Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T11:19:50.592Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Static and dynamic stability of pendant drops

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  08 August 2023

Fei Zhang
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, PR China
Xinping Zhou*
Affiliation:
School of Mechanical Science and Engineering, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, PR ChinaState Key Laboratory of Intelligent Manufacturing Equipment and Technology, Huazhong University of Science and Technology, Wuhan 430074, PR China
*
†Email address for correspondence: xpzhou08@hust.edu.cn

Abstract

Despite the widespread occurrence of pendant drops in nature, there is still a lack of combined studies on their dynamic and static stability. This study focuses on the dynamic and static stability of elongated drops with either a free or pinned contact line on a plane. We first examine static stability for both axisymmetric and non-axisymmetric perturbations subject to volume or pressure constraints. The stability limits for volume and pressure disturbances (axisymmetric) correspond to the maximum volume and pressure of the drops, respectively. Drops with free contact lines are marginally stable to non-axisymmetric perturbations because of their horizontal translational invariance, whereas pinned drops are stable. The linear dynamic stability is then investigated numerically through a boundary element model, restricted to volume disturbances. Results show that when the stability limit is reached, the first zonal mode has a zero frequency, suggesting that the thresholds for static and dynamic stability are essentially equivalent. Furthermore, natural frequencies experience sharp changes as the stability limit is approached. Another zero frequency mode associated with the horizontal motion of the centre of mass is also revealed by the numerical results, reflecting the horizontal translational invariance of drops with free contact lines. Finally, the frequency spectrum modified by gravity is explored, resulting in the identification of five gravity-induced frequency shift patterns. The frequency shifts break the spectral degeneracy for hemispherical drops with free contact lines, leading to various spectral orderings according to polar and azimuthal wavenumbers.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2023. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Figure 1.Schematic diagrams of (a,b) pressure and (c,d) volume disturbances of partially wetting drops, with (a,c) free and (b,d) pinned CLs. The solid and dashed lines indicate the disturbance and the base state, respectively. The blue T-shaped piston is to keep the liquid pressure constant, and the red bars placed vertically and horizontally indicate the opening and closing of the valve, respectively, to switch between preserving-pressure and preserving-volume constraints. The stabilising effects of CL pinning and the volume constraint are indicated by the horizontal and vertical arrows, respectively, with stabilisation along the direction of the arrows (see also Bostwick & Steen 2015, figure 10).

Figure 1

Figure 2.Volume–pressure diagrams of gravity-free drops with free CLs ($\alpha =90^{\circ }$, red line) and pinned CLs ($R=1$, green line). Drops with free CLs and hydrophobic ($\alpha >90^{\circ }$) drops with pinned CLs are $p$-unstable (dashed line), while the hydrophilic ($\alpha <90^{\circ }$) drops with pinned CLs are $p$-stable (solid line). The hemispherical drop with a pinned CL (green point) is marginally $p$-stable. Drops with either free or pinned CLs are always $v$-stable.

Figure 2

Figure 3.(a) Schematic diagram of a pendant drop suspended from a plane under gravity $g$, and (b) the rendered perturbed surface $\bar {\varGamma }$. For comparison, a gravity-free drop (dashed line) of the same volume is drawn.

Figure 3

Figure 4.(a,d) The family of solution curves (grey lines) for the Young–Laplace equation (2.7), where five typical solution curves (black solid lines) are plotted for $\tilde {\mu }=1, 2, 3, 4, 5$. The red and blue lines denote the boundary conditions (a) $\alpha =70^\circ$ and (d) $\tilde {R}=1$, respectively, where the arrows indicate the direction of instability. (b,c,e–h) The curves of volume $\tilde {V}$ versus $\tilde {\mu }$, pressure $\tilde {P}$ versus $\tilde {\mu }$, and $\tilde {V}$ versus $\tilde {P}$ for (b,c,g) $\alpha =70^\circ$ and (e,f,h) $\tilde {R}=1$. For $\alpha =70^\circ$, the solid and dashed lines correspond to the first and second curves of CL points (yellow dots), respectively. The inset in (g) compares our results (red line) with those of Sumesh & Govindarajan (2010) ($\bigcirc$) for $\tilde {V}/{\rm \pi}$ versus $H$ with $\alpha =70^\circ$. The inset in (h) shows a pendant drop scaled by $l_c$, where $H$ is the drop height.

Figure 4

Figure 5.Volume–pressure ($\tilde {V}$–$\tilde {P}$) diagrams of pendant drops with (a) free CLs and $\alpha =70^{\circ }$, and (b) pinned CLs and $\tilde {R}=1$. Instability occurs at the TPs (hollow circles) along the counterclockwise direction. In (a), drops $\tilde {A}$ and $\tilde {B}$ are $v$-unstable and $v$-stable, respectively, but both are $p$-unstable. In (b), the drop $\tilde {D}$ with the same shape as $\tilde {A}$ ($v$-unstable), however, is $v$-stable due to the stabilising effect of the pinned CL. All gravity-free drops are $v$-stable. Here, the characteristic length $l_*$ is the capillary length $l_c=\sqrt {\sigma /{\rho g}}$.

