No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
The Saudi historian Uwaidah Al Juhany argues that Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab's mission, which he calls the Salafi reform movement, represents the culmination of long-term historical trends in Najd. He develops this argument from a resourceful reading of primary sources that he discusses in the Introduction. From the pre-Saudi era, he draws on four rather sketchy chronicles and fatwa collections. From the richer record of the Saudi era, he uses chronicles, genealogies, biographical dictionaries, works by Arab writers from neighboring regions, European travelers' reports, and Najdi popular poetry. The chronicles tell us about such natural phenomena as rainy years, periods of drought, famines, locust plagues, and epidemics. Al Juhany posits a correlation between these phenomena and population movements (nomadic tribes entering and leaving Najd), conflicts between nomadic tribes (over scarce grazing lands during drought or because of immigration), and the sedentarization of tribal groups in abandoned and new settlements. It is logical to posit some kind of relationship between ecology and population dynamics, but the sources are too thin to reach firm conclusions. At one point we read that drought forced nomads to settle down as cultivators (p. 88), but we later learn that droughts caused cultivators to abandon their settlements (p. 94).
Al Juhany's thesis does not rest on a specific definition of nature's effects on population. Rather, it depends on accepting the idea that Najdi oasis settlements underwent a period of social and political stress caused by an increase in the sedentary population. The sources provide two supporting indications for that idea. First, they report the revival of abandoned settlements and the creation of entirely new ones. Second, they report a growing incidence of conflict within them, and that implies that an increasing number of townsmen were competing for scarce resources. One of the book's strengths is its discussion of social structure in the settlements. Their inhabitants fell into three distinct status groups: tribal, non-tribal (khadirī), and slave. The precise origin of non-tribal townsmen is unclear. Al Juhany cites local views that they may have been the offspring of freed slaves or descendants of nomads who had been settled for so long that they lost track of their tribal ancestry. Each town was further divided between chiefly lineages and “neighbors” (jīrān) who lived under the chiefs' protection. The muscle for the chiefs came from retinues of slaves and retainers (fidawiyyūn). Power struggles took place within and among chiefly lineages for political supremacy, which carried with it control over revenues from taxes on agriculture and trade.
Al Juhany suggests that as the settled population increased, so did the number of religious specialists (ulema). Najdi sources from the 17th and early 18th centuries identify more ulema than for the earlier period, and they give the impression that the number of towns with religious judges increased from three or four to a dozen or so. The author emphasizes three characteristics of the ulema. First, study under Hanbali authorities in Damascus and Cairo distinguished the most respected scholars. Second, they specialized in jurisprudence (fiqh) because the settlements needed their expertise in Islamic law to resolve disputes. Third, the majority of ulema came from a handful of lineages with scholarly reputations. One of those lineages was Al Musharraf, the clan of Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab. To Al Juhany it makes sense that the solution to turmoil in the oasis settlements should come from a member of the estate that possessed the cultural resource—religious knowledge—to diagnose and treat society's social ills. In this reading, Ibn Abd al-Wahhab understood that the remedy was a revival of true Islam and that accomplishing this required a powerful political authority; therefore his mission developed an alliance with al-Dir

iyya's ruler, Muhammad ibn Saud. In essence, this is a secular rendering of a common Saudi historical narrative that portrays Muhammad ibn Abd al-Wahhab as a heroic figure who rescued Arabia not only from the social and political turmoil we find here but also from religious and moral degeneration.
The internal coherence of Al Juhany's argument is elegant. To put it simply, ecological factors precipitated demographic changes, and the growth of towns ushered forth both political stresses and the cultural resources—the ulema—to resolve them. The sources may not bear the full weight of this argument, but this book should spur historians to explore it further. In other respects, Al Juhany's monograph makes a significant contribution to historical scholarship on Arabia. Readers will appreciate the thumbnail accounts of tribes and towns and the maps of mountain ranges, plateaus, wadis, and sub-regions with their primary settlements. There is also a chapter that gives an overview of the region's history from the early Islamic period to the 15th century. The book is based on the author's 1983 doctoral dissertation for the University of Washington, and the text could have used some polish to eliminate repetition, update the bibliography (including the multivolume Khizanat al-tawarikh al-najdiyya edited by Abdallah al-Bassam), and correct misprints on the maps. On page 25, the map reads “Mufud” instead of Nufud; on page 28, the map reads “Al-Nihmal” instead of al-Mihmal; on page 32, the map reads “Muraymilah” and “Manfubah” instead of Huraymilah and Manfuhah. Readers unfamiliar with the subject will find it difficult to get through sections packed with the names of tribes and towns, but it is an essential work for scholars of Arabia and an accessible one for graduate and serious upper-level undergraduate students.