that it was most closely bound up with the politics, economics, and social movements of states across Europe, Africa, Asia, and North and South America. Indeed, there may be nowhere better than South Africa for us to consider the global dimensions of an apparently national story.
While innovative in its theoretical underpinning, Skinner's book is, however, conventional in its structure and style. We start circa 1800 and finish a little over 200 years later. It is South Africa in the world, from slavery to Jacob Zuma. Nor should readers mistake this for a research monograph. The book is based almost entirely on secondary sources and with its linear narrative and its suggestions for further reading at the end of each chapter, one imagines it being aimed principally at students of South African history. This is perhaps an opportunity missed. Despite its transnational emphasis, the book makes far less of a contribution to transnational historiography than it does to the history of southern Africa. Ironically, its obvious comparators are the same single-volume national histories that Skinner claims to be moving beyond.
This perspective is not to devalue its worth. The book is ambitious, all the more so for seeking to cover multiple scales of analysis, historiographies, and historical dimensions — politics, economics, culture, and society — within such a limited canvas. The writing is, and needed to be, tremendously concise. As a synthesis of recent scholarship, framed as a short history of South Africa with an emphasis on the wider world, it is revealing. Perhaps of most value, it forces a rethinking of the boundary lines separating national, regional, international, and global histories, boundaries that all historians, to varying degrees and with varying degrees of acknowledgement, daily reinforce.
The book has two major limitations. First, Skinner at no point attempts to define what transnationalism is and how he intends to use it. At various points, therefore, what he describes as transnational could equally well be described, and often has been, with alternative conceptual terms. During his account of the frontier wars on the Eastern Cape, for example, Skinner describes how the politics of metropolitan Britain were bound up with the militarisation of the frontier. He terms this process ‘the transnational politics of empire’. But this idea — that metropole and periphery were mutually constructed — has been an axiom of imperial history for well over twenty years. One of the book's great strengths is that it rests on such a wide reading of existing literature. But that grounding makes all the more peculiar Skinner's sometimes dated historiographical claims. The South African war, he writes, ‘is now primarily a subject of comparative imperial, international or global history’, but his references are to two edited volumes that appeared in 2000 and 2002 respectively, while publications issued since then which offer a transnational perspective on that conflict go unmentioned (39). Likewise, it is strange that there is no discussion of recent South African histories that offer an explicitly transnational perspective — such as Keith Breckenridge's Biometric State, for example, or Nick Grant's Winning Our Freedoms Together.
The second limitation relates to the framing of the book, or specifically how to conceive of a study that is genuinely transnational when the subject itself remains the nation. This problem might be unavoidable. Stephen Ellis elided this tension when he used as his unit of analysis the African continent.Footnote 9 Here, the result is a deep inconsistency. For long passages, the book reads as narrative South African history — very well rendered but nothing transnational about it — followed by a section that adds the global perspective. The book is much stronger for the period after 1945 but I am not convinced that its coverage of the preceding century and a half is as novel, or as transnational, as Skinner claims.