Figure 5

Figure 6.Typical mode shapes for a pendant drop with $Bo=1.4$, $\alpha =90^{\circ }$ and $R=0.7$ in (a) cross-sectional and three-dimensional (c,e) oblique and (b,d) bottom views. The modes with free and pinned CLs are indicated by the red and green lines, respectively.

Figure 6

Figure 7.Frequency of zonal mode $\{2,0\}$ with pinned CL against equivalent radius ${\tilde {r}}= ({3{v}}/{4{\rm \pi} })^{1/3}$. The numerical results of the BE model (solid lines) are compared with the experimental results of DePaoli et al. (1992) (dots) for CL diameters $D=0.068$ cm (red) and $0.16$ cm (black). The BE results without gravity (dashed lines) are drawn for comparison. For $D=0.068$ cm, the maximum drop (yellow dot) corresponds to the horizontal TP (the right-hand inset; see also figure 5). The physical parameters used here are $\rho =997\ \textrm {{kg}}\ \textrm {{m}}^{-3}$, $\sigma =0.072\ \textrm {{N}}\ \textrm {m}^{-1}$ and $g=9.81\ \textrm {m}\ \textrm {s}^{-2}$. A sharp fall in frequency is highlighted by the cyan region.

Figure 7

Figure 8.(a,b) Maximum Bond number $Bo_{max}$ versus (a) contact angle $\alpha$ for free CLs, and (b) CL radius $R$ for pinned CLs. The black solid and black dashed lines correspond to marginally $v$-stable drops with $\alpha \geqslant 0^{\circ }$ and $\alpha < 0^{\circ }$, respectively. In (b), the red solid line corresponds to drops with $\alpha = 0^{\circ }$. (c–f) The curves of $Bo$ versus $\tilde {P}$ for (c) drop $A$ with $\alpha =0^\circ$, (d) drop $B$ with $\alpha =50^\circ$, (e) drop $F$ with $R=1$, and ( f) drop $\bar {H}$ with $R=2$. The maximum Bond numbers $Bo_{max}$ correspond to the horizontal TPs of the $\tilde {P}$–$\tilde {V}$ curves due to $Bo=(3\tilde {V}/2{\rm \pi} )^{2/3}$ (see (2.6a–d)).

Figure 8

Figure 9.Frequency of zonal mode $\{2, 0\}$ against the Bond number $Bo$ for (a) free and (b) pinned CLs. The eight points $A$–$H$ correspond to the maximum Bond number $Bo_{max}$ (i.e. drops $A$–$H$ in figure 8). The cyan region highlights a sharp fall in frequency.

Figure 9

Figure 10.Five typical contour diagrams of shift factor $S_{n,l}$. (a–c) Types I, T and II correspond to modes $\{10,0\}$, $\{6,9\}$ and $\{1,2\}$ with free CLs, respectively. (d,e) Types A and B correspond to modes $\{1,10\}$ and $\{2,0\}$ with pinned CLs, respectively. The black dashed and red dashed lines indicate $Bo_{max}$ (see figure 8) and $S_{n,l}=0$, respectively.

Figure 10

Figure 11.Types of contour diagrams of $S_{n,l}$ for modes with (a) free and (b) pinned CLs, where $n=1,2,\ldots,10$ and $l=0,1,\ldots,10$.

Figure 11

Figure 12.Numerical results of the absolute value $|\lambda ^2|$ of frequency squared versus the grid number inverse $1/N$ of the BE model for zonal $\{2,0\}$ ($\bigcirc$, $\square$) and Noether $\{1,1\}$ ($\bigtriangleup$, $\bigtriangledown$) modes. The frequencies decay to zero in power laws $|\lambda ^2| \propto N^{-c}$ with exponents $c \sim 2$ for these modes, as indicated by the lines fitted by least squares.

Figure 12

Figure 13.Breaking of the spectral degeneracy due to gravity: frequency $\lambda _{n,l}$ versus the Bond number $Bo$ for (a) $k=2$, (b) $k=3$, (c) $k=4$, (d) $k=5$, (e) $k=6$, and ( f) $k=7$, where the layer number is $n=(k-l+2)/2$. The yellow dots indicate the spectral degeneracy of free semi-drops with $\lambda ^2=k(k-1)(k+2)$ (see also Bostwick & Steen 2014, figure 2). The cyan region highlights sharp frequency changes near $Bo_{max}$.

Figure 13

Figure 14.Spectral ordering of the first 19 modes. (a,b) In the two standard orderings (equivalent to the standard PTs proposed by Steen et al.2019), modes are first sorted in ascending order of $k$, and then modes with the same $k$ are sorted in (a) ascending or (b) descending order of $l$. (c–e) Three non-standard spectral orderings with irregularities arise from the breaking of the order of (c,e) $k$ or (d) $l$.

Figure 14

Figure 15.Schematic diagram of a uniformly discretised boundary $\partial D$. There are $N$ uniform BEs for the liquid surface (red line), and $M$ uniform BEs for the solid surface (black solid line). In each element, the midpoint $P$ is employed as the collocation point, and the nodes $Q$ located at both ends define the element shape.