For the countries of Central and Eastern Europe, more so than anywhere else, explaining changes in human rights–related policies requires research at the disciplinary intersection of international relations, social movement theory, and comparative public policy. Janet Johnson's book on gender-violence reforms in Russia masterfully proves how rich and rewarding such analysis can be in explanatory terms.
Gender Violence in Russia examines the impact of international interventions on the reform of gender-violence policy and practice in Russia during the last two decades. Johnson compares three different kinds of international interventions, as they play out in three different policy fields subsumed under the wider field of gender violence: sexual assault and rape, domestic violence, and trafficking in women. Although a case study of Russia, the book speaks to international relations, public policy, gender and politics, and social movement scholars; scholarly specialists working on the post-Soviet space; and practitioners and activists involved in transforming human rights, and particularly gender regimes, in the post-Soviet region. It provides insights into the ways that successful policy change related to gender occurs and into the role of different international and domestic actors in fostering or stalling such change.
Two decades ago, gender violence as a violation of women's rights was dynamically rising on the global human-rights agenda to become the prime consensual women's rights issue across the North and South. In the meantime, gender violence was largely absent from the policy and transformation agenda of countries in the post-Soviet arena, Russia included. Yet by the new millennium this had changed, and increasing mobilization, awareness, and policy practice related to different forms of gender violence have since emerged in most countries of the region. Gender violence has become the women's rights issue most widely addressed by activists in the region. The fast pace of change can partly be explained by factors discussed by gender and politics literature in relation to Western postindustrialized states. At the same time, that literature now offers an incomplete picture of the issue of women's rights.
The role of women's rights advocates and their allies within the state has proven to be important in countries of the region in ways not addressed by the earlier literature. In order to understand the activism of these agents, the policies they frame, and the impact of their actions, interventions coming from international and transnational actors must be taken into account. Research has responded to this challenge primarily by interpreting the interaction between local and outside actors as a process of unilateral, top-down transfers of rigid international norms, often neglecting the agency of domestic women's rights advocates and the importance of local political, discursive, and gender structures that serve as filters for translating and adopting those international norms.
Johnson's book makes two contributions in this context. It aids in unpacking the dynamics and multidimensionality of internationally driven policy change. The author's story is one about international intervention in the name of women, but international intervention is placed in the context and dynamics of the domestic, and its impact is examined by taking into consideration the politics around it. Secondly, the book also contributes to a better understanding of the dynamics and variability of international interventions promoting women's rights, in terms of global trends, the national politics of powerful players such as the United States, the role of authoritative norm entrepreneurs, and the specificity of the policy issue at hand.
Johnson develops an exceptionally rigorous conceptual framework for her analysis by combining comparative gender policy and international relations approaches and then refining them to respond to the specifics of the post-Soviet transition states. Her premise is that the effects of different types of international intervention regarding the development of gender violence policy in Russia can be usefully extrapolated to other contexts. Depending on how embedded the reforms are in the domestic context, how sustainable they are, as well as how aligned they remain with the global feminist objectives that initially set them in motion, the impacts of various interventions can vary enormously.
Three types of intervention are differentiated: soft, norm-based interventions operated by a “blame and shame” logic; interventions where adoption of norms is further advanced by the “carrots” of foreign assistance; and interventions operated by a logic of threats and sanctions. The three types of intervention are illustrated and compared in the book through the analysis of three subfields of gender violence: sexual abuse and rape, a field in which norm-based interventions dominate; domestic violence, where norm-based interventions combine with massive foreign assistance; and trafficking in women, where threats and sanctions are imposed by interventionist US foreign policy in order to promote policy change. International interventions for addressing gender violence rarely meet the feminist objectives in both substantive and descriptive terms. Though initiated under the aegis of the global feminist consensus, some interventions end up preempting global feminism by meeting its objectives but excluding feminists from the process; other interventions may include feminists yet result in co-optation of their objectives by other mainstream policy objectives.
Johnson's definition and operationalization of the outcome of international interventions for women is equally comprehensive. The author goes well beyond looking at policy change and includes the impact on mobilization for women's rights, the awareness of women's rights by the public and media, and the responsiveness of the state in terms of policy and practice.
The evidence assembled to provide a thick description of the Russian case study includes a wide variety of qualitative and, where available, quantitative data. It also ranges from a detailed analysis of the dynamics of mobilization for women, through analysis of public opinion data and media, to an analysis of policy changes and changes in policy practices and implementation.
The book tells us four stories. One is about the weakness of norms-based international intervention on sexual abuse and rape. It shows how prolonged and intensive efforts of transnational activists in cooperation with domestic women's rights advocates to monitor and raise awareness proved insufficient to challenge deeply rooted norms. Activism has ultimately failed to bring the desired policy change and has allowed for sexual assault to be “privatized as women's individual misfortune” (p. 92) in the context of a hostile environment.
Another story talks about domestic violence reforms. It describes how the prolonged combination of the blame and shame tactic with foreign assistance can be seen to have achieved some seemingly irreversible changes: a good balance of domestic ownership and domestic cooperation over the issue; awareness of the public and the media, even if sometimes skewed by localized traditionalist meanings; and even some changes in policy practice in which foreign assistance is no longer the only driving force.
The third story, on trafficking in women, is double edged. A master case for threat-based international intervention, trafficking proves to be, on the one hand, a success in bringing policy change and change in policy practice, more so than the other two issues. On the other hand, it fails to produce genuine ownership of the issue either by domestic mobilization or by the public and the media. The change remains a top-down process in which social transformation of gender relations as it pertains to trafficking is not touched upon.
Finally, we read a story that cuts across the entire book, one about the emergence of an internationally as well as locally connected women's movement in Russia, an active movement that is, however, frighteningly vulnerable to decreasing interest in funding by foreign-assistance programs and extremely exposed to domestic constraints, ranging from domestic support that emerged too slowly to the openly hostile environment of the Putin era.
Coupling the three types of international intervention with the three different forms of gender violence makes the book a great read. Nevertheless, the reader familiar with the politics that revolve around the three forms of gender violence may wonder to what extent the impact of the different kinds of intervention are in fact linked to the varying nature and politics of the three issues addressed. Is trafficking not most vulnerable to preemption and easiest to pursue without genuine social transformation, given its implications for organized crime and border protection? Does the fact that domestic violence can be easily tied to traditionalist views on the family as a protective institution that often also victimizes children not give a relatively fast green light to the rise of the issue? Is sexual assault not the most difficult issue to pursue in these terms, being the least available for co-optation by other objectives and the least feasible for preemption by nonfeminist actors? These questions may merit more reflection.
All in all, this book provides us with a primary argument about the success and failure of international intervention for women's rights, but it can be read in many different ways: as a story about women's movements, as multiple stories about developing policy agendas on different forms of gender violence, as a story about weak state capacity in post-Soviet transition states, or as a story of transnational feminist networking. The wealth of data presented allows all of these readings. I highly recommend this book.
