Ignatius Kung (Gong Pinmei, 1902–2000), the Catholic bishop of Shanghai, was arrested in 1955 and almost five years later, in 1960, was sentenced to life imprisonment as head of a “traitorous counterrevolutionary clique.” He was convicted of spying for the Americans and attempting to organize an armed rebellion against the People's Government. In 1979 Pope John Paul II secretly (in pectore—“in his chest”) elevated Kung to the rank of Cardinal. Kung was finally released in 1988 (after a couple of years on parole under house arrest), and probably as part of the deal went into exile, living out his days at the home of a nephew in Connecticut. With others, notably Dominic Tang (Deng Yiming), bishop of Guangzhou, Kung stands among prominent Chinese Catholics as a brave soldier of the faith under persecution (there were, of course, many more in the lower ranks, among religious sisters, and in the laity). This study by Paul Mariani is a welcome one.
Mariani's book details the communist crackdown on the Church in Shanghai prior to the Cultural Revolution. A Jesuit priest and a professor of history at Santa Clara University, Mariani draws most of his information from the correspondence of Shanghai Jesuits, especially those from the United States, who lived through these events. Mariani has also interviewed some of the actual participants, both Chinese and foreign. His vivid description of the campaign against the Church is told very much from the Church's point of view, and is commendably even-handed in discussing divisions within the Church. The title of the volume is “Church militant,” but in the description here the Church seems more like a passive victim, and Mariani may actually underplay how subversive the resistance actually was. Other writers have made a sharper point of the Church's anticommunist stance under Pius XII (even treating this as something gratuitous, without considering how actual communist parties and regimes had behaved toward the Church). Mariani may also downplay the role of the Korean War in conditioning the regime's attitude.
But be all that as it may, the Church could not have avoided persecution, given the regime's claim to total control over all aspects of life. The most prominent early target was the Legion of Mary, a youth group given to a military idiom. The regime seemingly took this language seriously, but Mariani leaves the impression that it was a bunch of kids who liked to gather for prayer meetings. The Church did attempt to organize an underground resistance, albeit a nonviolent one and designed to win freedom of action for the Church rather than to overthrow or transform of the regime. Bishop Kung, for his part, courted regime attention by ostentatiously boycotting regime-sponsored public functions as long as his priests and religious were under attack.
Some Chinese Catholics at the time likened their approach to the regime to Shaolin-style martial arts fighting, whereas the Protestants adopted a more “tai-chi” approach, yielding in order to gain advantage; and generally the regime came down much harder on the Catholics than the Protestants. It is not obvious which strategy worked better. Protestantism today is thriving in China and Catholicism is not; but the spread of Protestantism has been mainly among those congregations that declined to collaborate with the regime. Given its structure, the Catholic Church had less room for maneuver. Part of the regime program was the indigenization of the Christian churches, requiring the expulsion of all foreign missionaries and the rupture of ties with foreign missionary boards. Catholics, in addition, had to break from all “political” and administrative relations with the pope. A “Patriotic Association” would govern the Church autonomously from the Holy See, running its own affairs and appointing its own bishops: in other words, it would be under the control of the Communist Party. There was and so far remains no way completely to reconcile the claims made by either side.
Father Mariani's book is stronger on the persecution in Shanghai than on the Catholic resistance, and stronger on the resistance than it is on Bishop Kung. Kung remains a shadowy figure, seeming almost a figurehead, and the reader is hard put to say just what Kung did, besides holding office, to make himself so obnoxious to the authorities. His tormentors would no doubt have further detail.
Purely as a biography, the book may be more successful in its treatment of Kung's one-time colleague, Jin Luxian (Aloysius—later, sometimes, Louis—Jin, 1916–), a French-educated Jesuit native to Shanghai, whom Mariani interviewed for his study. The adjective most often used to describe him is “brilliant.” Jin served under another Jesuit, Father Fernand Lacretelle, in the secret organized Catholic resistance. Lacretelle was arrested and broke after two years of intense physical and psychological pressure, revealing everything he knew. Jin was arrested later as part of Kung's counterrevolutionary clique and folded like a lawn chair, later citing Lacretelle's collapse to rationalize his own. According to fellow inmates Jin continued to collaborate while in prison. He was released in 1973 and in 1985, when some forms of religious activity had again become possible, assumed the office of bishop of Shanghai under regime auspices. He toured the world bad-mouthing the pope and hobnobbing with progressive Catholic poobahs such as the President of the University of Notre Dame. In the 1990s he (in common with most other serving Chinese bishops) “secretly” returned to the acceptance of papal authority and (Kung having by then passed the age of retirement) won papal approval. Jin helped bring Chinese liturgical practice back to conformity with that of the universal church, restored orthodox teaching in the Shanghai seminary, promoted good works in service to migrant workers in the city, and issued periodic denunciations of the crassly rapacious materialism characteristic of Chinese society today. He has also kept up his somewhat self-serving criticisms of Bishop Kung (for God knows what). He has always landed on his feet and, as he approaches his hundredth year, one hopes that at the appropriate time he will land safely in Paradise, to bask for eternity in the Beatific Vision.
Jin claims that everything he did was for the good of the Church, and there is no reason to doubt he means this. Mariani finds “most perplexing” Father Lacretelle's later claim that despite his confessions, he never betrayed the Church. Given our weakness and astounding capacity for self-deception, it would be more perplexing if Lacretelle should say otherwise. Given the pressures, silence was not an option, and even Bishop Kung confessed to some absurd charges; a certain amount of equivocation may have been required to secure his release. But Kung kept true to his core principles—he is one of those who persisted to the end. It is said that moral courage is one virtue that no person may ever demand of another; and few of us, we should be thankful, are ever likely to have our moral fiber tested as was those of these three men; and each, one may assume, did the best that he could. But the behavior of Jin and Lacretelle could not save the Church, whereas Kung's could.
But (leaving God aside) Kung and other courageous priests and religious could not have saved the Church by themselves. Equally important was the general refusal of the Chinese Catholic laity to accept the leadership of those who knuckled under to the regime and who displayed overly servile submission. Things in China will probably not go smoothly in the future, and even the Holy See, in its eagerness to normalize its relationship with China, may have become overly given to compromise, viewing those Catholics who remained faithful as embarrassments and impediments. In the post-Christian West the faith is under pressure from an increasingly hostile secular culture, increasingly reinforced by political power; and one wonders if the faithful there will stand as true as their brothers and sisters in China.
