One of the challenges of teaching material about the formative period of Islam lies in the uncertain knowledge we have of the period. It is difficult to avoid the temptation to rely, for the purposes of coherency, upon the smooth narratives created by later Muslim and non-Muslim scholars. One needs to continually remind oneself and one's students how little solid evidence dates back to the first century of Islam. What makes Suleiman Ali Mourad's Early Islam between Myth and History so interesting and valuable is the attention it pays to the murky space of that uncertainty. Although Mourad is not uninterested in historical facticity, his methodology takes us to the heart of what obscures it. His detailed and systematic approach to uncovering errors, contradictions, biases, deceptions, and omissions in the work of medieval and modern scholars provides a model for working through the historiographical layers surrounding early Muslim figures of great symbolic importance. He succeeds not only in presenting us with what is undoubtedly the most accurate information we have to date on the life, thought, and works of al-Hasan al-Basri, but he also succeeds in critically examining the role of scholars in creating, developing, and maintaining his legacy.
Al-Hasan al-Basri is an apt choice for this kind of study, given the significance of the contested issues the writings and sayings attributed to him address. After looking at the source material for basic information on al-Basri's life and career, Mourad examines the evidence for his being a foundational figure in asceticism and mysticism and his theological position in the controversy over free will and predestination. What distinguishes Mourad's work from previous scholarship on al-Basri is its thoroughness. The bibliography of nonmodern sources runs over twelve pages, and this exhaustive research is amply demonstrated in analysis that seems to effortlessly cross genres of writing and centuries of scholarship. Although setting a daunting standard for the rest of us, the payoff for this comprehensiveness is clear. Mourad is able to construct his textual evidence from a solid comparison of names mentioned, language use, terminology, and style of argumentation. This enables him to assess the authenticity of the writings attributed to al-Basri and to state with assurance that such works as the treatise on asceticism to caliph ʿUmar II b. ʿAbd al-ʿAziz and the epistle against the predestinarians to caliph ʿAbd al-Malik b. Marwan are examples of what may have been a much larger phenomenon of pseudepigraphy in medieval Islam.
Mourad's claim that groups competing for legitimacy engaged in a process of glorification and sanctification of al-Basri is not a new one. Rather, his contribution here is in the establishment of a timeline for this process. The dating of each piece of evidence leads, for example, to the discovery that al-Basri is not portrayed as a significant figure in the formation of Islamic mysticism until the late 10th century. It enables Mourad to compare proto-Shiʿi and proto-Sunni sources in order to come to a tentative conclusion on al-Hasan's position in the freewill and predestination controversy. Of most importance, however, is that Mourad's careful analysis of his meticulously gathered material allows him to suggest that al-Basri's role in formulating particular trends was not a historical one but rather a symbolic one created as a posthumous legacy by others.
The appendices to the book will greatly increase its value to scholars of the formative period as well as students of early classical Arabic. The Arabic for all of the quotations attributed to al-Hasan al-Basri mentioned in the text are reproduced here, including the entire epistle to ʿAbd al-Malik from several sources. There is also an appendix listing the full names and religious and political inclinations of over sixty of al-Basri's students. Although the usefulness of the book will primarily be for graduate students, it can be shown to interested undergraduates as a superior example of how textual analysis of the formative and classical periods of Islam is done. On this basis, I would recommend it as a possible addition to any college or university library where Islamic studies is taught.
