Updating the trends of Mexico's agriculture as NAFTA is approximating complete trade liberalisation (2008) is a welcome subject for scholars looking at the economic and social issues of the region. The collection of articles presented in this book gives brief insights on the impact of NAFTA from different angles as it draws on case studies from a diversity of regions and crops, focusing on peasant and small-scale producers. The book thus revisits the question brought up at the start of the NAFTA debate: who are the losers and winners of this trade agreement?
The introductory chapter gives a brief description of neoliberal reforms and how sectoral and social policy has responded to organised peasant demands on the production side and to offset rural poverty in general. The economic impact is presented in chap. 1 by M. A. Gómez Cruz and R. Schwentesius Rindermann, focusing on the asymmetries among the three partners. The data and conclusions sum up the view of many Mexican scholars who are critical towards the trade agreement on the grounds that it has undermined basic crops, small farmers and fiscal income, and in general offered an uncertain future for Mexico's agriculture.
Chap. 2 by M. Chávez widens the discussion of asymmetries. Writing more in the style of an essay, the author undertakes a broad review of the institutional setting for trade and points to asymmetries among partners in major regional trade blocs. On NAFTA, the author discusses the role of the government in providing the necessary information and skills to farmers in order for them to prepare for participation in competitive open markets. This is an issue of good governance, in which the Mexican state has failed. Rather than discuss the failure of governance, however, the essay takes a public policy view of NAFTA's shortcomings in addressing the failures in transparency and accountability to stakeholders, rather than a critical political economy approach, and so ends with a list of ‘lessons learned’ and ‘policy recommendations’.
The following chapters present case studies in line with the general tone of the book, which seems aimed at underlining the positive outcomes of NAFTA as small-scale farmers link to new market ‘opportunities’, much in the style of the 2008 World Bank Development Report Agriculture for Development. These opportunities include moving into crops or livestock activities in which the farmers have a competitive advantage due to resources and labour endowment, and using local and cultural knowledge to increase productivity. Such opportunities may be enhanced by associating with private capital.
This is the case with the poultry sector in Querétaro studied in the chapter by M. Martínez and G. Real Cabello. This case contrasts the state's former role in supporting agricultural activities versus private capital: the poultry industry in Querétaro is led by a large transnational corporation, transparency and professionalism have been the rules of the game, and overall farmers consider doing business with the corporation as an opportunity and an improvement in their poultry activities. In the case of Querétaro, the introduction of private capital and reorganisation of the poultry sector, mainly targeted at the domestic market, was already an ongoing process prior to NAFTA. In other words, the existing economic and institutional setting is a key factor in providing the ‘opportunities’ for a positive performance in the regional market.
Another positive case presented by E. Patlán Martínez and J. D. Trujillo Félix is that of the production of vegetables for frozen food companies in the Bajío in Guanajuato. The frozen food industry's presence in the region, catering to the domestic market, also has a long history prior to NAFTA. The authors focus on the contractual arrangements with different types of farmers and show how each of the frozen food firms in the region, two of which are US-based and one of which is Mexican, follows differential policies and hence different contractual arrangements. The authors are balanced when pointing to the constraints and positive results for farmers dealing with agro-industries that hold the power in the playing field. Transparency and mutual trust among stakeholders are key factors in contractual arrangements.
To a great extent the literature has assessed small corn farmers as losers within NAFTA, since they are uncompetitive and have been abandoned by public support for maize cultivation. The two cases presented by J. M. Rivera argue against this, since Rivera reports two successful experiences in which small maize producers have benefited from joining up with multinationals. The first concerns the La Barca region of Jalisco, a straightforward case of contract farming with a transnational corn wet-miller. The other case is the experience of the Campo Unido project led by Monsanto, targeted at assisting poor farmers to increase yields through the use of hybrid seeds and a technical input package for corn. The project operates in the high valleys of Puebla, the state of Mexico and southern parts of Veracruz. The ‘controversial’ firm Monsanto now takes a lead in an altruistic development project that will teach small farmers ‘modern’ techniques, in close collaboration with the Fundación Mexicana de Desarrollo Rural (Mexican Foundation for Rural Development, FMDR). In both cases the author uncritically assesses a ‘win-win’ situation.
One more success story is that of organic agricultural products, analysed by L. Gómez Tovar and M. Gómez Cruz. By using the word ‘resistance’ in the title of their chapter, the authors seem to mean resistance to farming methods based on chemical inputs as farmers use local and cultural knowledge to farm organically, rather than resistance to globalisation, because as the paper shows, organic exports have grown at high rates in the last decade, largely due to the success of organic coffee on the international markets. If demands for organic and fair trade produce account for growth, however, they have little to do with NAFTA. In fact, as the authors point out, the agricultural chapter of the NAFTA agreement has no provision on organic products. A merit of this paper is that it provides a systematic overview of organic agricultural production in Mexico in the world context and within the country.
The only story of ‘failure’ is reported in a chapter on Bimbo-Coronado and goat keepers in Matehuala by J. D. Truijllo Félix Patlán, E. Martínez and R. Schwentesius. This story may seem unimportant (who remembers melty, sweet cajeta, now that children crave Nutella?), but it illustrates one of the ‘favourite’ models of the FMDR, a non-profit organisation with a say in rural development policy in the PAN regime, sponsoring cooperative arrangements as opportunities for small farmers to link to markets. In this case, the FMDR took up a role as intermediary between the milk processing plant, where cajeta was produced, and local goat producers from a marginal and resource-poor region. The project was short-lived and showed that productive alliances can thrive only as business agreements, not social projects.
Sugar is one of the most complicated and controversial products in trade agreements. G. Otero and C. Butter Flora focus on the policies followed in the three countries that comprise NAFTA, the way in which provisions on sugar have been negotiated, and the domestic impact on labour. This is a well-documented analysis that enables the reader to understand better the complexities of the sugar industry and the role of the state as a key player in shaping the industry. The case of sugar clearly illustrates that the ‘free trade’ market is a construct based on a complex set of rules and regulations.
The concluding chapter by J. M. Rivera again turns to the macro issues of the impact of NAFTA on production, rural livelihoods, agricultural and trade policy, and, again, the complex challenges to be confronted by public policy. There is a role for the state and public policy to play in creating or strengthening the institutional framework in order to enhance the participation of different actors in agriculture, with the inclusion of small producers.
Unfortunately, the conclusions to this volume do not pick up some of the interesting threads underlying the various case studies: the importance of the local context and the history of regional and local agriculture, particularly the relationships between farmers and agro-industry; the importance of farmers being able to organise; and the construction of social capital that often evolved in the decades before NAFTA. Finally, the question of ‘governance’ is raised in several chapters, as Mexico has moved away from a one-party government and is now experiencing the second term of the conservative PAN administration. Attending to the rules of free trade under NAFTA and to the rural constituency, as well as the powerful interests of agro-industry and the welfare of consumers, is not a new challenge for Mexican governments, but the balancing act is constantly being modified by new rules of governance under PAN leadership. In this book, however, this is not addressed as a problem of governance. Instead, policy issues are phrased in neutral development discourse with respect to lessons learned, shortcomings and proposals for more appropriate policies in the NAFTA context.
Finally, the editing of this volume could have been more careful, avoiding the reader having to undertake a disconcerting search for references and, in one case, a missing concluding paragraph.
