Theatre and performance scholars and practitioners have been critically engaged in understanding the influence of 9/11 and the U.S. global War on Terror, recording the response by New York theatres, creating and examining performances, and analyzing the performative aspects of protest and political power. Sara Brady's Performance, Politics, and the War on Terror: “Whatever It Takes” takes a performance studies approach to these enduring moments and provides an exceptional analysis of the rhetoric of the Bush administration, documentary theatre, war games and simulation, representations of torture, and—returning to the presidency—of the Obama administration's hopeful rhetoric and the assassination of Osama bin Laden. She argues that even though politics and performance have always influenced each other, since 9/11 there has been an unprecedented increase in their symbiosis, forming cycles of representation, reflection, and reiteration in the objects of her study. Her book—a vital text for scholars engaged in work on theatre and performance, as well as for those in cultural studies and American studies—provides an excellent analysis of a wide array of performances.
Brady's subtitle, “Whatever It Takes,” both refers to President George W. Bush's answer to a question about the lengths to which the U.S. government will go for domestic security, and serves as her metaphor for a “new normal” in which the extreme (or, as Giorgio Agamben would argue, the exception) has become a perpetual state. Brady argues that Bush's emphatic lack of nuance became the pervasive mode of political performance serving to support U.S. political and military policy. In Brady's estimation, performance analysis is central to understanding U.S. domestic and global policy because the extremes of “whatever it takes” culture—or what she terms “counter-insurgency culture” (66) —bring forth a heightened level of drama. This new discourse is reflected in theatre and performance that, in turn, influence politicians and policy.
Brady is at her best when unearthing those cycles of performance and politics that her text demonstrates are a pervasive and fundamental repercussion of the policies of the War on Terror. Her discussion of torture offers one such moment as she emphasizes the relationship between political policies and depictions of torture in popular culture, arguing that the justification of torture by the U.S. government resulted in an increase in images of waterboarding and other brutal techniques in popular culture, most significantly in mainstream television programming. The Fox Network's 24 became so renowned for these depictions that military guards and interrogators ritually watched the show, seeing the fictional counterterrorism agent Jack Bauer as a model for their work, and the show's plot points as further justification for torture. This blurring of performance and reality became so troubling that in 2006 there was a meeting between Human Rights First, Fox executives, and the U.S. military to alert the show's creative team to the real danger of the influence of their depictions of torture on U.S. interrogation policy. As Brady perceptively argues in her analysis, it is theatre and performance scholars who are uniquely positioned to critique when reality is theatre—to identify those moments when the real and the performed not only come together but also sustain each other through ideas, images, and affects.
Brady's work is also part of an interdisciplinary field of scholarship whose research responds to the increased use of drone warfare and the use of digital technology, games, and simulations in U.S. war policy. Her analysis of what scholars have called “the military–industrial–entertainment complex” (66) focuses on war games and the role of military simulation for play, recruitment, and training. Brady supports her argument about the reciprocal relationship between post-9/11 cultural performance and policy by demonstrating how advances in digital gaming and combat technology have made it difficult to discern the performed from the real. This is highlighted in her analysis of Virtual Iraq, a video game based on previous work with Vietnam War veterans that is used as exposure therapy for soldiers suffering from PTSD. Virtual reality becomes a method for recreating traumatic events as a means to overcome them; instead of imagining a scenario, a patient is able to return and reexperience his or her trauma, complete with the sights, sounds, and senses of that moment, but in a controlled environment. As Brady points out, there is something meaningful happening when a solider, prepared for war through simulation and gaming, experiences the reality of war, only to be assisted into reentry by reexperiencing the real through virtual reality.
In spite of the book's strengths, however, without an introduction or conclusion and with far too many examples in every chapter, Brady's promising argument is weakened by her desire to cover too much information. The brief preface does not provide a sufficient guide to the overall purpose of the text; without a solid road map Brady's well-researched and engaging book is sometimes challenging to follow. Her argument about the integral relationship between performance and policy is well documented in her examples, but there is a missed opportunity to link the larger arguments of her chapters together. Brady insightfully draws a connection between documentary-style war games and documentary theatre, demonstrating that scholars who seek to understand their roles separately would be better served to consider their popularity as connected phenomena, but since her analysis of documentary theatre falls in a different section of the text, she misses an opportunity to follow through on her own proposal. The exception to this is her excellent comparative analysis of presidential rhetoric, crafted images, and substantive differences between Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama. Brady uses her astute examination of Bush's cowboy persona, malapropisms, and depictions of traditional masculinity to investigate the performance of power enacted by President Obama, from the 2008 election to the execution of Osama bin Laden. Her argument demonstrates a prescient wisdom that locates the death of bin Laden as the moment that ruptured the hopeful image of change presented by the Obama administration, suggesting that this moment was the foundation for WikiLeaks, increased drone warfare, and the assassination of U.S. citizens abroad—and by extension, the more recent revelations by Edward Snowden about NSA surveillance.
Sara Brady's Performance, Politics, and the War on Terror: “Whatever It Takes” offers an analysis of post-9/11 U.S. culture that acknowledges the vital role performance plays in crafting the policies of the global War on Terror. Despite its need for greater synthesis of overall ideas and arguments, this book offers tremendous benefits for scholars seeking to contemplate how the War on Terror has influenced performances, both inside and outside the aesthetic frame.
