Women's Voices on American Stages in the Early Twenty-First Century is a book fueled by feminist anger, intellect, and hope. Two recent events frame Leslie Atkins Durham's analysis of Pulitzer Prize–winning playwright Sarah Ruhl and ten of her contemporaries. The first Durham mentions directly: Emily Glassberg Sands's 2009 economics thesis in which she offered concrete data to support anecdotal evidence regarding systemic gender bias in season programming. The second happened over a year after Durham's book was published. On 17 February 2014, at a gathering of Washington, DC artistic directors, women theater artists tweeted that Ryan Rilette of Round House Theatre was blaming the lack of women's work in theatre seasons on “the lack of [new] plays [by women] in the pipeline” and characterizing those existing plays as “feminist, out of date and hard to revive” (Ilana Brownstein's Storify archive of #TheSummit, 17 February 2014. https://storify.com/bostonturgy/thesummit?utm_source=embed_header). This was clearly not the fulfillment of Durham's “dream of [American] theater seasons to come” (159), filled with new and old titles from the eleven women whose body of work she painstakingly examines as commercially viable, dramaturgically inventive, and theoretically feminist.
Durham's book marks an evolution in feminist criticism from foundational titles such as Sue-Ellen Case's Feminism and Theatre and Jill Dolan's The Feminist Spectator as Critic. One element of this evolution is the lack of the word “feminism” in Durham's book title even while she conceives of this as “a feminist project” (8). The second element is her focus on parity in mainstream American theatre. Durham quotes Dolan's 2008 Theatre Journal essay that reconsiders the possibility of finding feminist values “circulating within our most commercial theatres” (5) to challenge the critique of liberal feminist theatre that was articulated convincingly in Dolan's 1988 Feminist Spectator. Durham argues that third-wave feminists have reinvigorated liberal feminist analysis through their active engagement of “a wider variety of human experience” (9) that acknowledges the “‘lived messiness'” of women's lives (10), a messiness that cannot neatly divide margin from center, mainstream from alternative, experimental from commercial.
Durham places Ruhl, “a white, heterosexual, privileged woman” (9) at the center of this analytical universe and puts her “‘beside’ women […] who identify as Asian American, African American, and Latina” (10) to give women playwrights of all backgrounds working “at the center of American theater” the “same kind of rigorous and sustained critical attention that alternative feminist theater received from scholars in decades past” (5–6). Ruhl's success should not be singular, for the dramaturgical choices and themes in her work are present in the work of other less well-known and less critically decorated writers. Durham also identifies a target audience for her book as those teaching the next generation of theatre artists, audiences, and scholars as well as those programming with those populations in mind.
In each chapter Durham constructs a two-pronged dramaturgical analysis. Along one trajectory, she examines the artistic and professional developmental processes and critical reception of Ruhl paired with two other playwrights: Joan Didion and Jenny Schwartz; Lisa Loomer and Diana Son; Young Jean Lee and Kate Fodor; Bathsheba Doran and Quiara Alegría Hudes; Lynn Nottage and Kia Corthron. On the way, she also discusses a group of creative mentors and a circuit of influential American new play development institutions that deserve their own critical analysis for how and whose creative work they seed, fuel, and sustain. Along the other trajectory, Durham dissects the dramaturgical structure of one major work from each of the artists (seven works in the case of Ruhl) with “a particular feminist analytic lens” (10). As Durham contextualizes the selected plays' structures, characters, and dynamics with the work of feminist theorists from a range of disciplines, she organizes her investigations around five central themes. Some (emotion, theology, and technology/space) I found more compellingly argued than others (economics and ecology). In the process she forwards a central claim about Ruhl's and her contemporaries' work: “whimsical” and “fantastical” are gendered terms that allow mainstream theatre and feminist critics to overlook these artists' “passionate interest in … social concerns and ethical questions” (4). By locating their feminist investments in their dramaturgy, Durham recasts those values as central to the popular success and historical significance of these artists' work.
Durham's list of women's playwrights is diverse but in a way that can feel somewhat manufactured given her stated interest in mainstream American theatre artists. It is hard to conceive of Lee's work under this heading, and the inclusion of novelist Didion seems driven by the notoriety of one piece. Durham mentions having access to Ruhl's and Hudes's scripts in development, and her reading of Water by the Spoonful is particularly compelling as she peels away the multiple layers of meaning regarding digital spaces and discourses of home that are fragmented by characters' physical separation and trauma. By contrast, her discussion of Ruined made me wonder what insights would have been possible had she put Nottage's work at the center of a feminist analysis and treated Ruhl as an artistic constellation.
Fundamentally, these musings do not diminish the book's admirable scope and insightful dramaturgical analysis. Durham illuminates an important circuit of feminist scholars whose theories reinforce and extend the intellectual value and influence of women's theatrical writing, even those plays that have been critiqued by feminist theatre scholars as successful because they “reproduce hegemonic stories and perspectives” (73). To this point, I was surprised at Durham's omission of feminist theatre/performance theorists in her dramaturgical examinations. This critique aside, as the immediate, vocal, and productive response to the #TheSummit indicates, Durham's book is essential to push back against the enduring lack of gender parity and diversity in American theatre play development, production, and scholarship. Without academic work about women playwrights to feed the next generation of student audiences and artists, who will want to see, produce, and emulate those playwrights, there will not be the critical, artistic, and commercial demand for the wide rage of women's theatre work, and it will remain stuck in the so-called pipeline.
