Melvin Urofsky's biography of Louis D. Brandeis (1856–1941) is a big book—and aptly so. Its length enables the author to cover Brandeis's many activities and achievements while illuminating his character via anecdotes and telling details.
Brandeis's early law practice was of the Gilded Age. His firm was the first in Boston to require its lawyers to have gone to law school (57). The firm also was in the vanguard of a new organizational structure: “the modern large law firm, marked by specialization and commercialization” (59).
Brandeis steeped himself in each client's business, visiting factories and poring over ledgers (50). He developed a reputation as a very skilled corporate attorney, and his practice prospered. “In 1890, at the age of thirty-four, he earned more than $50,000 a year . . . , while 75 percent of [American attorneys] made less than $5,000” (73).
Brandeis creatively crafted solutions to clients' problems. When a shoe manufacturer hired him to get the workers to accept a wage cut without striking, Brandeis studied the industry and concluded that the problem was irregular work. He advised the manufacturer to change the timing of orders to smooth out the manufacturing cycle. “No strike occurred, no wage cuts took place, the company grew more prosperous, and its workers enjoyed high and—more important—regular wages” (65). Here the Gilded Age meets the Progressive Era: Brandeis got rich and helped the manufacturer get rich while also helping the interests of labor. Not a radical, he typically sought basic fairness and reform “to forestall upheaval” (168).
Brandeis lived modestly for a man of his wealth. He explained his pro bono work:
Some men buy diamonds and rare works of art; others delight in automobiles and yachts. My luxury is to invest my surplus effort, beyond that required for the proper support of my family, to the pleasure of taking up a problem and solving, or helping to solve, it for the people without receiving any compensation. . . . I don't want money or property most. I want to be free. (154)
He also gave money to causes, family, and friends—nearly $1.5 million in his lifetime (356).
Many of the reforms Brandeis undertook were suited to his gift for mastering a mass of technical detail. This presents a challenge for the biographer. For example, the story of Brandeis's opposition to the Boston Elevated Railway Company's merger must include financing, leases, dividends, and special legislation—not plot elements one could pitch to Hollywood studios. Urofsky rises to the occasion, ably recounting this and other complex controversies (utilities, railroad mergers, railroad rates) so that a nonspecialist can follow.
Of his many reforms, Brandeis took the greatest pride in savings bank insurance, established in 1907 (179). As an alternative to the exploitive policies insurance companies marketed to working people, Brandeis devised a scheme for savings banks to handle insurance through a fund overseen by a government agency. To achieve this reform, he created the Massachusetts Savings Bank Insurance League, “one of the first modern citizens' lobbies” (174).
Brandeis's first national effort was defending protective labor legislation in Muller v. Oregon in 1908 (218). In what his wife later called his “days of knight-erranting” (437), he took on a staggering number of causes. He represented the publisher Robert Collier in the Pinchot-Ballinger affair in 1910 (254). Also in 1910, he mediated the New York garment workers' strike (243). In 1910–11, he challenged railroads' petition for a rate increase (289). In 1912, he stumped for Robert La Follette (333–34), helped to outline Woodrow Wilson's New Freedom (343), and campaigned for Wilson (351). In 1913, the Interstate Commerce Commission asked him to advise on another rate-making case (295). He helped the Wilson administration with banking and antitrust legislation (382, 384). He wrote Other People's Money (1914), “one of the major muckraking works of the Progressive Era” (323). In late 1914, he became the leader of the American Zionist movement (403), a cause in which he remained active for decades.
Brandeis served on the Supreme Court 1916–39. He joined it at the height of legal classicism, “a jurisprudence reflecting the predilections of the Gilded Age—protection of property rights, fear of government intervention in the market, and disdain for labor and minority rights” (592). Through persuading his colleagues when he could and dissenting when he could not, Brandeis moved the Court toward an approach that would take account of “the real world” (594). In many of his dissents in the 1920s, Brandeis argued for judicial restraint because he believed that policy should be determined by the people's elected representatives (599).
In addition to discussing Supreme Court opinions, Urofsky offers sketches of Brandeis's work habits and his relationships with his clerks and his fellow justices. During his time on the Court, Brandeis advised politicians, corresponded with academics, and was active in Zionism. “Neither Brandeis, the press, nor most of the men and women he spoke with during the 1930s considered his advice a breach of judicial ethics” (703).
Urofsky is blessed with a subject who wrote very well, and he makes the most of it. The book is enlivened by many wonderful quotations.Footnote 1 Urofsky himself writes well and engages in a dialogue with other authors, discussing and disputing their interpretations.
Urofsky controls his narrative by grouping activities thematically. Brandeis could stay on top of railroad regulation, labor unrest, litigation, and national politics simultaneously, but no ordinary reader could. The advantage of this biography over narrower works looking at only one area of Brandeis's activities is that it shows the themes that united, for instance, Zionism and progressivism or practicing law and judging. It is a welcome addition to the literature on the period, as well as a portrait of a remarkable man.
