A book bearing the title Archaeology and Capitalism: From Ethics to Politics should cause great excitement for readers of a cultural property journal. The notion of property is, of course, central to capitalism and the contentious evolution of the category cultural property needs no introduction to readers of this journal. But buyer beware! The true goal of this 15-chaptered, 25-authored book is to be found in the book's subtitle, From Ethics to Politics: a critique of archaeology's ethical turn to move the conversation toward an engagement with politics. This argument is presented in explicit terms in the book's introduction, perhaps the most focused and rewarding chapter in the collection. After reminding readers of what he labels official archaeology's foundations in western capitalist modernity, Hamilakis explores and critiques the effects of the discipline's ethical turn over the past two decades. “Ethics,” he writes, has “become the decoy that can rescue us from politics” (23), an instrument that professional societies and practitioners employ when seeking to right the discipline's wrongs. For Hamilakis, the ethical turn has had unfortunate effects. Archaeologists now declare themselves apolitical professional stewards who privilege the protection of the archaeological record from looters, dealers, and developers over working in the interests of the poor and disempowered communities that are victims of global capitalism. To invert this equation, Hamilakis argues for a political ethic, a position that recognizes the contingences of ethical problems that universal codes cannot mitigate, a position that works for social justice and an end to economic inequalities.
Hamilakis's critique is refreshing for readers who have grown impatient with ethical positions that depend on national and international legal systems; or await the assumed goodwill of imperial and postcolonial governments to recognize the injustice of their ways. The case for a political ethic in archaeological praxis is explored in the remaining 14 chapters, but writers often diverge in their interests. Part Two, “Ethics in Question,” is a collection of five essays that draws out the theoretical contradictions that the archaeology and ethics discussion has produced. Bauer and colleagues challenge commonly held assumptions about repatriation and cultural property, whereas Nicholas and Hollowell present a literature review of so-called alternative archaeologies (e.g., indigenous, feminist, Marxist) but argue that archaeology has yet to achieve a postcolonial position. Riggs explores the problem of ethics and empiricism in American Southwestern archaeology, and Shepard presents a case study in development and repatriation in Cape Town, South Africa.
Part Three, “Archaeology in Capitalism, Archaeology as Capitalism,” includes six provocative essays that explore how archaeology works as an instrument of capitalism. This includes Everill's investigation of commercial archaeology in the United Kingdom and Funari and Robrahn-Gonzalez's review of public archaeology and development in Brazil. Mourad adds perhaps the most scathing essay in the entire collection, a must-read comparison charting the collaborative relationship between Near Eastern archaeologists and Western empires as recent as the 2003 invasion of Iraq. Kehoe describes how archaeology's recent quest for multiple pasts accords with capitalist modes that create identity niches for narrow consumer categories. Silberman somberly reflects on the difficulties with creating sustainable heritage destinations, and Silverman compares contrasting presentations of Peru's past in two Cusco museums, one public and one private.
Given my own involvement in Near Eastern archaeology, I was drawn to Mourad's provocative chapter, “An Ethical Archaeology in the Near East: Confronting Empire, War and Colonization.” Between a clumsy charting of archaeology's entanglement with nineteenth-century European imperialism and an interesting critique of James Henry Breasted's collaboration with the American and British military in World War I, Mourad asks a critical question: At what point are archaeologists considered combatants in armed conflicts? Using the Geneva Convention's definitions, she suggests that archaeologists who collaborated in the 2003 invasion of Iraq—providing the geographic coordinates of archaeological sites and museums before the invasion, and then cooperating with occupying forces to stop the looting and rebuild the antiquities authority—exchanged their civilian clothes for army issue uniforms. Mourad argues against this collaboration, insisting that archaeologists stake out positions as civilian intellectuals unfettered by national and institutional constraints, writing against war and violence. Thinking back to my 2003 conversations with Near Eastern archaeologists who supported the Iraq invasion, I doubt her argument would persuade them to worry less about broken museum cases and more about rising body count. After all, a liberated Iraq would give them a chance to return to their excavations in southern Mesopotamia, many abandoned since the 1980s. Whether or not one agrees with her condemnation, though, there is no denying this participation illustrates Hamilakis's complaint that contemporary archaeological ethics privileges the protection of the inanimate over the animate.
Oddly, although their actions may have been the right step in the wrong direction, the archaeologists Mourad condemns share a common aspect with many authors in this book: the willingness to set down their pens and take action to bring about the changes they believe just (and then, of course, take up the pen again to reflect on their successes and failures). In Part Four, “Ethical Futures, Emancipatory Archaeologies,” four case studies of archaeological interventions demonstrate what Hamilakis's political ethics might look like in practice. Bernbeck and Pollock discusses archaeology's role in memory making in post–World War II Germany, while Balbe and colleagues discuss their current project investigating the crimes of the Franco regime in twentieth century Spain. Ronayne writes of her collaboration with Kurdish communities, especially female members, in Turkey, who are attempting to stave off an immanent dam project that will flood their homes. But it is the final chapter, Saitta's presentation of the Colorado Coal Field War Archaeological Project, that spells out a satisfying, theoretically informed emancipatory archaeology. Transferring Dewey's notions of pragmatism to archaeological practice, Saitta suggests that archaeologists should evaluate the claims they make about the past in terms of their effects on local disenfranchised communities. This means parting ways with both empiricism and critical theory, the bourgeois sciences that university tenure committees reward, and descendent communities disparage. Disseminating their knowledge of the Ludlow massacre requires Saitta and his colleagues to reach communities through alternative channels rarely found emanating from the ivory tower, radio broadcasts, and union rallies, for instance.
The book is relatively well edited, with limited spelling and grammatical errors, and illustrated with more than a dozen figures and tables. At the very least, these case studies lead us to reflect on the ways our research serves the public good, studies to motivate our students, and stimulate seminar discussions. This collection's greatest virtue may be found in its ability to sway those few remaining constituencies who believe archaeological research has no effect on conflict and inequality in modern societies. For the choir, the rest of us who are convinced that the discipline's practices need tweaking, this book nudges us toward a day when archaeology will be made safe for the world.
